r/EDH•
BMM33

Why White Doesn't Need Card Draw: On the Nature of Game Design

DISCUSSION

Some people might not like this post, but I think a lot of people here need to hear it. White doesn't get card draw. White won't get card draw. It's the same thing as red not getting enchantment removal. It's just not in the color pie. And sure, some people will nitpick and say that red got [[Enchanter's Bane]], but I'd counter that white has had cards like [[Tithe]], [[Gift of Estates]], and the ever-present [[Land Tax]] for quite a while, which are all forms of card draw.

 

Now some people might complain that these cards aren't "real card draw", to which you would be correct. White doesn't get "real card draw". But the problem isn't where white fits in the color pie, the problem is the difference in design philosophy. WotC makes cards primarily for Standard and limited. We can disregard limited here, as cards designed for limited generally don't have a place in constructed, and that's fine. But Standard cards are designed to fit in not only a specific environment, but also within a specific game setup: two players, twenty life, sixty cards. And there's nothing wrong with playing other ways, I myself love EDH, CanLander, and Modern, among plenty of other formats.

 

But why is EDH special? White sees plenty of play in other, non-Standard formats. Well in two player, twenty life formats, white's strengths matter more. Small creatures don't mean a lot in EDH when there's 3 opponents with 40 life each. Sure, cards like [[Thalia, Guardian of Thraben]] still have powerful abilities, but not every creature is or should be Thalia. White's life gain cards don't matter nearly as much when you start at 40 life. Yes, you can build decks around gaining life, with incredibly strong payoffs, but cards like [[Revitalize]] that saw fair amounts of play in their standard environments mean nothing to commander players. White does still have some advantages, like strong creature, artifact, and enchantment removal, but that alone doesn't a deck make. Now, one of white's greatest strengths is Mass Land Destruction (yes, there are only a few cards that do it, but those that do are very good at it). But the pervasive culture of EDH makes it so that a lot of people don't want to play or, perhaps more aptly, play against, MLD. And that's okay. Stax falls into a similar category, with white having plenty of good taxing/lockdown cards ([[Thalia, Guardian of Thraben]], [[Thalia, Heretic Cathar]], [[Rule of Law]], [[Ghostly Prison]], [[Spirit of the Labyrinth]], the new [[Deafenening Silence]]), but very few players want to play with or against stax in EDH. And that's okay. But if you want to play in a way that cards aren't primarily designed for, then you have to accept what that means.

 

Now some people might say, what about Commander Precons? After all, they are made specifically for our non-standard ruleset. And while that's true, WotC still can't willfully break the color pie. Sure, mistakes happen, but we can't pretend like we can design breaks (or really even bends) in good faith. And even in precons, WotC still has to make considerations for other formats. Multiplayer sets are known for producing some wildly powerful cards for Legacy (and occasionally Vintage). See [[True-Name Nemesis]] and [[Council's Judgement]]. True-Name is, quite frankly, not that good in EDH (it's not unplayable imo, but it's not on my shortlist of blue cards to include in any given deck), and while Council's Judgement is still quite good in EDH, both it and True-Name are significantly more powerful in Legacy. WotC doesn't, and can't, design cards in a vacuum.

 

But what if WotC did design a good white card draw spell? Well that doesn't solve the issue unfortunately. Let's assume it ticks all the boxes we need it to: it won't see play in other formats so the only driving force is EDH, it's generically strong enough to not be pigeon-holed into one strategy, and it's put in a precon. Sounds great right? Well, maybe not. For starters, this is one card. If the only card draw spell you put in your mono-blue deck was [[Rhystic Study]], how good would your draw be? Not very. This doesn't fix the issue that white doesn't have good card draw, it makes one auto-include card that every white deck should be playing. You know what happened the last time we got a generically powerful white card in a precon? [[Teferi's Protection]]. The card is two years old and it's TCGPlayer median is $40. People were clamoring for a reprint within a year of it's release. So even if WotC creates one, good card draw spell for commander, it wouldn't fix the issue white has as a color. You need a density of reasonable card draw, not just one spell.

 

Ultimately, it comes down to this: when you create a format with different parameters than a game is designed around, don't be surprised when the balance is warped.

 

Cheers!

 

EDIT: I should have been more clear with this, my point here is that white won't/doesn't/shouldn't get unconditional card draw, apologies for the lack of clarity.

Posted Oct 28, 2019, 2:11 AM UTC · edited

2184
AndyDaMage•

We just had a thread on this, we don't need another one today.

