r/eu4•
farrydarry

Can we ever stop GB forming so early?

In pretty much every single game I play Great Britain is formed by England, through conquering all of Ireland and Scotland, by the mid 1500's. I understand that the idea of a united Britain was not an alien concept in the 1500s, but it was unfeasible and not just a very realistic proposition at the time. There's more of a case for it in the later 1600s, as Cromwell did actually manage to form a united Ireland and Britain of sorts, speaking of, it would be awesome if you form the Commonwealth of England, Scotland and Ireland instead of GB (providing different ideas/missions).

But my point is, seeing Great Britain and the Union Jack wage war against Castile and Burgundy in the early 1500s feels a bit anachronistic. It's hard to imagine Tudor-era troops and battleships rallying under the Union Jack, and waging war and converting Catholics in the name of Great Britain. Considering England was relatively poor until colonisation and the Reformation, it doesn't seem right to imagine England so seamlessly conquering and integrating Scotland without any problems so early in the game.

Does anyone else feel me? I feel like the option to form GB should be limited to 1650 and after or something. Or, that Scotland has a much better chance to stay alive for longer. Or both.

Posted Oct 22, 2019, 9:21 AM UTC

19
IkatiDW•

The problem is the English channel.England is filthy rich from the start. No matter what you do they will have the money to wage wars with irish minors and scotland

6
GallantGentleman•

This.

Makes me wonder if the end node shouldn't be moved to Bordeaux or somewhere in the low lands as these were historically filthy rich areas.

2
IkatiDW•

i don't know ,maybie split it and make the coast of holland the end node and the the english channel a connecting one to that?

1
GallantGentleman•

Or just remove England from the channel node. Move it to the European coast, maybe include Dover and 1-2 provinces, creating a London node that feeds into it.

2
IkatiDW•

They gonna change the genoa trade node next patch i think.I want a simmilar thing to that you can look it up on paradox forums

1
erwin-gomell•

Ye I found that happens when I play single player but in multi player I always have France take all of continental france and Cornwall so we never see a Britain cause france and Scotland team up

3
Captain_Brexit_•

I normally PU France first as England then vassalise Scotland since England can easily get powerful allies in Castile and Austria to win the Hundred Years' War. The game just is how you play it and I don't see that being any different to forming an independent Prussia in 1500

2
I_haku_I•

Prussia is a bit differetn tho, all nations that can form prussia are rather poor and weak in the beginning, with the potential to be rekt early on by Bohemia, Austria, Poland/Lithuania and later on Russia, I had to give up about 10 prussia games mid 17th century because my allies france and austria didnt give a flying fuhk or werent able to help when russia and bohemia teamed up to invade me with 6 armies each one half the size of my force limit.

England just messes everyone up once the 100y war is won and france is PUed.

3
aimangujarati786Naval Reformer•

Nothing is realistic in this game except for the start date.

1