QT: Is it transphobic to not believe trans women are women or trans men are men?

The following quote from a medium article summarizes my stance:

“Trans women are women”

This statement, I think, is the epicentre of this debate. It is where it usually begins and ends — often circularly. So I will start here. And this is where I will undoubtedly hurt someone’s feelings — I’m sorry.

I don’t believe trans women are women, and I never have. I don’t believe it because it isn’t true. Neither do I believe trans men are men. It doesn’t matter how many times you ask me to repeat after you — I’m not gonna believe it. Sorry.

I will treat trans women as if they are women and trans men as if they are men and in every respect behave as if they were the sex they declare themselves to be even if I do not believe they really are.

Do you believe this attitude is transphobic?

Posted Oct 21, 2019, 1:34 PM UTC

86680

I personally have always hated this phrase. It should be changed simply to Transwomen are tranwomen, transmen are transmen.

I have a rather radical opinion that saying shit like transmen are men is just erasing my identity. I'm a transman, that has very specific meaning and I do not intend to just erase that.

59
DistantGlimmer•

Yes, I think this is a good compromise. I personally am fine calling them transwomen as a third category of gender that is still biologically male. They are not women though. Woman already has a well-established definition and biologically male people will never be women. [obviously, the same goes for transmen in reverse.] I think though, that TWAW is a political statement calculated to get access to women's spaces which I 100% oppose. So, while reasonable people like you may accept just being called trans, TRAs will continue to use "transphobia" to try to verbally bully us into pretending they are women and accepting their ideology.

33

I get it, I get that label too and agree with you on most points and thank you for sharing. While I'm not against transwomen in womens spaces, that is based mainly on the transwomen I know who pass and are in no way unsafe to others, however... I have seen some messed up stuff on some trans pages that have been circulated in GC circles and yeah... I can absolutely see why some people would be 100% against it and it's a tricky one to work out how to resolve.

Anyways, your idea of it as a third category seems like a really good stepping stone to something progressive between both sides. Most TRAs are batshit anyways, and they are the only ones who get attention. Most trans people I know are just living normal, quite, day to day lives and we just get on with things.

17
for-fuckssake•

Exactly! Your experience is as a trans man is absolutely unique to you but it is much more comparable to that of another trans man. Whilst the experience of a natal man is one hugely different surely. Why is there this emphasis on (mostly women) people having to pretend a trans person has always been that sex and even stating something about the biology that we don’t share is transphobic?! I am in no way transphobic, I don’t want you to kill yourself or be unhappy, I don’t think you should have any less rights I.e marriage, work etc but I don’t see you as always having been the sex you feel you are inside. Because that’s not what you are. You’ve been through something a whole lot different to that and so have I. I was watching a speech the other day that got interrupted by a load of activists chanting ‘TWAW’- they were chanting this to a woman talking about her own sexual assault. I mean what the fuck? Sorry to rant at you about it, I know it’s not your fault, I just went on a tangent from my original point. Much love x

21

Thank you so much!!! Your attitude towards this is the exact attitude I would advocate for! I am a transman, that has a very specific meaning. Why are we not advocating for a place in society when trans people and be just that, trans. Trans by definition means you were born a certain sex which you gender identity does ny sync with. Like you said, every person has a journey in their own unique way. Trans is it's own journey and it's a damn tough one in it's own way, I'm not going to white wash that! (Not that natal men experience a peachy rosey socialisation, just different from a trans one). I guess its linked to gender dysphoria, it's so debilitating for some that perhaps saying just transwoman or transman is triggering for them, and I too find gender dysphoria pretty debilitating too but the answer is not to try and sweep what it means to be transwomen/transmen under the carpet of the 'cis' to a point where we dont even know what the distinction is. I think the best option of for trans women and trans men to go on a inward personal journey to try to find a place where they are comfortable with their origins in life and just say it like is its, transwomen are transwomen and transmen are transmen.

I respect your opinion and your clear respect towards me though I would imagine you have had the transphobe label thrown at you, I know I have...me.... a transman....!!!!