Also, if the solution is "Just don't play monowhite in commander", that's not a solution.

15
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

If you were referring to this thread, I feel that this is different enough to qualify as separate post. If you're referring to something else, I apologize for missing it.

 

I also wouldn't say that the "solution" is not to play monowhite in commander, I think the solution is to either use the tools that white has that some might consider "unfair" or "unfun" (mld, tax, etc.) or to at the very least accept that you might not win as many games. I think it's unreasonable to expect WotC to balance what are effectively separate two games with the same card pool.

2
AndyDaMage•

Considering EDH is a very social and often more casual format, telling people they need to allow 'unfun' playstyles just isn't viable.

I don't expect to win every game with a monowhite deck....but I want to be able to play one without having to worry that by turn 5 I'll be out of cards and top decking for the rest of the game.

Also, the cards you need to make monowhite viable are sooo expensive. A budget monowhite deck is just hell to try and play.

3
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I don't disagree that people can play the game the way they want to, thats fine. But the point of the color pie is that colors have strengths and weaknesses. It's not WotC's fault that other people made a format where white's strengths aren't as good and its weaknesses are particularly egregious. I also agree that the cards needed to make monowhite more consistent are too expensive, but that's more a reprint issue than a design issue.

3
counterstance•

You're just as unhelpful as you claim op is! Well done

2
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

If you're referring to this one, I feel that this is different enough to qualify for a separate post. If you're referring to something else, I apologize for missing it.

1
Scubasage#BanFlash•

The answer is to make multiplayer specific cards, similar to the battlebond lands. Boom, problem solved.

They need to start doing something about White in EDH. It's strengths are garbage in this format, it's the only color whose weakness is a major game component (drawing cards) as opposed to a minor one, and EDH is the most popular format, having recently surpassed Limited IIRC. Even if I'm remembering incorrectly, it's still the 2nd most popular format, and it's not even close, Limited and EDH are far and away more popular than anything else. They've basically designed a game with 5 colors where only 4 colors can be played, and the 5th is exclusively a support color to add like 4-5 total cards in decks that run it.

13
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I think the idea of multiplayer specific cards is really interesting. It does allow them to create cards that are functionally exclusive to commander, and there is a lot of room to play there. That being said, I'm not sure that it's a good answer to this. After all, if white can get card draw in commander, then what's the point of the color pie? What makes colors different? (Also, I'd nitpick that they didn't design a game with 5 colors where only 4 can be played, they designed a game with 5 colors and other people created a format where only 4 can be played, but that's neither here nor there.)

-1†
Scubasage#BanFlash•

Every other color's weakness is a minor game element. Red and Black don't deal with Enchantments. Green has troubles with Creatures. Blue has troubles with Planeswalkers. White has trouble with card draw, a baseline function that is necessary to play the game. You see the issue here? If the color pie relies on every color having a minor weakness and White having a major one, then the color pie needs to be overhauled because the current design is unacceptable. They used to say Red had issues with card draw and then spent the past 2-3 years fixing that. However they refuse to do the same for White, flat out.

4
Bdudud•

I think saying the colourpie is majorly flawed is a bit disingenuous. The trouble with white is not a result of bad game design but the fact that EDH is so different to traditional magic so the same balancing techniques don't work. I still want White to be improved but the colourpie should remain.

6
Scubasage#BanFlash•

It is majorly flawed. Just because the problems are on a smaller scale doesn't change the fundamental nature of the problems. Objectively, having issues with card draw is miles worse than having issues with answering a specific type of permanent, which is the "weakness" of ALL the other colors. It doesn't matter if the issues with card draw don't come up often enough in other formats. It doesn't matter if the games don't last long enough for the issues to break the color's back. The problem is a fundamental one, and that's why the current design of the color pie is bad and broken.

1†
Quantext609•

Black don't deal with Enchantments

Black's thing is more artifacts than enchantments now. See [[mire in misery]]

1
MTGCardFetcher•

mire in misery - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
Scubasage#BanFlash•

Black has two cards that answer artifacts and only one that answers enchantments.

[[Gate to Phyrexia]] and [[Phyrexian Tribute]]

1
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

The issue here is that card draw isn't a baseline function that is necessary to play the game. Card draw is a baseline function that is necessary to play commander. It's unreasonable to expect WotC to restructure their game and design philosophy for a format they didn't make.

-2†
captainnermy•

Nah man even aggro decks play stuff like [[Light Up the Stage]]. If you aren’t drawing cards, you aren’t playing cards, and so you’re not really doing anything. This is just amplified in commander where players have more life and games go longer.

