r/movies•
Inrau

What Film Franchise Didn’t Succumb To Fatigue?

With Terminator running on recycled fumes and Star Wars failure to move past the Skywalker family... what is a film franchise that managed to stay fresh?

Or at the very least try new ideas with each iteration?

The only one I can think of is Mission Impossible, although some could say the second movie caused some alarms.

I suppose Toy Story also has maintained relatively high quality and public interest, but they are only four movies in.

To me franchise fatigue in Hollywood seems inevitable. Reboots seem to be the only way they sometimes get around the issue.

Posted Nov 4, 2019, 10:36 PM UTC

35133
AffectionateLeg7•

MCU so far.

Downvote me motherfuckers. They just had three films gross over a billion this year, and one is the highest of all time.

76
msr_1809•

Downvote me motherfuckers

I dont think you need this. This inevitably leads to downvotes.

49
[deleted]•

People on this sub shit on the MCU all the time. Look at how self-righteous everyone got after Scorcese said he doesn’t consider superhero movies to be art. Everyone jumped on the hate wagon, and anyone trying to defend the MCU got downvoted to shit.

I also hate this mentality that people on Reddit have where anyone who acknowledges the possibly of being downvoted must therefore be downvoted. It’s like people really think they’re teaching others a lesson by doing the exact thing the person said they would.

21†
codyd91•

I find the "bring on the downvotes" trope stupid because, generally, it is not going to be downvoted into oblivion. It's just a way to say "look, my opinion is edgy and against the grain!" when it isn't at all.

46
mrbaryonyx•

People on this sub shit on the MCU all the time.

Are we talking about the same sub?

26
Bomber131313•

It does go both way, there is love and hate on this sub in great amounts for the MCU.

2
WitherWithout•

Funny how any MCU related news gets immediate front page on r/movies though...

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-10
Bomber131313•

And what was the meaning or your intention for pointing that out?

1
RoRo25•

There was a fatigue around Iron Man 3/Thor Dark world. I remember a lot of people thinking the Avengers 2 movie may not happen after all. But they Jumped back big with Winter Solder and then even bigger with Guardians of the Galaxy.

28
Darth_Lehnsherr•

Iron Man 3 grossed $1.2 Billion and was at the time the 5th Highest Grossing Film of all time. Thor 2 while far less of a success still made $200M more than Thor. Avengers 2 was always coming the moment the first Avengers hit $200M on OW.

Faitgue definitely could have set after Ultron though but Marvel has been smart in negating that through introducing newer characters and revamping the older ones. And of course Infinity War/Endgame stuck the landing.

9
jfstompers•

They're good for kids , they're good for adults. Even people who say they don't like them go see them.

3
Baktab•

None of Disney's franchises suffer from financial fatigue.

Creatively? I most definetely am fatigued.

1
InrauOP•

Would you classify the entire MCU as a franchise though?

-5†
AffectionateLeg7•

It's a franchise as much as Star Wars or Harry Potter is considered one.

42
InrauOP•

What would you consider the solo hero trilogies, Iron Man 1/2/3?

To me the MCU should be called a multiple franchise.

-2†
Abc123youand_me•

I'd say it's all the same franchise, since it shares the same universe. You could argue that each phase count as its own franchise, but they were all packaged into the "Infinity Saga".

15
TPolls•

I consider them to be sub-franchises to the main franchise.

7
AffectionateLeg7•

Depends on what we're defining as a a franchise. If each movie has to have the same cast then most of the examples here are out.

3
TacoParasite•

Even then he's still right.

Each sequel makes more money at the box office than the previous installment.

2
LoneWolf-CDN•

The MCU train is gearing up for another 10 year run of dominance and there aint no stopping it... chugga chugga chugga chugga chooo chooo!!

-8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

73
IHateBlindKittens•

Back door sluts 9 makes Crotch Capers 3 look like Naughty Nurses 2

22
InrauOP•

'Backdoor Sluts 9' really cemented the franchise in the all time list. Seven and Eight, were classy films but lacked the drive that the previous iterations had. I mean who can easily forget the way Esmi drops her undergarments in the CEO's home, at once its a vulnerable moment, but also an empowering one. She is strong, confident and totally hot.

12
Crankyolman•

Spoilers!

9
delsinson•

Intellectual ☝️

15
Alaska_Pipeliner•

You have 9 points and I can't upvote you because of that.

-1†
ZorroMeansFoxr/Movies Veteran•

Richard Linklater's Before... movies.

68
InrauOP•

Thats a good call, while there are only three movies, the span in decades is impressive. I haven't seen the third, but have heard its great.

4
jfstompers•

Good choice they're quality movies. The time frame helps with fatigue too.

1
Entling_•

Mission Impossible for me. They've been consistently good imo.

64
Daveed84•

It could be argued that they've only gotten better with each installment

20
True_to_you•

MI:2 was the only weak part. I'd definitely blame John Woo on that one. It's also the movie that's the most product of its time.