16
for-fuckssake•

Exactly! It’s so refreshing to meet a trans person that feels this way too. I wish everyone thought like us then we could come to an arrangement with the nitty gritty stuff that suited everyone without anyone being accused of being a bigot. The very fact that they are accusing you...a transman..of being transphobic just speaks to the ridiculousness of how they think!!

8

I can only say the same, it's been refreshing! I dont believe in thought policing, I think people may think what ever the choose to think, including what they think of me. As long as we show basic respect for each other we can start to move forward and actually talk about things properly, not censoring everything as transphobic. You have your thoughts and you have shown respect and I respect the hell out of that. THAT should be the way forward.

9
gayorles57•

Thank you. This is perfectly reasonable and I never would've even found GC if this is how most trans people acted, especially transwomen.

12
drunkthrowwaay•

Your radical opinion strikes me as very reasonable :)

6

I have a rather radical opinion that saying shit like transmen are men is just erasing my identity. I'm a transman, that has very specific meaning and I do not intend to just erase that.

If you don't mind expounding on this a bit, I am a little interested - wouldn't saying you are a man, while also recognizing you as technically a transman, help to not cause/trigger dysphoria/discomfort? I guess I assume it would, mainly because so many trans people seem to disagree with your opinion.

3
drunkthrowwaay•

Should alleviating possible discomfort caused by acknowledging things that are true be our primary concern when it comes to public discourse dealing with issues that affect the fundamental rights of multiple classes of people though? Some things are tough to talk about. Most of the really important things are, really.

5

Oh no, I fully agree - I'm GC. I'm just interested in this persons specific opinion since it's very against the grain.

5

It's kinda a bit of both. Like with new people I wont go out of my way in being introduced to them to make sure they know I'm a transman man however I would make no effort to hide it either. When it naturally comes up I just go with, I wont twist the past to suit who I am now you know? I pass as I have been on hormones a number of years now so it's not so obvious immediately. But I would never ask my parents to remove the family photos before my transition, I have no removed such photos from my social media either, I would never go on a date with a woman without letter her know I'm a transman and if she respectfully declined on that basis I would never ever EVER consider this right to bodily autonomy as transphobic.

I have basically spent a whole bunch of time and mental resources and trying to better my own mental health, strength and confidence to find the courage to walk this earth exactly as I am, no work arounds or gloss overs, just exactly who I am. A transman. Do I consider myself a man, in short yes but I very specific type of man, one with it's own journey in life that is not the same at all someone who was born male.

So for me, what you have described above would cause me no discomfort personally. It would probably trigger the majority of trans people, I couldn't be sure. I guess it depends on the kind of mental work they have put into themselves.

4
Barbievive•

I have basically spent a whole bunch of time and mental resources and trying to better my own mental health, strength and confidence to find the courage to walk this earth exactly as I am, no work arounds or gloss overs, just exactly who I am.

I would like to high five you, but, physics

2
thrwpllw•

Well yes, in the same way it's godless and sinful to not believe that someone who has found Jesus has been Saved.

That is to say, I know and acknowledge that people who believe in the transgender ideology will consider me a heretic transphobe because I do not share their belief system. I know that some of them will be offended by what they perceive as my blaspheming.

This is why I avoid trans topics in professional settings, just as I avoid debates about other religious or spiritual beliefs. I have no desire to offend someone else's beliefs, and I also have no desire to lie about my own beliefs or recite the catechism of a religion to which I do not belong.

55
nikitatx•

I think this is a fantastic comparison. I am close with a Baptist family, and while I know their ideology dictates that I will burn in hell (as a non Christian), it has no bearing on my ability to be civil or treat them with respect. If someone wants to believe something, that’s on them. I am not required to conduct myself in accordance to their ideology. On the flip side they are also incredibly respectful to me, and would never accuse me of killing Jesus simply bc I have other beliefs.

It boils down to respect, and an ability to coexist in the world at large with people who share different viewpoints without resorting to threats or acts of violence.

31
thrwpllw•

This is also why it baffles me to see people asserting (as in this thread) that not believing transwomen are women is bound to lead to transphobic action.

I'm an atheist, so does that mean I'm inevitably going to violate the civil or human rights of religious people? Is it fair to assume that my lack of belief in God a precursor to assaulting, raping, or murdering believers?