Because white has no easy way to draw cards, once a mono white player has played out their opening hand they are at a strong disadvantage for the rest of the game, because while players in other colors refill their hands, giving them new threats to play and new answers, the white player has to hope they topdeck the right card.

Card advantage is a fundamental part of the game that all decks need to acknowledge to be competitive.

3
Scubasage#BanFlash•

No, card draw is a baseline function to play the game, full stop. If you do not draw cards, you cannot play cards since you won't have access to them. Commander makes the lack more apparent, but it's present in other formats too.

2
ToxitoxiNo pain, no gain•

But why is EDH special? White sees plenty of play in other, non-Standard formats. Well in two player, twenty life formats, white's strengths matter more.

The Starcity Atlanta Modern Open top 16 had 2 decks including White. Only 1 of them in the top 8.

This weekend's Vintage Challenge top 8 had 2 Elesh Norns in dredge reanimator and 1 copy of Monastery Mentor as the only White main deck cards, though things got a bit rosier when including sideboards.

Zero White cards in the last Legacy Challenge top 8.

White's not really in a good place right now even outside EDH.

9
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

That's fair, though I think using Vintage as a barometer of color power isn't totally fair given old cards' history of breaking the color pie and creating some colors (looking at blue) that are so much better than others. That being said, the issues that white has in EDH are not the same issues it has in other formats. Legacy isn't exactly clamoring for white draw engines.

1
036Gooddaysir036•

Each color has it's own unique form for card draw. White's simply needs to be expanded.

One thing white has going for it more than any other color is Tax.

If there were white specific cards that were printed to have the following effect it would start to solve the issue.

An effect like:

Whenever an opponent draws a card other than the first card they draw each turn, draw a card unless that opponent pays 1. 

I disagree with the notion that white doesn't need card draw. It just needs to be leveraged through the color's strengths.

8
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I don't disagree that white needs card advantage. But I'm not sure that it needs to come in the form of card draw. WotC seems to have been making an attempt at stuff like this recently (see [[Brought Back]]), though it's not quite great. I would prefer them have more creative forms of card advantage than just drawing cards. That being said, I do appreciate the idea of incorporating white's themes like taxing into it. I think this kind of effect would be okay, I just feel like people keep clamoring for something a little more powerful and a little more generic. I also think that just printing one card doesn't solve the issue (see my paragraph in the op about it), but you can't have a multitude of cards that draw if you don't start somewhere.

1
MTGCardFetcher•

Brought Back - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
036Gooddaysir036•

Thanks for the reply! I 100% agree that 1 card definitely isnt a fix. If anything it just turns into [[Smothering Tithe]] where it just becomes an annoying auto include because it is so good. I do appreciate the forms of card advantage that have been introduced. Sun Titan effects like on [[Sevinne's Reclamation]] are excellent.

1
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

Agreed!

1
Pannanja•

OP you are talking about the color pie like it is some sacred design that cannot be touched for fear of destroying the game. It's not. The color pie is a design strategy intended to provide flavor and strategy. It's a pie of strengths and weaknesses, not cans and cannots.

Card draw is not a binary color attribute. Blue has way better card draw than red. Almost all red's card draw comes in the form of wheeling or looting, which have significant drawbacks compared to blue's card draw options. Red and black have access to some ramp but not like green. WotC could easily give white a set of minor, conditional card draw options that don't solve the problems of going mono white in commander, but alleviate them enough to make it fun to play if people want.

Imagine a white enchantment that draws you a card at the beginning of your upkeep but you sac it after 3 turns. Does that mean there is no point in going Azorius? Of course not. Any deck with blue is going to have better card draw, but at least white isn't lagging so far behind that it is just not fun to play. Could players abuse that card? Sure! They could bounce it or flicker it or recur it and get card draw from it all game! And if they want to build a deck around that, it would probably suck. Because it will always be way worse than any number of blue cards that will keep your hand topped off with ease. White's color pie identity is not harmed.

The problem with cards like [[land tax]] and [[smothering tithe]] isn't that they give white ramp, it's that they are they only ways to give white ramp. And both of them are highly conditional. I don't think they give anyone the impression that white has better ramp than green. And your comparison to [[teferi's protection]] is totally unbalanced. Teferi's protection costs $40 because it is an insanely strong card, not because it is the only option in white. It is just the only option for what it does. Period. Giving white a couple of mediocre card draw cards is not even close to the same thing as making another teferi's protection.