11
kitx07•

Man 15 year old me was pumped for that movie and soundtrack

4
KicksButtson•

I think we don't give MI2 enough credit. That was the film which told the studio an over the top action flick version of the franchise was the way to go. Just not a John Woo directed one. Before that the first film was good, but only if you like espionage films. Otherwise it was really slow and confusing, and some of the tense moments don't connect with the audience unless you know what's going on. The second film is where Tom Cruise began to love doing his own stunts, which is now a staple of a good Tom Cruise movie. It's literally something he's iconic for, and something iconic for the series itself. Before that he only did the rappelling scene himself which was not much of a stunt.

1
Baktab•

I still like 1&3 the most with Fallout coming in as a close third.

1
Parictis•

They are so canned and I don’t care for Tom Cruise’s always confident guy space religion portrayals in all of his movies AND I feel like Ving Rhames just gave up on pretended to try to act after MI2. And I still enjoy those films every time.

-12
drogyn1701•

I want to say Rocky. It had a slump with Rocky V to be sure, but it got itself out eventually with Rocky Balboa and Creed.

49
hailtheprince10•

I agree that Rocky V was the least entertaining but I also kinda feel like the series needed that movie. Like a closing chapter.

I need to watch it again because I don’t remember it being that terrible of a movie, it just wasn’t Rocky training montages and underdog victories.

8
Tocallaghan95•

It was kind of meh throughout, but redeemed with the last 15 minutes or so (mostly just "my ring's outside" and Burgess Meredith). Though I still contend that the scene of Rocky in the shower at the beginning dealing with the brain trauma is some of Stallone's finest acting.

5
OprahNoodlemantra•

Fast and the Furious is somehow still going strong.

41
TacoParasite•

La familia keeps it strong.

30
OprahNoodlemantra•

cracks open a Corona

24
WubbyLubbyDoobDoob•

Mumbles in family

4
Poonchichi•

Dude that's all Ludacris has left, that's why he defends it so much

5
OneUmbrellaMob•

luda has 5 platinum albums before streaming

16
Poonchichi•

We both know he can't ride that success anymore. No one has wanted to hear him rap since 2008

-7
treathugger•

honestly kinda tired of it...didn't even get to watch Hobbes and Shaw yet

3
[deleted]•

I haven't either, and I have far more interest in that movie, because I'm at least not tired of The Rock and Statham yet.

I'm completely over Vin Diesel except when he's a tree.

5
OprahNoodlemantra•

Don’t bother.

2
Patara•

Thats the best one

1
[deleted]•

If you're a fan of how insanely dumb the series has gotten and how the stakes keep getting ramped up to ridiculous heights, you'd probably love it.

I certainly did.

1
ThreeMarlets•

Fast and the Furious is also fascinating in how it evolved from a street racing movie into a heist franchise and then an espionage franchise. It's not like one film does the jump but each new film nudges into another genre, apparently without there being a studio plan to do so.

3
KicksButtson•

Going strong, sure. But let's not pretend it's high art by any means. It's actually more of a practice in narcissistic personalities and pop culture trends.

1
hijack-carman•

Both universal monster franchises, there’s no fatigue if you can’t get past one movie.

The View Askewniverse is ok

38
fenderdean13•

Uh, they have got past one, it peaked with Abbot and Costello meet Frankenstein

6
CementCemetery•

So much promise yet never any worthy results.

4
Pigmy•

I dont know about viewaskew. Yoga hosers alone is almost enough to tarnish any goodness from the original 3 films.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Pigmy•

I stand corrected on that point.

I dont think I ever saw Super Groovy, but i'll check out the reboot.

1
AnalogBubblebath•

I think the recent Planet of the Apes movies did it. I didn't care for the first one, but when Matt Reeves came in, he transformed them into something amazing. Dawn was great and War was even better, IMO.

34
KrillinDBZ363•

Which is pretty impressive given how many Planet of the Apes films exist in total.

4
jfstompers•

As far as modern series and blockbusters go I think apes just gets lost in the shuffle. Which is too bad they're 3 very different movies and so well done. I think the fact that there isn't an actor that spans the series, isn't like the face of it might contribute to it being lost.

3
WarningThread64•

Mad Max

33
chuckDontSurf•

Eh... Thunderdome was a goofy mess.

1†
airchinapilot•

It's certainly a change in tone and a step down but it deserves note because it is the most quotable of the movies. regardless, the franchise was redeemed by Fury Road.

4
happypants101•

Harry Potter. 8 straight movies all of them good to varying degrees, but certainly none of them could be considered bad

32
zacweso•

I think the key to this was we had a definitive ending. I think what causes franchise fatigue is there being no end in sight with the franchise due to lack of source material. The source material stayed good for 8 books, so as long as the movies followed those books well enough then it was all good.

2
LaxSagacity•

The problems with Star Wars isn't that they suffered fatigue. That is just spin to excuse the awful mismanagement of the current trilogy.

16
InrauOP•

Fatigue to me is just the result of awful mismanagement. Fatigue isnt the cause. EDIT: and I dont think its awful mismanagement, but oversaturation and lack of overall direction.

6
LaxSagacity•

I would say fatigue is a franchise that has outstayed it's welcome and has nothing more to say or do. There's still plenty to do with Star Wars. We have a big new TV series people are excited about launching a new streaming service in a week or two.