38
nikitatx•

Critical thinking is in short supply these days, particularly so in Internet echo chambers.

20
villanelle23eve•

No, but belief in religion is often a precursor to assaulting and murdering non-believers.

And belief in religion has always led to violating the civil rights of atheists.

8
lavenderamethyst•

[–]thrwpllw [score hidden] 3 hours ago Well yes, in the same way it's godless and sinful to not believe that someone who has found Jesus has been Saved.

I love you! Ha! 🤣

11
NumerousEventOP•

people who believe in the transgender ideology will consider me a transphobe because I do not share their belief system.

It's amazing, but that's exactly what happened in another comment chain.

4
thrwpllw•

My first experience of internet forums was debating Creationists and Christians on an early-days political forum.

They made essentially these same arguments, like that declining to believe in their God meant I was obviously calling them delusional, or that opposing the teaching of Creationism in public schools constituted persecution of Christians.

It's both fascinating and a bit scary to see their ideology replicated in today's "progressives."

6
NumerousEventOP•

It's hilarious that the trans advocate in the other comment chain is willing to go along with that definition of anti-Christian so that they can keep their definition of transphobia.

5
Barbievive•

Nah, not transphobic. Even in my own mind I'm more like honorary woman, in many contexts. Yeah, I relate to dealing with shitty guys, but I don't relate to why my friend won't be wearing a white skirt for her Halloween outfit. Some experiences we share and some we don't.

I don't think I usually care about the specifics as long as we're all comfortable, safe, and getting along.

43

Huh. I admit, an interesting perspective. Agree of course on the "comfortable, safe and getting along" part.

14
Barbievive•

Agree of course on the "comfortable, safe and getting along" part.

🎉

3
zepppfloyd•

I kinda like that phrase “honorary woman” bc there are plenty of trans women I truly am honored to have join us :)

10
Barbievive•

💕

I realized some time ago that it doesn't really make a difference if it ever comes out that some of my friends don't "really" see me as a woman. I feel included where it makes sense to include me. I know that I'm loved and appreciated. If they secretly see me as a super-feminine guy, it's fine.

6
drunkthrowwaay•

That’s a very reasonable perspective, upvoted :)

6
Barbievive•

😁

3
Honeyphox•

This actually kindof summerises my views aswell :3

6
Barbievive•

High fiveee

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Barbievive•

Given that this isn't remotely convincing as an argument, is there some other purpose to your comment...?

1
somegenerichandleneither GC nor QT•

It's sexist. Asking to be treated like another sex implies that people should treat men and women differently. Trans people are humans, and hence i treat them with respect.

42
waterfall374•

Men and women should be treated differently in cases where differences between male and female bodies are relevant. In those cases, not treating men and women differently to the degree required by their physical bodies is what is sexist, and almost always misogynist, because it almost always advantages men over women. Sometimes this is simply the result of inherent advantages (greater strength in men, women's susceptibility to pregnancy etc) but often times it's the result of society designing the default with men in mind, and thus creating a male advantage where one did not exist naturally.

44
somegenerichandleneither GC nor QT•

I agree in medicine we need to treat bodies according to their sex, age, weight, race etc. I suppose i just assume when people say "treat me like a woman" this means in day to day life or in the bedroom.

21
waterfall374•

The whole restrooms/locker rooms/sports/everything issue is all about genderists being sexist by refusing to treat the sexes differently when relevant. And that's not even getting in to 'wax my balls' yaniv and men demanding to be seen by gynecologists

24
SqueakyBall•

I can't believe anyone outside r/TheDonald is actually arguing for equal treatment rather than equal outcomes.

  • End efforts to recruits girls and women into STEM programs.
  • Kill programs to recruit Blacks, Hispanics and other underrepresented minorities at Ivy League and other top universities.
  • Make Boards of Directors lily white male once again.
  • Enrich the rich!
3
hollyboombah•

What is being 'treated like a woman' in the bedroom?

16
somegenerichandleneither GC nor QT•

bottoming. This is what i assume they mean.

6
NumerousEventOP•

I meant day to day life. "Treat" mostly refers to using the desired gendered pronouns and honorifics.

