r/DMAcademy•
Sethlon

Chasme, monster damage output, and balancing encounters

Hello friends! Been a long time DM, really enjoying 5E and the group that I'm running it for. I've never been much of one to use encounter calculators even back when I was an inexperienced DM in 3.5 over 10 years ago, so honestly until a couple days ago I haven't even looked up how 5E recommends calculating total encounters. As a baseline I usually look at the CR of a monster for the idea of what level a group of PCs should be at to be challenged by that monster, but aside from that small frame of reference, I generally focus more on interesting combat scenarios over focusing on CR.

During prep for one of my upcoming sessions I've found something a bit concerning, though. My group of 5 lvl6 PCs has been going through a dungeon which is inhabited by a group of demons, with a Chasme as it's head boss. A Chasme is CR6, so it fits my usual criteria of being somewhere around a challenge for my PCs, plan is to throw in some Dretches that it summons over time and some environmental effects, seems like a good encounter.

But then I'm looking at how much damage a Chasme does, and I'm kind of balking. Only one attack, but on a hit, it deals 4d6+2 piercing (average of 16) plus 7d6 (!!!) necrotic damage (avg 24) for a total average of 40 damage in a single hit. Am I the only one who thinks that this is like...a ridiculous amount of damage? 40dmg one shots most of my PCs, and a high roll would one shot the rest. And then the necrotic damage lowers max health, which can result in an instant death if a PC's max health dips to zero.

It seems like a trend overall that monsters deal a good amount of damage for their hits, especially higher level ones, but this seems especially vicious to me. I've considered lowered the amount of damage that the Chasme does to balance it out a bit, but it's worth considering whether or not I'm just doing it wrong. Is it normal to be going up against monsters that dish out this kind of damage at level 6?

Posted Oct 25, 2019, 5:34 AM UTC

12
zephid11•

I wouldn't say the damage is that over the top. You have to remember that a chasme only have one attack per turn, instead of multiple which is more or less standard at that level. To make up for the lack of multiple attacks, a chasme's single attack has to deal a lot of damage. And because he only have one attack per turn, coupled with the fact that he only has a +5 to hit, means that he will deal 0 damage on a lot of the turns.

Edit: I just looked at the recommend monster statistics according to CR in the DMG and a CR 6 monster should do about 40 damage per turn, which is consistent with a chasme. But a CR 6 monster should also have 146-160 HP, a Chasme only has about 80.

1
Aethelwolf•

Its pretty average for a CR 6 creature. Just going through a few other examples from the basic rules. A Cyclops is dealing 38, a Mage has an 8d8 (36 average) Cone of Cold area spell, a chimera is doing 32 on a normal turn and 53 on a breath turn, a mammoth is doing 54 if it can charge.

The max HP drain is obviously pretty scary, but its only gonna get 1 or 2 attacks before going down against 5 level 6 PCs.

1