One of red's color pie characteristics is it's non-interaction with enchantments, right? And yet [[chaos warp]] allows it to destroy enchantments. And there are plenty of artifacts that can destroy target permanent [[meteor golem]] that you could supplement that with. The beauty of chaos warp is that it gives red a way to deal with a problematic enchantment in commander while retaining a red flavor. It's no [[swords to plowshares]] though.

So the question isn't whether white needs card draw for commander, it's how can WotC create card draw that doesn't mess with other formats and retains white's flavor. And you pointed out that WotC didn't invent commander so they shouldn't be held accountable for maintaining it. Well, they didn't invent EDH, but technically they did create commander. And they have been supporting it for years, and it is their biggest MTG playerbase. So do they have to support it? No. Would they be dumb as hell to abandon it? Yes. They aren't responsible for fixing commander because we decide they are. They are responsible for fixing commander because it is literally their job to make a game that people will want to play, and right now they are ignoring a major flaw in it's design. And yes, they do design commander now. They create commander specific cards all the time, and they are the only people with the authority to do so.

8
MTGCardFetcher•
1
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I should have been more clear in my post. I don't think white can't have card advantage, I just think that a lot of the way people talk about white getting it is through very mundane card draw spells that wouldn't make sense in white. As far as I'm concerned white should get conditional card draw spells, or at the very least better card advantage that isn't necessarily draw-based.

As for the Teferi's Protection comparison, perhaps I'm wrong but I feel that people want something that is generically powerful. And while very few cards could be as generically powerful as Teferi's Protection, some hypothetical new card draw spell could have a similar demand with the same supply.

1
BounceBurnBuffSmashios, Akymna, Tanuse•

We need to discount the colour pie when designing cards for Commander, specifically precon cards. The weaknesses are too pronounced and I'll actually go with mono black as an example. It either does the most tutored degenerate nonsense, or it will flop like a wet towel to hate enchantments it has little to interact with. [[Rest In Peace]] in pretty much the best 2 mana you will ever spend against a mono black deck, followed by a wealth of other grave hate or "can't search library" effects.

They've made a step, albeit a club footed shuffle, towards fixing this with [[Mire in Misery]], but that is so inconsistent it isn't worth the deck slot. I don't think black should be able to answer artifacts, but given that Red is able to along with white and green, black should pick up some slack for enchantments. Even if it is a Mire in Misery effect that doesn't also allow creature sac, that would be a massive step up.

White will continue to suffer in EDH as a mono identity until card draw comes to it, being forced into its degenerate niche of board wipes and land destruction to compete. This neither makes for enjoyable gameplay patterns, since we're on about design here, nor effective ways of leveling the playing field since white also happens to recover the worst from these effects. Green has been overwhelmingly showered with gifts for near enough a decade of sets, pushing it far above the rest in its variance. Its draw is probably 2nd best at this point, noncreature removal stapled to threats, ramp in a whole different league to the others. If you're worried about the homogenization of the colour pie, it's already here. Green now has a solid competitive tier counterspell for protection in [[Veil of Summer]], the best Cantrip in Standard with [[Once Upon a Time]], a mass draw spell THAT LET'S YOU PLAY SOMETHING FOR FREE in [[Rishkar's Expertise]]. It boggles the mind that so many are so timid about giving white basic tools for the format whilst the gluttonous green giant half-chokes a "here here" between its meals.

3
MTGCardFetcher•

#####

######

####

Rest In Peace - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Mire in Misery - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Veil of Summer - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Once Upon a Time - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Rishkar's Expertise - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I'm just not sure that discounted the color pie makes for good game design. After all, if you remove the color pie, what is magic? The issue is that white shouldn't get unconditional draw, but people won't be happy until all of the possible mono-white decks have their own conditional draw spells. It's not an insurmountable issue, but certainly one that takes a lot more time than other issues will, and will likely remain a latent problem for years.

-1
BounceBurnBuffSmashios, Akymna, Tanuse•

Again though, look at green. All you have stated is already an issue that green now embodies. It hasn't taken years since EDH took off for it to be relevant, and now it has a free spell that digs 5 deep. It also now has the Song of the Dryads effect being explored as a fixture for its removal suite to deal with creatures thanks to [[Kenrith's Transformation]]. You cannot hold white to some false purity of game design whilst living in a world where green already breaks the back of said design over its knee with each new set.

3
MTGCardFetcher•

Kenrith's Transformation - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I have made no statements that recent green design doesn't break WotC's general design tenets. I also won't disagree as it's obvious that green's "weakness" to creatures has been waning as of late, but this is ultimately a red herring and not totally relevant.