5
lavenderamethyst•

Oh my god. Smack my fucking head. This is so sad

14
somegenerichandleneither GC nor QT•

It really is. When people agree with the MRA's belief that women live life on easy mode, they transition and assume life will be easier. They wonder why it's not, instead of realizing that the grass is not always greener, they think it's society not treating them like women. I am not a therapist, but i assume some people have a thought process like this.

18
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
hel_o_connEdgar Allan Hoe•

If you treat me decently and respect me for who I am, then I don't care whether or not you believe it. Thought crime does not exist. Simple as that.

Maybe I should use an analogy: if you believe that homosexuality is a sin, but treat me the same as any heterosexual, then there is no harm done. Even if you feel a deep aversion towards homosexuals and thus don't want to associate with them if possible, but treat them with respect when you have to interact, then your aversion kind of becomes a non factor.

24
marianep2001•

I feel the same way as the OP. But if you look like a 300lbs linebacker in a dress, knee high socks, a tiny bow in your hair and call yourself “Iris”, I cant promise I won’t 😂.

10
hel_o_connEdgar Allan Hoe•

Understandable. I would try not to, but if you try to be every cliche [name should be Luna or Zoey thou] then I might think it's funny xS

0
gayhaught•

I don’t know why sin and theology keep coming up when this is a matter of biological fact, theology doesn’t have to come into it. Respectfully referring to what someone wants to be referred to even if it’s not biologically true is pretty much what’s happening. Anyone who says “transwomen are women” they don’t literally mean women, im assuming. They mean for all intends and purposes generally speaking this person is a woman as recognized under the law but they’re not going to actually be a woman in any biological sense. If they died and we’re buried and exhumed a thousand years from now, the bones would only contain DNA evidence of a man. You can’t get rid of the reality of that fact.

6
NumerousEventOP•

Anyone who says “transwomen are women” they don’t literally mean women, im assuming.

I think this is what many people mean, but there are also plenty that go beyond that, especially when the "cotton ceiling" is concerned. The argument goes: (a) If lesbians and heterosexual men are attracted to women and (b) if trans women are women (and not accepting this is transphobia), then (c) lesbians and heterosexual men should be attracted to trans women unless they are transphobic. I'm trying to interrogate (b) in this post.

6
hel_o_connEdgar Allan Hoe•

I would agree if you used female instead of woman. If transwomen were female, then they wouldn't be trans. Woman on the other hand has uses outside its ivory tower definition and within those uses TWAW.

I used that particular analogy because coming from a strict Christian family it's one of the first things that comes to my mind.

1

100% agree, so so much agree!!

2
InALandOfMakeBelieveradfem•

GC siding here

I think telling people they're transphobic for perceiving the world differently than you do will always alienate people from trans rhetoric. Because I could be the most pro-trans person, fight for: removing sex-based protections, making it easy to change legal sex, making medical transition free and removing all gatekeeping, etc etc etc but if inside my brain I see a difference between women and transwomen and men and transmen I would be a transphobe despite all that.

23
[deleted]•

Hey...this question is directed specifically at QT. It isn't good etiquette here to respond to posts aimed at a specific group with a top level comment if you are not part of the group the question is for.

4†
InALandOfMakeBelieveradfem•

I'll delete if OP asks me to

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

19
horse_and_buggy•

Being tricked or fooled isn’t believing. Being polite or respectful still isn’t believing. Until they 1984 me it can’t ever become believing.

24
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2†
polelifeandpussy•

Except that the part of the value of the Mona Lisa is that it was painted by DaVinci. The replica was not. So while it may look real, you cannot sell it for the same price and if you tried too, and were found out, you would be arrested for fraud.

A ftm with a fully functioning neo penis will still never be a true male because a female can never be a male. And for many if not most of us that matters. Maybe the day will come where a ftm passes enough as a male, genitla included, that I would sleep with them, but the moment I learn that they are female biologically, I would feel violated, deceived, and disgusted. Because I am not a lesbian woman. I am a straight woman and I only want male humans to be sexual with me.

21
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
horse_and_buggy•

Why is it wrong to change your race or want to change your race then? It's much easier to "pass" as a different skin color but this is seen as highly offensive.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
MrFahrenheit46(Transsexual) Boy ♂⇌ Ideologically Homeless•

I don’t care about what you think of me. I care about what you do to me.

