r/Diablo•
ColCabbage

Actual constructive criticism

I have a multiple thousands of hours in Diablo 3 and Reaper of Souls. As well as lots of time in D2 back in the day and in games like PoE. It’s not like I’ve played any of these constantly since release, but they are some of my favorite games and I love coming back to them. And I’m pumped for D4

I have made some long comments responding to some of the threads being posted here that just seem to be mindlessly bashing D3 while singing that d2 is somehow perfection and could never be improved. This is only a slight exaggeration from a lot of what’s being said around this topic.

It’s frustrating and disappointing to see and can at times be disrespectful of what the devs have done and are trying to do. Most importantly it’s not cOnSTrUctIVe.

But I do get peoples love for D2 as I share it, but it’s not a perfect game. Just hope people can realize that there are good lessons to be learned from it as well as D3 and not to yell the devs into no feedback mode so we can all get a game that we can enjoy.

So here are some comparisons/thoughts:

Trading

D2:

Has a variety of item types that have a very low potential of being useful for progression

has trading

Non sanctioned grey market trading exists as it is next to impossible to police this behavior.

Launch D3

Has a narrower variety of items and only certain very rare drops are useful to progress

Has sanctioned RM and gold AHs

Not as much grey market, only for beyond cap trades for perfectly rolled god items

Result

D2

You think you can grind enough to trade for the best items for you, but really you can’t beat the offer of a cash payout with in game goods.

You might get some decent gear together after hunting it down and beating the trade bots to it. Your hopes of having anything awesome rely on paying for it and the bots always get paid

Launch D3

You grind and grind in boring gear until maybe finally one item that is worth a bit drops and you post it for trade.

You get a chunk of gold and use it to buy a whole bunch of poorly rolled gear that has the right skill mods or set bonuses.

Your hopes of having anything awesome rely on paying for it. Or suddenly feeling like you are missing out if you get so lucky that you got a god roll item and don’t sell it for 250$

Also the bots probably are getting all the money here too but blizzard took their cut as well

Trading conclusion

Neither of these are very good or rewarding progression systems. They both result in outside of “game” markets that determine the outcome of character progression. I don’t view that as very “rpg” or “actiony” some people seem convinced that this is somehow a staple of the genre. Or that it’s the hardcore players that get the best stuff, they don’t, the casuals with disposable income get the stuff and the hardcore get to farm it for them. Most players don’t want that.

I do think some form of bartering should be included in D4 but it shouldn’t be so directly tied to your characters power or progression while still having a compelling reason to participate in it. I’ll suggest more specifics later.

Moving on to

Itemization - will try to stick to the merits and drawbacks of each and not how they are tied to trading

D2 Had to touch on this above but yes D2 has more variety in lesser quality items that could be useful. Random stats and varying roll ranges for different item types The number of end game viable builds varies by class but most can clear the hardest content in the game assuming they can get this eclectic mix of gear together

Launch D3

Fairly fixed stat budgets and number of stats by color. Very low variety and unimpactful stats. Legendaries and set items are extremely rare have huge impact and are required for progressing

Early RoS

Same as above but legendaries drop much more frequently, and can be farmed for with some degrees of specificity. Much more possible for a good number to assemble an end game viable build and gear to push into the hardest difficulties on their own.

Later RoS

Sets are focused on more they are given enormous flat damage bonuses even more specificity in gear farming with the cube. We now must use the super sets to get mega ultra legendaries that are stronger than boring old reglegs. Interesting addition of LoN which opens some things up. More in conclusion

Late RoS

First full set is literally mailed to you just for logging in for the season essentially. You just farm every set to get the next and do everything with every build. We can get god roll mega legs that very rarely drop now. More upgradability paths for items

Conclusion:

The most fun I personally had playing RoS seasons was when LoN was enabled by default.

You got the damage bonus of a set with ancient legendary items making non set builds usable and without having to wear the set rings required before.

I felt like I was building my character up always and could work towards a new item or a better version of what I had and both would be impactful vs. a set piece getting upgraded by a couple inconsequential stat increases. Although on the downside the different currencies feel kind of pointless as well as having just one or two and a more robust crafting system that utilized combinations of something that maybe had value in other ways (runes hint hint) might be a cool way to remedy this.

I do think blizzard went a bit far with the set meta though, it was forcing some very specific builds to the top artificially with static numbers that did were not that interesting. That and just giving the items away during seasons just left me feeling underwhelmed.

For D2/ and D3 launch

It’s hard to separate this from the trading section here, but I’ll just say I prefer to actually see an item that I want drop, I really don’t get the same feeling from saving my tuppence to spoil myself with a new piece of gear. It just doesn’t feel like a game.

Character arc

Ya you level up in D2 and that’s the game. In D3 you up the difficulty higher and higher with multiplicative power creep making you stronger instead of your level. They both feel pretty good tbh. At least when you are actually progressing.

In D3 and, presumably, D4, the level up phase is mostly to slowly introduce your character to you. You could, in a more radical move, even decouple this entirely and make all skills and talents acquired in the world, but that might be a bit much. Would be cool for a special league down the road maybe hmmm?

Don’t think having to reroll should be necessary to change a build in D4 if leveling isn’t the progression system as it wasn’t in D3. Having to earn some way of diversifying the talents and skills you can switch between could be good/ and doesn’t have to be tied to level either.

Final thoughts and suggestions

TLDR

D4 looks to be on a pretty good track.

Trading is bad. Limit as much as is necessary to make real world trades not viable. Bartering could be fun for non power related items/ commodities as long as there is a compelling system behind it.

There is something to be said for fun stats on lesser items. I wouldn’t mind allowing some weird combinations, but if it can be wished for it can also just be turned into an intended part of a build with more impactful items.

Along that note. Make sets trash, and even not as many pieces for sure. Not quite along the lines of blackthorns. Just outshined and outperformed by more interesting combinations of legendaries. This also makes the upgrades in power more steady and rewarding instead of “oh well this upgrade doesn’t let me do anything more until I have a 6 piece or a good royal ring” :p

But it needs to be more than you straight up deal 1000% more damage transparently spelled out in that way with no change to play style.

Posted Nov 4, 2019, 12:11 AM UTC

21
AutoModeratorMOD•

This submission has been filtered by AutoModerator and is currently not visible. Returning players should check out the Commonly Asked Questions page which will answer most questions. If not, your submission will be approved shortly pending review by a moderator.

This comment is automated and replies to it are not monitored. Please message the moderators using the link below with any questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1