 

That being said, design tenets are allowed to change. While I don't necessarily agree with it, green has been getting more answers to creatures as answering creatures (beyond just having bigger ones) has become more important. Similarly, blue has lost shares of it's color pie over the years, and gained others. White's design doesn't have to be totally static, but I think just giving white unconditional draw is not the answer. It should fit in with the colors other themes, be it life gain (see [[Dawn of Hope]]), or taxes, or some other theming.

1
MTGCardFetcher•

Dawn of Hope - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
ichik•

I think what a lot of people overlook is that in practice white doesn't even have best answers (the reasoning behind it not getting the draw in the color pie philosophy). After you tick the obligatory PtE and StP and WoGs and such the modern removal from White is very restrictive, rarely exiles and mostly hits creatures or only one type of non-land permanent. That's not good enough for eternal format, especially when blue suddenly gets instant-speed removal that bypasses hexproof and all kinds of protection slapped on a cantrip.

3
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I think that's the point that MaRo was making about "best answers" when he said "It can deal with any problem, if it knows what it is, but has the worst flexibility." In his eyes (not necessarily that I agree with this design) if white had unconditional, powerful card draw, it's ability to answer anything would make it too good.

1
ichik•

See, that's my point, if you look at stereotypical Azorius decklist it isn't using Blue draw to utilize those inflexible answers, because it is very far from optimal game plan.

2
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I'm not sure what you're getting at here. Perhaps I'm mistaken, but every UW control deck I've seen is explicitly using blue cantrips and draw spells to get to inflexible white spells (swords, path, wraths, stony, RiP, etc)

1
RegirexCertified Jankmaster•

But white NEEDS card draw. You really can’t deny this. It’s falling behind every other mono color simply because of the fact it can’t ramp or draw cards

2
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

The point I'm making is that it's falling behind in commander, not magic as a whole. Commander was designed in such a way that makes white bad. WotC shouldn't be held accountable for a color not being good in a format they didn't make.

2
RegirexCertified Jankmaster•

The commander precons are a perfect opportunity to make a good white card draw engine. But we haven’t gotten one, even in the mono white precon.

4
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

They'd be a perfect opportunity if not for the color pie, yes.

4
RegirexCertified Jankmaster•

MaRo said that white can’t have card draw because of all of it’s answers. Blue has counterspells, tons of instant speed removal (even instant speed wipes) and they get a ton of card draw. White isn’t even able to function properly in EDH because of this. It gets screwed after a wipe, as it has no way of ramping lands besides [[land tax]] and [[weathered wayfarer]], both old, expensive cards. Color pie be damned, colors shouldn’t be objectively weaker than other colors. That’s the situation we have

5
captainnermy•

It doesn’t matter if they didn’t make it; Commander is now one of the most popular formats in the game.

Your solution is “Monowhite decks are bad in EDH, this is fine, they shouldn’t even try to fix this”? Should the people who like white just suck it up and not play commander? I just don’t understand where you’re coming from.

3
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I suppose I should have been more clear in my op about what a solution I like actually is. I think WotC should work on card advantage that isn't necessarily card draw. It looks like they've started to shift their focus this way (see [[Brought Back]]), though they haven't quite gotten to something that's really good yet.

0
MTGCardFetcher•

Brought Back - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
Aquafier•

The issue isn't that colours are restricted from a field, it's that not getting card draw is infinitely more crippling than not getting a certain type of removal like the other colours

2
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I don't disagree, but white's card draw should be conditional in some fashion. The whole point of blue is that it gets unconditional card draw, while other colors card draw require something extra (life for black, creatures for green, limited-time access for red). White's card draw needs to be tied to it's theming (and they've recently given us a pretty good one in [[Dawn of Hope]]). The only issue with that is people will never be happy until each and every possible white theme has multiple draw spells made for it, which will take a very long time to design and implement.

1
Aquafier•

You cant make everyone happy always, but I was rather concerned with MaRo's philosophy on card draw in white. Seems like a poor mindset on how restrictive it has to be

3
MTGCardFetcher•

Dawn of Hope - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
TinyTank27•

I've said it before, and I'll say it again: the color pie should exist to serve the game's balance, not the other way around. Right now there's a huge imbalance and the things necessary to fix it are immediately shot down as not in the color pie. To which I say re-examine the color pie and balance the game.

Green has historically not had creature removal in its color pie but it got fight when creatures started to become important enough that having removal for them was a necessity for every color. It's still the worst at it but it at least has some options now.