18
lavenderamethyst•

Is speaking our thoughts “doing” something to you?

19
MrFahrenheit46(Transsexual) Boy ♂⇌ Ideologically Homeless•

No, I mean “doing” stuff like throwing garbage in my face, or pulling my pants down in a public area.

10
Quixoticfutz•

Vile, are those not crimes classified as harassment or something?

7
MrFahrenheit46(Transsexual) Boy ♂⇌ Ideologically Homeless•

I would certainly hope so, but I guess the consequences depend on the school/workplace policy.

2
Poopskirt•

I’ve wondered about this too. Especially when feeling like the spread of misinformation is dangerous.

5
SqueakyBall•

Upvote for reasonable-ness

10
MrFahrenheit46(Transsexual) Boy ♂⇌ Ideologically Homeless•

Thanks!

4
villanelle23eve•

where's the upvote?

0
SqueakyBall•

?

3
ascreamingbirdPro-Trans•

Nah, I don't believe this attitude is transphobic. In fact, I also hate the "trans women are women" chant that goes around. Trans people are always gonna be trans. The sooner that's accepted the better. You don't need to co opt someone else's identity to alleviate your gender dysphoria. The fact is that trans women's experiences are different from female experiences, and to say that these are one in the same is a lie.

Having said that, if someone asks you to refer to them with certain pronouns or a certain name, and you actively use other pronouns and another name because you don't think they should have feminine pronouns/name, that's bordering on transphobic for me. The reason you're not using their new name or giving them the respect you'd give anyone else is because they're trans, and that's problematic.

15
Akumu01•

As a trans person myself who struggles with some of the same thoughts as this person I'd say probably not. I think the big thing is that they're clearly trying and that says a lot for me. You can't control what you think only how you act

12
somegenerichandleneither GC nor QT•

I disagree. That's kind of the main point in CBT is to change your thought patterns. I agree you can't do it quickly, but instead of quickly dismissing the thought, they are dwelling on it. The more you dwell on them the more you think about them, and perhaps convince yourself to do it.

5
SqueakyBall•

I agree that thoughts and patterns can be changed to a degree but that presupposes that one wants and/or needs to change their thoughts. If a person treats transpeople with respect, why should she try to believe something that actively contradicts her own belief system?

6
somegenerichandleneither GC nor QT•

It's for you to decide which thoughts you want to change.

0
horse_and_buggy•

The brain is neuroplastic, meaning in it's natural state it can change

5
absinthecity•

Completely agree

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

6
ComfortableStressPro-Trans•

It is not necessary and sufficient. It is necessary however.

5
NumerousEventOP•

That's fair, but some argue that by being necessary, it is transphobic.

5
MatthewH0Between •

For me, 50/50

A MTF can be socially considered a woman and I find completely okay referring to these people as women. However, biologically they're not. It's the same case with FTM., their biology is not the same (and there is nothing wrong with that) I don't think you're a bigot for this though You are okay treating them which makes them comfortable, however you still own a point.

5
burntmatchesburn3x•

Reality is transphobic. Men are not women. Ever.

3
Kayde-666•

No it is not. It does not matter how many treatments you take, the outcome from the XY chromosome at birth is 100%. This is a scientific fact. Being transgender is a chemical imbalance in the brain, it does not change the result of the XY chromosome given at birth.

2
Ember_11•

Yes, but I don't think that anyone would have a problem with that if you are willing to treat people as their prefferred gender

1
PainAuxBananes•

Yes it is.

1
sesekriri•

Just like all other categories we have created in language, the categories of men and women are arbitrary. We create categories because they have use to us. For example, we create the category of chair to mean an object with a back and four legs. However, if we find utility in expanding this category, perhaps by including an office chair with an atypical base, or even a beanbag could be considered a type of chair. Categories, even scientific ones, are created arbitrarily. There is no 'inherent truth' in it.

Marriage was defined as a union between a man and a woman. However, we saw utility in expanding that category to include same sex marriage as well. The utility was that more people could feel accepted and be happy and fulfilled in their life.

