Comp should have a "forfeit" option.

Discussion

To forfeit a match one whole team would have to unanimously vote to forfeit. With this feature a 4v1 3v1 game could be ended long before the whole game played out.

Edit: forgot they changed it back to 3v3. Also the forfeit feature would only come into play if one team is down 1 or 2 players. Not if both teams are full.

Posted Oct 31, 2019, 8:56 AM UTC · edited

7523
AudioRebellion•

Yeah i'm surprised they haven't added that in.

You must havent played comp in a while because it's no longer 4v4 its 3v3 currently.

20
OriginalSweeperbotOPHave you seen my broom?•

I actually have, but I'm not use to the 3v3 thing again. I wish they never changed it to 4v4, it should have always been 3v3.

7
blakeavon:GB: Gambit Classic•

Oh please no, given how easy and quickly some people here are at accepting defeat, I dont not want my gaming sessions ruined just because I am team with people who cant lose with dignity.

Seriously, imagine you are two rounds down and getting decimated, to some people that is game over. To me that is when i have learned what i up against and learn to start countering better. Even in solo queue I have won sooooo many games being down two or three, compared to how many I have been decimated on.

If I had two quitters on my team and they had the right to vote, those games would have been loses. Some people need to grow up and learn how to play better, AND they need to learn how to get defeated. They will learn neither if they accept defeat.

12
OriginalSweeperbotOPHave you seen my broom?•

Unanimous.... meaning the whole team would have to vote to forfeit.

12
OKLISTENHERE:V: Vanguard's Loyal // Y'all just fear the Praxic Fire•

Right, but if 2 people vote to forfeit, and the other doesn't, the 2 aren't going to actually give a shit at all.

8
rossomesauce•

Exactly, this is what happens in games like League of Legends with FF systems. You run into players that want to FF because they decide that the game is over and unwinnable. They don't care that their teammates voted No on the FF and want to try and clutch a win. They stop playing seriously or throw the game to get it over with.

6
C0C0TheCat•

This is what happens anyway. Voting system or not. And with the snowballing in crusible i get it. Make crusible less snowbally and this wont happen.

5
-BoBaFeeT-:AD: Team Bread (dmg04)•

How the fuck is that any different than if they couldn't vote?

You already hit the nail on the head, if they are committed to the loss, you're fucked either way.

Might as well end it sooner.

That argument is as baseless as the dudes who hate matchmaking, but continue to use it as if that's the only way to play...

CHOICE IS ALWAYS A GOOD THING. STOP IT.

1
sayroksho•

this, and even if the game is 2v3 you have an advantage in lives if you can trade or take 2 with you so giving up early is bad

1
fxbeta•

Yes, but ONLY when your team is shorthanded (if a player leaves, for example). Otherwise you will have some whiny players who will vote to forfeit as soon as they are down one point, and will then idle or play against their own team if they don't get their way. This is what happens in other games like Rocket League. If the option is only there when the team is short a player or two it may be a great way to avoid frustration for the unlucky team, and not waste everyone's time.

8
-BoBaFeeT-:AD: Team Bread (dmg04)•

I've never had a team successfully vote to forfeit in RL on rage alone.

That's making a mountain of a molehill.

So a few people abuse the system, that's easy to track based on stats. Bungie already takes that into account before throwing the ban hammer at folks.

If people want to abuse the system, that's fine as long as it's a small percentage. Change needs to happen anyway.

4
OriginalSweeperbotOPHave you seen my broom?•

Yes! This is exactly what I meant!

2
Completely_Swedish•

I haven't even thought about that before.

But honestly, not only should they add a forfeit option to all Crucible activities. That should be the only way you can leave a match.

If you are going to abandon your team by rage quitting, the least we can do to them is wasting their time by having to restart the game.

5
Storm_Worm5364•

That should be the only way you can leave a match.

People would just Alt-F4/close the game.

3
Completely_Swedish•

Well, duh.

That's why I wrote the least we can do to punish them is wasting their time.

2
-BoBaFeeT-:AD: Team Bread (dmg04)•

That's why you force people to rejoin a match when they launch the game.

I'd rather go 1v6 and fuck over 5 deserters vs new teammates

(Also, I think we can all agree that joining a match that's being stomped is never fun, so it's a blessing in disguise.)

2
negotiat3r•

Would you show the amount of active forfeit votes to players or would you hide it from them unless everybody felt the same way?

2
OriginalSweeperbotOPHave you seen my broom?•

Well there would only be at most 2 voters, so there wouldn't really be a reason to not show what the other person voted.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
E00000B6FAF25838•

This would screw with Bungie's time-to-progress design. The games take as long as they do because if they were shorter, you'd get wins/progress faster. Survival would be just as good with first to three, but that would make it too short.

I've been playing like 5-7 hours a day for the past week and the thing that's been getting to me is just how little the game respects the player's time, and it's wholly intentional.

1
Robtachi•

This is a really, really solid suggestion. There needs to be a way for people who get unfairly disadvantaged by a quitter teammate to not suffer for that by getting mercilessly farmed AND lose glory as added insult. Similarly, people on the other end of a forfeit should still be rewarded with the win but not get the chance to just unfairly stomp their opponent.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
AlienVoice•

Definitely, then I can just log in and forfeit 3 times a week instead of just getting stomped 3 games.

0
samstownstranger•

Yes please. I'm not cammycakes, just trying to play not make montages. As if it's not bad enough that I'm gonna lose glory because I'm loaded into the game 3v1, I have to sit there and get destroyed or suicide off the cliff. Either one is a gigantic waste of everyone's time.

-1