Why White Doesn't Need Card Draw: On the Nature of Game Design
Some people might not like this post, but I think a lot of people here need to hear it. White doesn't get card draw. White won't get card draw. It's the same thing as red not getting enchantment removal. It's just not in the color pie. And sure, some people will nitpick and say that red got [[Enchanter's Bane]], but I'd counter that white has had cards like [[Tithe]], [[Gift of Estates]], and the ever-present [[Land Tax]] for quite a while, which are all forms of card draw.
Now some people might complain that these cards aren't "real card draw", to which you would be correct. White doesn't get "real card draw". But the problem isn't where white fits in the color pie, the problem is the difference in design philosophy. WotC makes cards primarily for Standard and limited. We can disregard limited here, as cards designed for limited generally don't have a place in constructed, and that's fine. But Standard cards are designed to fit in not only a specific environment, but also within a specific game setup: two players, twenty life, sixty cards. And there's nothing wrong with playing other ways, I myself love EDH, CanLander, and Modern, among plenty of other formats.
But why is EDH special? White sees plenty of play in other, non-Standard formats. Well in two player, twenty life formats, white's strengths matter more. Small creatures don't mean a lot in EDH when there's 3 opponents with 40 life each. Sure, cards like [[Thalia, Guardian of Thraben]] still have powerful abilities, but not every creature is or should be Thalia. White's life gain cards don't matter nearly as much when you start at 40 life. Yes, you can build decks around gaining life, with incredibly strong payoffs, but cards like [[Revitalize]] that saw fair amounts of play in their standard environments mean nothing to commander players. White does still have some advantages, like strong creature, artifact, and enchantment removal, but that alone doesn't a deck make. Now, one of white's greatest strengths is Mass Land Destruction (yes, there are only a few cards that do it, but those that do are very good at it). But the pervasive culture of EDH makes it so that a lot of people don't want to play or, perhaps more aptly, play against, MLD. And that's okay. Stax falls into a similar category, with white having plenty of good taxing/lockdown cards ([[Thalia, Guardian of Thraben]], [[Thalia, Heretic Cathar]], [[Rule of Law]], [[Ghostly Prison]], [[Spirit of the Labyrinth]], the new [[Deafenening Silence]]), but very few players want to play with or against stax in EDH. And that's okay. But if you want to play in a way that cards aren't primarily designed for, then you have to accept what that means.
Now some people might say, what about Commander Precons? After all, they are made specifically for our non-standard ruleset. And while that's true, WotC still can't willfully break the color pie. Sure, mistakes happen, but we can't pretend like we can design breaks (or really even bends) in good faith. And even in precons, WotC still has to make considerations for other formats. Multiplayer sets are known for producing some wildly powerful cards for Legacy (and occasionally Vintage). See [[True-Name Nemesis]] and [[Council's Judgement]]. True-Name is, quite frankly, not that good in EDH (it's not unplayable imo, but it's not on my shortlist of blue cards to include in any given deck), and while Council's Judgement is still quite good in EDH, both it and True-Name are significantly more powerful in Legacy. WotC doesn't, and can't, design cards in a vacuum.
But what if WotC did design a good white card draw spell? Well that doesn't solve the issue unfortunately. Let's assume it ticks all the boxes we need it to: it won't see play in other formats so the only driving force is EDH, it's generically strong enough to not be pigeon-holed into one strategy, and it's put in a precon. Sounds great right? Well, maybe not. For starters, this is one card. If the only card draw spell you put in your mono-blue deck was [[Rhystic Study]], how good would your draw be? Not very. This doesn't fix the issue that white doesn't have good card draw, it makes one auto-include card that every white deck should be playing. You know what happened the last time we got a generically powerful white card in a precon? [[Teferi's Protection]]. The card is two years old and it's TCGPlayer median is $40. People were clamoring for a reprint within a year of it's release. So even if WotC creates one, good card draw spell for commander, it wouldn't fix the issue white has as a color. You need a density of reasonable card draw, not just one spell.
Ultimately, it comes down to this: when you create a format with different parameters than a game is designed around, don't be surprised when the balance is warped.
Cheers!
EDIT: I should have been more clear with this, my point here is that white won't/doesn't/shouldn't get unconditional card draw, apologies for the lack of clarity.
Posted Oct 28, 2019, 2:11 AM UTC · edited
We just had a thread on this, we don't need another one today.
Also, if the solution is "Just don't play monowhite in commander", that's not a solution.
If you were referring to this thread, I feel that this is different enough to qualify as separate post. If you're referring to something else, I apologize for missing it.
I also wouldn't say that the "solution" is not to play monowhite in commander, I think the solution is to either use the tools that white has that some might consider "unfair" or "unfun" (mld, tax, etc.) or to at the very least accept that you might not win as many games. I think it's unreasonable to expect WotC to balance what are effectively separate two games with the same card pool.
Considering EDH is a very social and often more casual format, telling people they need to allow 'unfun' playstyles just isn't viable.
I don't expect to win every game with a monowhite deck....but I want to be able to play one without having to worry that by turn 5 I'll be out of cards and top decking for the rest of the game.
Also, the cards you need to make monowhite viable are sooo expensive. A budget monowhite deck is just hell to try and play.
I don't disagree that people can play the game the way they want to, thats fine. But the point of the color pie is that colors have strengths and weaknesses. It's not WotC's fault that other people made a format where white's strengths aren't as good and its weaknesses are particularly egregious. I also agree that the cards needed to make monowhite more consistent are too expensive, but that's more a reprint issue than a design issue.
You're just as unhelpful as you claim op is! Well done
If you're referring to this one, I feel that this is different enough to qualify for a separate post. If you're referring to something else, I apologize for missing it.