Changing the historically defined category of women to include trans women is the same. The category exists for societal utility, and the ultimate goal of society is to allow the most people to be the happiest.

By believing that one is not the other, you are refusing to move with the times. By insisting that definitions of the socially used categories and terms are rigid and unchangeable you are incorrectly viewing how language works, how it evolves. Using an antiquated, more strict version of the term DOES hurt trans women and makes them feel like a discount version of who they are. While your intention in sticking to these old definitions might be to be more 'accurate' but it does not mean that is it right.

0
Redpants_McBoatshoepronouns: he/she/they•

Well it's true they are arbitrary, you're almost getting it. Just keep in mind that the arbitrariness works both ways. You have to motivate why your paradigm is better, if you want people to change their minds.

Changing the historically defined category of women to include trans women is the same.

That's not true, because a marriage is a covenant between two people and it doesn't define anyone else. Like, ”if you don't like gay marriage, don't get gay married”. But when we include trans women into the category of womanhood, that obviously includes cis women as well. Do you see how it's different? You are defining cis women as well as trans women. Perhaps it upsets you that they want to define what sex trans women are. But will you allow them to define their own sex?

A chair is not problematic, either. Why would anyone care if a beanbag is a chair or not? But if these chairs had legal rights and obligations, and sentience, then their identities start mattering. Women have rights and sentience. Like, they have subjectivity: try to look at it from both perspectives.

By believing that one is not the other, you are refusing to move with the times.

Nuh-uh, you are!

By insisting that definitions of the socially used categories and terms are rigid and unchangeable you are incorrectly viewing how language works, how it evolves.

I actually agree with this. However, that just means things can be changed, not that they have to. Don't worry though, I'm confident it'll happen once sex change becomes more advanced and so on.

Using an antiquated, more strict version of the term DOES hurt trans women and makes them feel like a discount version of who they are.

There's a lot to unpack. How do you define trans women? Based on self-id? Or something else?

While your intention in sticking to these old definitions might be to be more 'accurate' but it does not mean that is it right.

Doesn't mean it's wrong either. It's wrong, I think, to say someone else can't call themselves a woman. But not to say or believe it yourself. But then it gets complicated when it comes to laws and politics maybe, and science, because they pretty much require us to agree about language more or less.

1
90hagr15•

Perhaps it upsets you that they want to define what sex trans women are. But will you allow them to define their own sex?

Gender, not sex.

There's a lot to unpack. How do you define trans women? Based on self-id? Or something else?

Gender is literally identity, that's why we have different words for gender and sex. There is no other way to know someone's gender apart from knowing what they self identify as.

1
Redpants_McBoatshoepronouns: he/she/they•

I mean, the problem arises when people use man and woman to mean different things relating to gender or sex.

1
rogerthecat9•

It's not transphobic to believe that trans women aren't women or vice versa. WHAT IS transphobic is going out of your way to tell trans women they are men or trans men they are women. WHAT IS transphobic is refusing to respect name changes of trans people because "that's a man's/woman's name and you are not a man/woman!" WHAT IS transphobic is insisting that simple pronouns (she/her/hers, he/him/his, they/them/theirs) are inextricably linked to a person's sex, rather than a linguistic construct that identifies a person in shorthand for their name. WHAT IS transphobic is pointing out how much X feature "looks so masculine/feminine!" in an attempt show that a trans person is "artificial" or "will never be who they want to be", etc. WHAT IS transphobic is denying the existence of dysphoria. WHAT IS transphobic is campaigning to deny trans people their bodily autonomy by comparing dysphoria to body dysmorphia, ignoring the DOCTORS who say that transitioning alleviates dysphoria. WHAT IS transphobic is denying the oppression of trans people and refusing to acknowledge their struggles.

-1†
Hypocritical-Cunt•

WHAT IS transphobic is insisting that simple pronouns (she/her/hers, he/him/his, they/them/theirs) are inextricably linked to a person's sex, rather than a linguistic construct that identifies a person in shorthand for their name.

Why are there two of them, then?

And if they’re not inextricably linked to sex what’s the big deal with calling a transwoman he? He isn’t a pronoun for males, right, just a shorthand identifier for their name, so it’s not saying he’s male or anything, right?

