QT: Is it transphobic to not believe trans women are women or trans men are men?
The following quote from a medium article summarizes my stance:
“Trans women are women”
This statement, I think, is the epicentre of this debate. It is where it usually begins and ends — often circularly. So I will start here. And this is where I will undoubtedly hurt someone’s feelings — I’m sorry.
I don’t believe trans women are women, and I never have. I don’t believe it because it isn’t true. Neither do I believe trans men are men. It doesn’t matter how many times you ask me to repeat after you — I’m not gonna believe it. Sorry.
I will treat trans women as if they are women and trans men as if they are men and in every respect behave as if they were the sex they declare themselves to be even if I do not believe they really are.
Do you believe this attitude is transphobic?
Posted Oct 21, 2019, 1:34 PM UTC
I personally have always hated this phrase. It should be changed simply to Transwomen are tranwomen, transmen are transmen.
I have a rather radical opinion that saying shit like transmen are men is just erasing my identity. I'm a transman, that has very specific meaning and I do not intend to just erase that.
Yes, I think this is a good compromise. I personally am fine calling them transwomen as a third category of gender that is still biologically male. They are not women though. Woman already has a well-established definition and biologically male people will never be women. [obviously, the same goes for transmen in reverse.] I think though, that TWAW is a political statement calculated to get access to women's spaces which I 100% oppose. So, while reasonable people like you may accept just being called trans, TRAs will continue to use "transphobia" to try to verbally bully us into pretending they are women and accepting their ideology.
I get it, I get that label too and agree with you on most points and thank you for sharing. While I'm not against transwomen in womens spaces, that is based mainly on the transwomen I know who pass and are in no way unsafe to others, however... I have seen some messed up stuff on some trans pages that have been circulated in GC circles and yeah... I can absolutely see why some people would be 100% against it and it's a tricky one to work out how to resolve.
Anyways, your idea of it as a third category seems like a really good stepping stone to something progressive between both sides. Most TRAs are batshit anyways, and they are the only ones who get attention. Most trans people I know are just living normal, quite, day to day lives and we just get on with things.
Exactly! Your experience is as a trans man is absolutely unique to you but it is much more comparable to that of another trans man. Whilst the experience of a natal man is one hugely different surely. Why is there this emphasis on (mostly women) people having to pretend a trans person has always been that sex and even stating something about the biology that we don’t share is transphobic?! I am in no way transphobic, I don’t want you to kill yourself or be unhappy, I don’t think you should have any less rights I.e marriage, work etc but I don’t see you as always having been the sex you feel you are inside. Because that’s not what you are. You’ve been through something a whole lot different to that and so have I. I was watching a speech the other day that got interrupted by a load of activists chanting ‘TWAW’- they were chanting this to a woman talking about her own sexual assault. I mean what the fuck? Sorry to rant at you about it, I know it’s not your fault, I just went on a tangent from my original point. Much love x
Thank you so much!!! Your attitude towards this is the exact attitude I would advocate for! I am a transman, that has a very specific meaning. Why are we not advocating for a place in society when trans people and be just that, trans. Trans by definition means you were born a certain sex which you gender identity does ny sync with. Like you said, every person has a journey in their own unique way. Trans is it's own journey and it's a damn tough one in it's own way, I'm not going to white wash that! (Not that natal men experience a peachy rosey socialisation, just different from a trans one). I guess its linked to gender dysphoria, it's so debilitating for some that perhaps saying just transwoman or transman is triggering for them, and I too find gender dysphoria pretty debilitating too but the answer is not to try and sweep what it means to be transwomen/transmen under the carpet of the 'cis' to a point where we dont even know what the distinction is. I think the best option of for trans women and trans men to go on a inward personal journey to try to find a place where they are comfortable with their origins in life and just say it like is its, transwomen are transwomen and transmen are transmen.
I respect your opinion and your clear respect towards me though I would imagine you have had the transphobe label thrown at you, I know I have...me.... a transman....!!!!
Exactly! It’s so refreshing to meet a trans person that feels this way too. I wish everyone thought like us then we could come to an arrangement with the nitty gritty stuff that suited everyone without anyone being accused of being a bigot. The very fact that they are accusing you...a transman..of being transphobic just speaks to the ridiculousness of how they think!!
I can only say the same, it's been refreshing! I dont believe in thought policing, I think people may think what ever the choose to think, including what they think of me. As long as we show basic respect for each other we can start to move forward and actually talk about things properly, not censoring everything as transphobic. You have your thoughts and you have shown respect and I respect the hell out of that. THAT should be the way forward.
Thank you. This is perfectly reasonable and I never would've even found GC if this is how most trans people acted, especially transwomen.
Your radical opinion strikes me as very reasonable :)
If you don't mind expounding on this a bit, I am a little interested - wouldn't saying you are a man, while also recognizing you as technically a transman, help to not cause/trigger dysphoria/discomfort? I guess I assume it would, mainly because so many trans people seem to disagree with your opinion.
Should alleviating possible discomfort caused by acknowledging things that are true be our primary concern when it comes to public discourse dealing with issues that affect the fundamental rights of multiple classes of people though? Some things are tough to talk about. Most of the really important things are, really.
Oh no, I fully agree - I'm GC. I'm just interested in this persons specific opinion since it's very against the grain.
It's kinda a bit of both. Like with new people I wont go out of my way in being introduced to them to make sure they know I'm a transman man however I would make no effort to hide it either. When it naturally comes up I just go with, I wont twist the past to suit who I am now you know? I pass as I have been on hormones a number of years now so it's not so obvious immediately. But I would never ask my parents to remove the family photos before my transition, I have no removed such photos from my social media either, I would never go on a date with a woman without letter her know I'm a transman and if she respectfully declined on that basis I would never ever EVER consider this right to bodily autonomy as transphobic.
I have basically spent a whole bunch of time and mental resources and trying to better my own mental health, strength and confidence to find the courage to walk this earth exactly as I am, no work arounds or gloss overs, just exactly who I am. A transman. Do I consider myself a man, in short yes but I very specific type of man, one with it's own journey in life that is not the same at all someone who was born male.
So for me, what you have described above would cause me no discomfort personally. It would probably trigger the majority of trans people, I couldn't be sure. I guess it depends on the kind of mental work they have put into themselves.
I would like to high five you, but, physics