Is it possible to mix too quiet?

Info before post - I'm using Ableton, I'm making electronic music (not really edm though, more hip-hop), this isn't me MIXING or MASTERING this in the writing phase and me putting a limiter to make it loud for a very rough export...this is all irrelevant for the mix cause when that happens I'm gonna scrap everything and re-mix properly

Basically I've noticed that when I'm writing music I have a massive tendency to balance by lowering track volumes rather than raising...this results in a super quiet mix and when I put a limiter on the master I'm maxing out the input gain and lowering the limiter threshold as much as possible and it's STILL not gain reducing

So I've started putting utilities before the limiter just increasing gain, without any of that I'm peaking at like -32 on the master channel

My question is....does increasing gain with a utilities affect the mix in anyway? Or if it's quiet it doesn't matter...mix super quiet and then increase input gain to the limiter?

Posted Nov 3, 2019, 11:35 AM UTC

717

So I've started putting utilities before the limiter just increasing gain, without any of that I'm peaking at like -32 on the master channel

This is absolutely fine. The mixing summing engine is using 32 bit floating point. That means you could be at –60 dBFS or at +60 dBFS internally, and as long as the plug-ins are being hit with the correct level and you're not clipping the master buss, then you're all good.

I'd suggest using more gain plugins throughout your mix instead of just one, since many effects such as compressors and distortions need a healthy signal level in order to do their thing (just like your limiter does). There is mathematically no degradation to changing gain up or down, even a few dozen times, so don't worry about that.

20
cabalusOP•

That's more what I was getting at, if the level is really low heading in to some plugins will they behave differently?

Edit: I'll give an example, so my kick is currently at -30 dB and it has a saturator...if I turn up/down the track level will the saturator behave differently?

2
braxtons12•

Your plugins are pre-fader, so it will depend on what level your kick is BEFORE you turn it down, but absolutely yes. Any kind of compressor, saturation, or analog modeling/emulating plugin will behave differently based on the input level it's getting.

For example a saturation plugin will saturate a lot more on a high level signal than a low level signal

5
cabalusOP•

Ahhh...this would be pretty relevant for groups then I assume, I use a lot of group processing with a lot of quiet elements in the groups because of the way I explained how I write...however because of that the group processing might be deceiving me and when I go to mix, turn the limiter on the master off and start turning faders within groups up...suddenly it could become overcompressed/saturated whatever because I had them set for the really quiet inputs as I was writing!

Very important info to know hahahaha!

Of course in reality what I'd do for mixing is reset everything so this wouldn't be an issue so much but it's still very useful to know, thank you.

3
braxtons12•

Yes that could happen.

Signal flow and gain staging are very key to getting a solid mix,

But at the end of the day, as long as it sounds good that's what matters!

1

The saturator will behave differently because to distort you need a good signal gain. Come on, this is easy. If you have a guitar amp and your guitar signal coming in is super quiet, it's not going to distort! To distort a signal it has to be loud enough...

But of course if you crank up the digital input on the plugin then it's going to be the same as if the signal had been louder in the first place.

Basically if you like the sound coming from a compressor or distortion that means you set the signal loud enough for the plugin to do its job. If the signal is so low that the compressor or distortion isn't doing anything, it's too low.

The important thing to remember is that digital gain doesn't change the sound. If you need more gain, add a gain plugin or change a fader – there is no degradation. That's it.

2
sonicMayhem•

You could try turning your monitors or headphone level down, which would let you experience the sounds quietly, but the tracks would be louder.

I like to figure out what the lead or most important element is, put that fader at unity with good gain staging, then mix under that.

Or (same principle) turn the master fader down when creating, then back up when exporting. You might find that signal processors work better or differently when the gain is hotter..

8
SoCoMo•

Yep, OP needs to calibrate their monitor setup. Proper gain staging at every level is still important in the digital world.

3
cabalusOP•

It's not about me wanting to work at a low level...it's because say I have a kick and bass...and the kick is louder than the bass

I'd turn down the kick to balance rather than turn up the bass...and I do that across the board...so I end up with a really quiet sessions (in the WRITING phase)

What I'm wondering (which you alluded to) is if because of the low input levels, are some plugins behaving differently?