22
rogerthecat9•

Why are their two of them, then?

I mean ignoring the fact that there's three, it would be because they are associated with sex, not inextricably linked. Every good linguist knows that no word comes without exceptions, as languages evolve with cultures and contexts.

If they're not inextricably linked to sex what's the big deal with calling a transwoman he?

Respect. The same way you respect somebody's decision to change their name. It's a linguistic construct and as long as you're sticking with words that already exist and fit within the current linguistic structures (she/her/hers, he/him/his, they/them/theirs) it should be completely fine for anyone to choose whichever pronouns they're most comfortable with.

-1†
Hypocritical-Cunt•

I mean ignoring the fact that there's three,

I was clearly talking about the two that have no differentiation other than sex; the reason for “them” is the plural case.

Every good linguist knows that no word comes without exceptions,

Why should males who would prefer to be female be the exception?

And every good linguist also knows that language isn’t prescriptive like that and it doesn’t change just because you say it should, anyway.

Respect. The same way you respect somebody's decision to change their name.

Apples and oranges. Names are individual personifiers and belong to individuals. My name is mine. He and she, on the other hand, are not and do not. She doesn’t belong to me, it refers to any female. You can change your name, you can’t change an entire sexed pronoun.

it should be completely fine for anyone to choose whichever pronouns they're most comfortable with.

See above point. For someone talking the big talk about what good linguists know, you sure don’t understand how language functions. Tl;dr: you’re not in charge of it.

18
rogerthecat9•

why should males who prefer to be female be the exception?

Anyone should be able to determine their own pronouns but by and large it's mostly trans men and women who do.

It didn't change just because you say it should.

Wow, you're completely right. People who refer to trans women using she/her pronouns aren't going to stop just because you say they should! And they didn't start just because I said they should! Pronoun usage has changed outside of both of our controls. It's a cultural phenomena and denying it's existence dues nothing, nor does ignoring the fact that culture changes linguistics.

Names are individual personifiers and belong to individuals. My name is mine.

Even the person with the most unique name I've met had three other people in the country recorded to have had the same name as her. Your name is a collection of letters and sounds that anyone can claim as their own should they choose to. Just because there's more names than pronouns doesn't mean that pronouns can't be changed in a similar matter.

You can't change an entire sexed pronoun.

"Sexed" pronouns don't exist. Pronouns do not have genitals, chromosomes, or reproductive capabilities. You use the word "she" to refer to boats for crying out loud. Pronouns aren't sexed and there's no reason they should be.

-4†
NumerousEventOP•

WHAT IS weird is how you decide to be confrontational when the post makes it clear that I and the AUTHOR of the medium article do not do any of those things.

20
rogerthecat9•

Sorry if I implied that they did, I was mostly just thinking of things a lot of people do say when they at first only say they don't believe that trans women are women/trans men are trans men. If you think I should I can add an edit/disclaimer in the comment.

7
NumerousEventOP•

This comment is enough disclaimer. But if you were "thinking of things a lot of people do say when they at first only say they don't believe that trans women are women/trans men are trans men," then were you thinking that I and author of the article would say those things as well?

4
rogerthecat9•

I was thinking that you could, not that you necessarily would. If you did, I was hoping that you'd be able to civilly debate such things. If you didn't, surely some people who are reading it will, at least for most items, and I can have that discussion with those people instead.

1
sugar4thepill•

Yeah second this. OP misread the tone of your original comment

2†
gayorles57•

WHAT IS transphobic is pointing out how much X feature "looks so masculine/feminine!" in an attempt show that a trans person is "artificial" or "will never be who they want to be", etc.

Regarding this point, I find it so odd how QT conflates maleness with masculinity, the same way ya'll have started to conflate sex and gender. Both males and females can be masculine; only male people can be male. Gender critical women don't think MtFs need to be masculine, in fact we support all people being as "masculine" or as "feminine" as they'd like—we do acknowledge that all MtFs are immutably male, though, and sometimes we need to point it out in order to defend and protect women. And sometimes, lesbians feel forced to point out immutable male sex characteristics when we are harassed by transactivists & repeatedly asked why we wouldn't date a transwoman.

