Hoping someone can steer me in the right direction

US Sale

I hope this request isn't too vague. I'm not necessarily looking for someone to advise me to buy something specific.

Here's my situation: I work from home, and simply don't drive much at all. A few errands per week is about it, and they're all local. I typically buy a full tank of gas 4x a year (every few months).

I currently drive a 2002 Buick Century. I bought it at Carmax in 2004, and it's been a very reliable car, up until about 2 years ago, so I've been saving up for replacement. The Buick currently has about 80K miles on it. I do plan on visiting my local Carmax again for my replacement car. Both my spouse and I have been pleased with them in the past.

Here's where I do need advice. Spending wads of cash on a car to run errands seems wasteful, so I'm looking at something under $16K. I want a sedan, gas engine, automatic trans, but would consider a small SUV type. No minis or compact cars. I can find plenty at my local Carmax, even with those filters, but I can't decide if I should go for "the newest" model I can afford, or the model with the least miles on it... or even how I should determine how many miles per year I should look for.

Ex: I saw a 2019 Kia Optima LX with 31K miles on it for $15,998. Fleet car. Is that too many miles in such a short amount of time?

I saw a 2014 Cadillac CTS with 87K miles for $16,998 (a little over my preferred budget). One owner, though... and my parents always loved Cadillacs (though I don't know about myself...).

I saw a 2015 Nissan Rogue Select with 90K miles for $11,998. Now that one has a really attractive price, but what about those miles? Personal car; one owner.

There are others, of course, but I'm just citing a few examples to hopefully illustrate where my confusion lies. I do check for any outstanding recalls (I pass on those), and if it was a fleet or personal car... but I've owned cars that were previously used as rental cars, and never had an issue with them, so I'm not sure that makes a big difference... or does it?

I bolded the part of my post where I seem to have the most trouble. Any advice, tips, or handy links would be appreciated. Maybe I'm overthinking this and *any* Carmax car would be fine -- if I still want it after a personal inspection and test-drive, of course. I'm old, and it's been 15 years since I bought a car. Sorry if this was too long.

Posted Oct 19, 2019, 7:10 AM UTC

415
asureddit•

Carmax is very good and their cars are really good and they are not known of selling anything than good cars but I think you should not limit yourself to just Carmax. Try your local dealers like Toyota, Honda, or if your family like Cadillac then let it be and check Cadillac, maybe you can find a CPO with dealer warranty.

My personal opinions:

The Kia is less than a year old and it already has double the yearly average mileage plus its a fleet car so I would not recommend it due to mileage and it being a fleet car.

Cadillac is almost 6 years old with 90K miles. This newer model Cadillac is known for reliability since Cadillac fixed many issues with the previous model but for a used one with that much mileage and age, I would hesitate.

Same goes for the Rogue.

​

At this mileage, car need some parts to be replaced and unless there is a warranty I do not think you want the headache.

​

There are others, of course, but I'm just citing a few examples to hopefully illustrate where my confusion lies. I do check for any outstanding recalls (I pass on those), and if it was a fleet or personal car... but I've owned cars that were previously used as rental cars, and never had an issue with them, so I'm not sure that makes a big difference... or does it?

Problem with fleet and rentals is that you cannot tell how good or bad the drivers drove the car. Usually, when people drive a company car they will abuse it and not care about it unlike if it was a personal car.

​

My advice is since you do not drive that much and only drive what is equivelant to 4x fills a year then look into getting a smaller car like Corolla, Sentra, Mazda 3 or anything similar.

2
TheRealMeatloafCanadian Ford Finance Manager, Eh•

Usually, when people drive a company car they will abuse it and not care about it unlike if it was a personal car.

Horse shit.

3
salescunt131•

Citation needed about fleet cars being abused.

2
dougheeOP•

The reason for "no minis or compacts" is my height, and back problems. I need plenty of leg room. Comfort in the vehicle is important, but I have been in a couple of "compacts" that were fairly roomy, so I'll keep an open mind there.

2
Benjiryle21•

Go find a certified pre-owned from an actual dealer as it will have extra warranty.

2
WhapdemonToyota Sales Greenpea•

Fleet cars are no big deal, imo you should go with the Kia. Nowadays the biggest killer on cars is time, not mileage. Do your due diligence on the condition of the car and consider an extended warranty (max care is pretty great) and scoop it up. Kia has gotten a lot better in quality over the years and provide a great value proposition.

2
dougheeOP•

I was just looking at the maxcare warranty. I'll probably opt for it. My husband would care for our cars most of the time. I was good at taking mine in for oil changes and minor repairs, both before and after he passed away, but I don't have the knowledge of vehicles he had. Anyway, that warranty would give me a little more peace of mind about any future service needs. Thank you.

1
HotdogCaprecious•

Do you have savings (3-6 months is typically recommended)? If so, I would not opt for the extended warranty on a vehicle that new. The Kia will still have a 5 year 60k mile warranty even with you as the second owner.

1
dougheeOP•

Good point on the Kia warranty. I'm fine on savings.

1
HotdogCaprecious•

A warranty is just an insurance policy. If you can afford to self insure you'll usually (not always, but usually) come out ahead.

Kias are great cars. They have come a LONG way in the past 10-15 years.

2
AutoModeratorMODIf you flair your post a baby kitten gets its wings.•

Please review the FAQ to see if your question has already been answered.

Also remember to add flair to your post by clicking the "Flair" link beneath it. This lets us know where you're located so we can assist you better.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
salescunt131•

Carmax overcharges but people pay it because they’re scared to negotiate

1
drrew76•

Or they just don't want to deal with the hassle.

2
Sleep_adict•
1
dougheeOP•

That's an interesting subreddit. I've only casually perused it so far, but I'll browse through it more this evening. Thanks!

1