What is considered evidence of forced entry when claiming bulgary?

So I am filing a claim with my insurance for stolen goods from my car in my apartment complex parking.

​

The adjuster denied because she received no proof of forced entry to the leased premises. She then sent me this

“Burglary” means the act of stealing Covered Property by forcible entry into the securely locked leased premises provided there are visible marks of such forcible entry upon the exterior of the leased premises. The mere absence of a lock or padlock does not constitute visible marks of forcible entry.

So what is meant by forced entry proof? Do I have to go around and check every gate in the community and look for damages? Items stolen are worth more than $2500 and my deductible is $100 so it is so worth it to file a claim.

​

Please advise me.

Posted Oct 29, 2019, 7:11 PM UTC

29
PhotoJim99P&C broker (SK/AB, Canada)•

A broken window; pry marks on the door; ...

If you left your car unlocked and someone snatched things from within, that's not forced entry, and some policies require you to have signs of forced entry to cover theft/burglary losses.

7
asuredditOP•

My gas cap was broken and my car was locked but its a 1979 car so it's easy to find ways to open it. I have included a police report too.

Do I have any rights?

0
PhotoJim99P&C broker (SK/AB, Canada)•

Wouldn't hurt. But if there are no signs of forced entry, the insurer would still have the right to deny the loss.

If your car is that easy to break into, it seems imprudent to keep anything of value in it, unfortunately. But people do (many; I don't mean to pick on you). Insurance, alas, isn't intended to be a substitute for ordinary care.

5
Zendrifta•

You posted about this a couple days ago right?

"Securely locked leased premises".

Step one is whether the loss occurred on the leased premises. You said your parking spot was noted on your lease as part of the premises you were leasing but I wouldn't expect a court to say that just because your lease says you can use the pool or common areas that your policy would apply there. It seems to mean that portion of the premises that you're entitled to lock others out of, namely your apartment and your car (while it's in that spot).

provided there are visible marks of such forcible entry upon the exterior of the leased premises.

So.. broken window, pried lock, door bent or paint marred from using a wedge device, or a slashed convertible top, etc... If you left the car unlocked it seems pretty open and shut that it's not covered with that language. You could probably sell a judge on "forced entry" if somebody used a lock pick or some sort of electronic device, but you'd probably have to have them on video to prevail.

Sounds like there's a bit of a loophole with your theft coverage. Some policies cover your stuff "anywhere in the world", in which case you'd probably have coverage here, though if "mysterious disappearance" is not a covered peril you'd still have the burden of showing that your stuff was more likely "stolen" than "lost".

3
asuredditOP•

Yes I posted about it few days ago.

English is not my first language but isn't "marks of forcible entry upon the ext of leased premises" meant that damage to the gates and not the vehicle? If its to the vehicle then I do have ton of evidence but for the gates then it might be impposible for me to know which gate due to the size of the community.

1
AudreyGolightly79•

If you are filing for items stolen from your secured car and they're asking for signs of forced entry, they're referring to forced entry into the car. Broken window, door lock damage, pried door frames, etc.

4
asuredditOP•

I see. Okay, I believe I have enough evidence for this.

I have one more question. If the adjuster was not helpful in looking into my evidence or acted in bad faith, how do I go about it? And where do I report it?

The insurance are not the ones who are contacting me. The assigned another company to handle the claim (both not in my state).

Thank you.

1
AudreyGolightly79•

With the company I work for, we don't "contract" out claims handling so I'm not sure how that works. With us, if you're unsatisfied with the adjuster you can request a 2nd opinion or to work with their claims manager.

2
Zendrifta•

but isn't "marks of forcible entry upon the ext of leased premises" meant that damage to the gates and not the vehicle?

I would presume that if this ended-up in court that a judge would interpret it to mean your apartment or your car, and only the car while it's actually parked in that leased spot.

Unless the gate opens only to your apartment or only to your parking spot it would probably be considered a common area and not part of the "leased premises" covered by your policy.

1