Ultimately, it comes down to this: when you create a format with different parameters than a game is designed around, don't be surprised when the balance is warped.

When said format becomes one of the most popular ways to play your game and you're designing products specifically for that format that's a pretty poor excuse for not trying to balance it.

And yes, I'm aware that 20 life formats need to be accounted for but it is entirely possible to create a card for EDH that sees no play in other formats. Inspiring Commander in Arena, for example. Would be a great start if we got that in paper Magic.

2
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I actually would like to see [[Inspiring Commander]] printed in paper for Commander, it's the exact kind of card that fits. The point is that white shouldn't get unconditional card draw. Every color (other than blue, which is the point) has some extra cost or limiting factor for it's draw: green requires creatures, black costs life, red has limited-time access to those cards. White does have a fair few draw engine spells, but because they are narrow to white's different themings (life gain has [[Dawn of Hope]], taxing has [[Alms Collector]]), people still feel like white doesn't have any draw.

2
MTGCardFetcher•

Inspiring Commander - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Dawn of Hope - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
Alms Collector - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
pokk3n•

Card advantage is not card draw. White needs more stoneforge mystic and recruiter of the guard and as you said tithe type effects. Efficient quality cards that do themely things to generate advantage.

I never feel limited in white for getting cards. It's more that its bombs are bad and its ramp is weak.

The bombs are really the biggest issue. White has way fewer torment of hailfire, genesis wave, crater hoof, rise of the dark realms, expropriate, etc. Must counter game winning spells.

2
sharkism•

I think your notion that WotC primarily prints card for standard just doesn't lead to nowhere. With horizons we just had an entire set which is not standard legal and on top of all the cards in standard sets which are clearly not meant to work in standard there are plenty of supplementary products.

1
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

Sure, they do print cards, even whole sets not for standard. I'd argue that limited still prevails over the majority of cards in non-standard booster sets, but that still leaves non-booster supplemental products. Regardless, they have to juggle legacy and the color pie against these designs.

1
garbearly104•

They 100% do not care about legacy

1
stenti36•

While I fundamentally agree, your initial points aren't quite accurate.

Normal rotating sets are generally designed standard and limited. Wizards will take into account other formats and do some tweaking (especially when it comes to general mechanics). But that is one thing. The yearly non standard sets are designed around whatever they want them to be (generally I would say mostly modern, then commander). There are also the pre-cons you mention.

If card draw is the answer to mono-W problems, then wizards should attach card draw to things white already does. Although it would be stupid powerful, a card like rhystic study, but instead of card draw for spell cast, it would be "creatures can't attack you unless the opponents allow you to draw a card per creature" or something like that. Or something that affects tutors "draw a card each time an opponent searches their library". And then release those types of cards in the yearly set. Don't even let them be legal in standard rotation.

1
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I completely agree here. I do believe there is something akin the first effect you described, though I'm not at my computer right now so I'm not certain. I wasn't abundantly clear in my OP, but this is the kind of draw I think white should get. Something that fits into it's themes, just like black, green, and red all have.

1
stenti36•

But I think that it should be more limiting. Yes, white should get more card draw. But there shouldn't be anything unconditional about it. It either should be (considering current card designs) highly conditional/low draw power, or 6+ cmc.

Sadly the time has well past for those powerful affects like Rhystic Study at those low cmc levels to exist.

There is always [[alms collector]].

2
MTGCardFetcher•

alms collector - (G) (SF) (txt) (ER)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
BMM33OPNeheb | Sidisi | Bruna•

I strongly agree. And of course, there is always Alms Collector.

Though as an aside, I'm still not sure why Rhystic Study is a good card. It is, at its core, a punisher cards. And punisher cards are inherently bad. Is a one-sided sphere of resistance really that good? It only sees play because people don't pay, and I'm not sure why people don't.

1
stenti36•

Rhystic study is one of the best cards in blue. No joke. The common thing about every single deck is that spells are cast. So it's either resource denial by 1 mana tax, or card draw. The amount of card draw is stupid on the card for three cmc.

2
JetsNovocastrianGive me all the combos!•

Thank you for posting this! For the last 2 years I've argued this exact point, both in reality and online. Many people simply fail to grasp the design philosophy of Magic: the Gathering is why we're playing the most popular TCG in human history! Breaking the philosophy unbalances the game, and we all know what happens to card games when they become unbalanced ...

If you decide to play a mono-coloured deck, then you need to accept the restrictions that come with that selection.

-2