r/CQB•
OhHeckItsPeck

When is dynamic entry actually useful?

Title, basically. We’ve attacked dynamic entry a lot, and for good reason. But there’s got to be something it’s actually useful for. I’ve heard a lot of people saying it’s a hostage rescue tactic. Is it only good for HR, or is there something else where it has use?

Posted Nov 4, 2019, 10:19 PM UTC

1114
RPofkins•

I read a good formulation here the other day: When the safety of the people inside the structure is a higher priority than that of the entry team.

8
RPofkins•

Or outside of a police / HR context: when the likelyhood of danger is higher outside the entry point than on the other side of it: e.g. the street/hallway you are on is being fired through

7

That makes sense. It sounds like dynamic entry should be a last resort tactic provided there is no hostages, time constraints, or higher danger outside of the entry point.

3
cqbteamCQB-TEAM•

The point of contention: what should be default? There's good arguments on both sides.

2
PotassiumBob•

In SWAT school we where taught it's basically to only be used for two things, hostage rescue and narcotic searches.

That said, much to the instructors annoyance, it was almost always the team leaders go to tactic.

Lots of people "died" in those Force on Force scenarios. Which as the medic game me lots of practice.

8
cqbteamCQB-TEAM•

Toilet rushes, haha.

2
PotassiumBob•

Yep exactly.

For pretty much everything else you just smoke them out.

But see that makes for some boring, non sexy, training. Enforcing bad training habits be damned.

2
cqbteamCQB-TEAM•

What do you think are the most common bad training habits out there when it comes to CQB?

1
PotassiumBob•

I guess to make a long post short, I don't think a lot of groups do Force on Force early enough, and often enough. And i seen a lot of people (police/mil) who refuse to do FoF unless its UTM/Sims (meaning no airsoft). "My kid does airsoft, so i'm not using some toy my kids play with". I did a weekend indoor CQB thing a bit back where we were to use UTM rounds, but we where not allowed to shoot each other within 25 feet. And we spent all inside a building with rooms no were near 25 feet. So it was either all stationary fake targets or us saying "bang bang" or whatever.

Then at the state's SWAT basic, we do sims half the week, but not FoF until the last day. So nearly everyone wanted to go dynamic from the start, because why not? No one is shooting back and blowing up doors is fun. And the instructor did do his best to discourage it, but we where supposed to make our own mistakes. So we just did like 80 hours of training against paper targets, everyone has this corners and positions down...until someone shoots back for that last day. So everything goes to shit, just like the instructor warned us. And during this last day we all had to be in our 'real world' positions, so being a medic I was either in the back or at the CCP. "How that entry work for you?" i asked, as i treat the same cop for the 8th time that day. "have you tried not doing that? No? Well, im sure you get it next time."

All of which could have been fixed day one with FoF, but now at day 7, hour 90, everyone is to tired to learn.

2
cqbteamCQB-TEAM•

Night advantage direct action mission (night vision goggles, thermals, night optics, laser-light systems; against INS in COIN context without those capabilities). Real-time room information (e.g. fibrecam or snakecam, thermal systems, sensitive systems). Sleeping enemy. Reloading enemy. Distracted enemy (e.g. target fixated). Softened target room with grenades. Other options exhausted (escalation of force, e.g. tactical callout ineffective) and it's a mission critical task. Particular mission profiles like hostage rescue or special recovery (in context, situational factors remain true). Limited time on ground, time sensitive target (again, in context). Political direction, e.g. due to sensitive operational issues like covert cross-border operations, first contact meetings or use of top-secret equipment or assets (time constraints, political expediency, top-down pressure). Unsafe external, accurate shots on your position outside the building (to secure a foothold, "off the street"). Cannot get an engagement angle on the threat so entry and movement to contact is required (e.g. hostage-taker, vision-obstructing obstacle like a vertical pillar, narrow angle engagement). First man makes entry and you need to back him up (if it goes dynamic, you do too). Prolonged entryway, no vision into most of the room. Direct-to-threat, chased a runner and have the advantage on him by making entry a second behind him entering a room (situational caveats and dynamism). Simply put: if you decide on doing it, follow-through and do it in the best way you can. All those dynamic principles come into play.

6

That's a good question. I think dynamic entry is best for hostage situation when the lives of the hostages is a higher priority of those of the operators. This has been a problem in the early years of the Iraq War especially in Fallujah. The issue is it is in the muscle memory of the number 1 and 2 men to clear their corners that they overlook the middle of the room leading to casualties. In a situation where the obj is to clear the building of enemy combatants then threshold evaluation/limited penetration is the best option. You don't have to use each tactic separately. Some teams have their number 1 and 2 men pie around the doorways while the rest pulls security then go dynamic. Besides hostage situations, scenarios with time constraints like finding and defusing a bomb would probably use dynamic entry. But that is getting hypothetical. If you see anything wrong with my reasoning feel free to correct me.

5
cqbteamCQB-TEAM•

Nothing wrong with your reasoning. Makes sense to me.

2
Duncan-M•

When is it useful? In my experience, conventional infantry in Iraq, we used it well every time clearing a structure where there wasnt a strong suspicion an alert enemy was defending it. Or when ROE considerations are so stringent we were politely knocking on doors and asking people to search homes, and just peaking around.

5