FWIW, I don't know a single lesbian who has initiated an "I wouldn't date a transwoman" conversation with a QT person. Invariably, it is the transactivist who assails the lesbian with "would you date a transwoman?" and then captures her in a transphobia trap because nothing she says other than "yes" is acceptable to you.

17
rogerthecat9•

Reread my statement. You forgot the most crucial part

In an attempt to show that a trans person is "artificial" or "will never be who they want to be"

I suppose I should have put in a disclaimer that pointing out the sex of a person under relevent circumstances is acceptable, but I didn't think it would be inferred. I didn't think that pointing out features would be interpreted as pointing out genitals/chromosomes.

2
gayorles57•

I mean, I have only ever pointed out a person's sex for purposes of protecting vulnerable women's spaces (I'm not even talking bathrooms here, I'm talking about rape centers, sex-segregated mental health recovery centers and prisons—all of which should be available to trans people too, but not at women's expense) and/or defending the definition of female homosexuality. Other than these specific topics, I'm certainly not in the business of going around and reminding trans people that they aren't the sex they wish they were. I'm pretty sure most gender critical people feel similarly and only intervene under similar types of circumstances. I'm just not really sure what you mean by "reminding trans people they aren't their sex" as a common transphobic behavior because this isn't something I've seen happen outside of specific, relevant circumstances, at least not by gender critical feminists who are slurred as "transphobes".

17

Yes

-4†
NumerousEventOP•

What makes it transphobic?

13

Because it's denying either that gender exists as a category, or that it has social relevance.

It's saying that trans women are men, which is different from saying trans women are male.

And doing that is showing that you don't accept transwomen as they are, which is transphobic.

Whether that is a good or bad thing, or what kinds of "transphobia" are acceptable, is a different story imo. I personally don't really care if someone doesn't believe what I believe as long as they treat me normally.

I think it's the same as someone who is anti-X, but treats members of group X normally, is, well, Xphobic/Xist.

2†
Hypocritical-Cunt•

Because it's denying either that gender exists as a category, or that it has social relevance.

No, it’s not. Gender exists and has social relevance. It just doesn’t make men women.

you don't accept transwomen as they are, which is transphobic.

It’s transwomen who don’t accept themselves as they are, hence the need for transition. I’m perfectly comfortable with the fact they’re men.

22

It just doesn’t make men women.

That's like saying it doesn't make blue red. Men aren't women because men and woman refer to gender. If gender can change, than a man/woman can become a woman/man, but that's changing their category, not making one category the other.

It’s transwomen who don’t accept themselves as they are, hence the need for transition

I accept myself as I am and my need for hormone medication to be happy with my body. 🤷 If I hypothetically didn't produce any sex hormones at all, accepting myself as I am would actually be dangerous to my health. So I don't think acceptance has to be of one's "natural", unmedicated body and mind.

2
NumerousEventOP•

My definition of transphobia is a negative attitude to trans people. Your definition seems to revolve not accepting the QT worldview, and is completely out of step with other *phobias.

10

If you don't accept any trans people as the gender they present as, that's still transphobic. You're just not telling them so. If you did, it'd definitely come off as a negative attitude.

I think the -phobic part is a misnomer bc, like homophobia, it's not about fear.

0
syhd•

Because it's denying either that gender exists as a category, or that it has social relevance.

I know that gender exists and has social relevance. That's why I am a gender abolitionist.

I just don't think that trans natal males can be women.

And doing that is showing that you don't accept transwomen as they are, which is transphobic.

I accept that they are what they are, which is not women.

The only way your argument can ever work is if you assume TWAW as axiomatic. But then that's circular reasoning.

9

I mean the statement TWAW is axiomatic because, if trans is an adjective, it's like saying red boxes are boxes. I've kind of read it as more an affirmation that

  1. Gender is a social category we should have
  2. Trans women fall into the gender category of women, and "trans women" is a sensible term

I just don't think that trans natal males can be women

I don't think males can be female either. But I think man/woman are gender roles and a lot more flexible than sex. I don't think all trans natal males are or should be considered women. But I don't categorically think that none are. Which is turning down the validity of a group's lifestyle instead of just one person.

2