Which would mean when I DO go to the actual mixing step and start turning everything up it'll sound different because the plugins will behave differently with the higher input levels

2
sonicMayhem•

Yes, as others have said the effects will behave differently at different levels. Perhaps differently enough to affect your writing, given your writing style.

I don't work in Ableton, but generally I aim for peak levels of each channel in the "orange."

To me it just sounds like you could change the way you "gain stage" and mentally adjust for your tendency to turn down.

In the kick and bass example the bass may look like it's peaking the same as the kick, but need a bit of compression to bring the apparent level to where you like it in relation to the kick.

Good luck!

2
iscreamuscreamweallMixing•

If you’re making electronic music in ableton, then putting a gain boost before the final limiter stage shouldn’t matter at all. But you must be mixing pretty quiet 🤔

3
cabalusOP•

Very quiet, and again I'm not doing the actual "mix" process, this is in writing

What I'm wondering is if because I'm writing at such a low level that certain plugins will behave differently, which is deceptive and won't be what it's like once I start actually mixing

2
zeolmusic•

I'm getting somewhat annoyed (don't take this personal, thanks) from reading your comments. You're always saying you only do this in writing. So what's the deal, turn it up afterwards and mix it properly. If you use a compressor for sound design, then apparently it does its job so just gain afterwards. If you are using a compressor for dynamics and balancing: if it's "only writing", why bother with mixing stuff?

I'm not saying this is a wrong way of doing it, but you could simply do a more suitable gainstaging. And if you mix afterwards anyway, why bother?

Again: I'm not hating on you, I just want to give you some food for thoughts. Maybe u are not separating the mixing and writing stages enough, although you say you do in every comment. It is better practice (mostly) to gain stage correctly during writing as well. Try to have an idea of levels during writing and you'll have an easier time mixing.

2
cabalusOP•

My overall question has been answered, is my general practice in writing going to produce something I don't want once I start mixing. The answer was yes it might because of how certain plugins behave from input gain. That's it.

However it's kind of a mute point because when I start mixing I delete all my plugins and rebalance all my levels again. So it WAS irrelevant, but I didn't know that when I asked the question and now I do.

For extra context that might help with some of your frustration: I am not a professional at all, hobbyist at best...so I simply just don't know many things.

As for why am I bothering to mix while writing, well it's more to do with my specific situation, I make music for others at the moment. I like to mix as I go so that I can send and present a somewhat decent idea of my vision for the track. Then if they like it, wanna buy it whatever. I'll finish it off and then do a proper mixdown.

So there is a value for me mixing as I write. Which goes back to why I asked if my practice may be affecting my tracks in some way.

1
gotnolegs•

I've pretty much always done that too. It doesn't matter but it's not a great habit. Try grouping tracks like percussion, drums, synths and then balancing with the groups. It should be an easier process and you'll avoid this

3
dobias01Professional•

My two cents on mix volume, your comps, limiters, etc. Will be affected if your source tracks are too quiet. Proper gain structure is imperative when it comes to mixing, both live and in the studio.

What I tend to do when I get tracks to mix that are too quiet is normalize them. This will read the information on the waveform, and given a ceiling that you set, it will boost the track gain so that the highest peak just hits that ceiling (0db, -3, -6db, etc. Whatever you choose.) Doing this will ensure that you're not under-driving your plugins. That way, if you need a few db of compression, say, you won't need to crank down your threshold all the way to the bottom to achieve it, and your plugins will have more headroom to work with.

1
peepeelandComposer•

Your method of turning down is kind of an old school technique (and a good one), where mixes tend to end up quite open sounding (if you were at the mixing stage). After everything’s balanced, just bring everything up together, or gain plugin, etc. When you do this in the mixing stage, leaving tons of headroom and listening at low volumes, is one way to get very 3-d and open sounding mixes— it’s something about the way we make decisions- compared to mixing super loud. Aaaaanyway...

1