They just stuffed up the sequel trilogy, people are rejecting that, not Star Wars. Solo suffered in the wake of that, the current cinematic brand wasn't established as a must-see cinematic experience like Marvel. It couldn't easily brush off a film that people didn't like. They should have delayed Solo's release to a less crowded part of the year. Instead of pretending they didn't make a film that shat all over their franchise and attacked the viewers for not liking it. Then a few months later releasing Solo (a film people think is decent) between two Marvel films. It's just awful mismanagement that set it up for failure. Not fatigue.

3
killgart•

I think another reason Solo did poorly is that it was not a movie that fans were wanting. If Disney had given fans the Boba Fett film that was rumored I think that would have gone over much better and had been able to deal with fans not liking TLJ.

1
LaxSagacity•

I don't think a Boba Fett film would have faired much better on that release date.

1
[deleted]•

I'd like to conduct an informal poll:

Of the people who hate the new trilogy, how did you feel about the prequels?

I have a sense that most people either liked one or the other.

3
palabear•

Phantom Menace has its moments but overall is pretty weak.

Attack of the Clones is the worst of all Star Wars movies.

Revenge of the Sith is very good with some clunky parts.

Force Awakens is good but it’s recycled.

Last Jedi had interesting ideas but is too limited in scope for a Star Wars movie.

The thing hurting the sequel trilogy was the lack of planed story from FA to TLJ.

2
zacweso•

I think that what made Revenge of the Sith a less than stellar film is it was held down by being committed to story points from the previous 2 pictures. It does seem like TRS is going to try and let go of that anchor in a way which could hurt the franchise even more.

2
LaxSagacity•

I reckon that's a simplistic breakdown.

I like the ideas of the prequels more than the finished films, I can look past the bad aspects to enjoy them but never do not notice the bad aspects. I loved TFA and was onboard with the new trilogy but TLJ was a stinker and nose-dived any enthusiasm in the current trilogy. So there's nothing really to look forward to with the next film. I have my day one ticket booked for TROS, I hope I can love it but any enthusiasm is more about seeing it as a standalone film, a sequel to TFA and not TLJ. I thought that film was awful and really did not gel with TFA at all. It was an insult.

1
[deleted]•

I like the ideas of the prequels more than the finished films

Pretty much how I feel. The difference is that for me the bad outweighs the good to the point where I just don't watch those movies anymore. I might pull up some of my favorite scenes on Youtube once in a while, but that's about it.

I loved TFA and was onboard with the new trilogy but TLJ was a stinker

I quite liked TLJ. Maybe more so than TFA.

But at the same time, I'm not very hyped for the last movie.

3
LaxSagacity•

I quite liked TLJ. Maybe more so than TFA.

But at the same time, I'm not very hyped for the last movie.

TLJ really did nothing to set up for the next film. It's just ending on standard Star Wars premise, which is all both sequel films have done. Never actually had or laid down a proper story. Which gets to the whole deconstructed Star Wars aspect of TLJ. It's just playing around with the premise of Star Wars, in ways some people like or don't like. It's not even concerned if the plot makes sense because it's not about that. It's a take on Star Wars.

TFA can be excused somewhat because it's an introduction. TLJ can't be excused because it had to do this, it had to lay down the new story for the trilogy and cement it. If anything, it doubles down more on being Star Wars premise than telling a story.

Which is why there's no hype for the next film. Even if people loved TLJ. When it comes to the next film, your mind just goes back to a generic Star Wars premise, which is expecting a retread of the OT. Not helped by the film literally bringing back elements from ROTJ.

2
KicksButtson•

The prequels taught a relatively young me an important lesson. That some of the movies I loved were the creations of multiple talented people and not just one man, because when that man becomes too influential and tries to do something without anyone willing to criticize him he just creates crap.

The new trilogy validated a lesson I already knew. Don't spend that much money without a plan, and injecting forced social messages and annoying tropes isn't going to compensate for not having one.

1
AnxiousNightFury•

I absolutely hate the new trilogy, and I think that the Prequels were a fantastic concept and a fantastic story... that was executed very poorly. Admittedly, r/PrequelMemes has done wonders in letting me have a laugh at the weird-ass dialogue, so the Prequels for me are entertaining films to watch with friends on the surface, but a really cool and interesting story.

0
KicksButtson•

Every studio wants to be like Marvel but none of them approach their franchises with a plan the way Marvel has. Even Disney with its ridiculously expensive purchase of the Star Wars franchise was incompetent enough not to have a plan. First they just copied the original almost beat for beat, and then they had a mostly confusing nonsensical chase scene of a movie with forced social messages, and now... well, now they're just going to try to save face I think. They're going to end it and then reconsider how they approach everything.

2
[deleted]•

James Bond

15
Tocallaghan95•

I think it's slumped, but managed to come back strong over the years. Dalton after Moore and Craig after Brosnan, especially.

12
AshIsGroovy•

Depends on your tastes. Moore was hugely popular as Bond. Same with Brosnan. Dalton was too dark, hence why he only got two films. None even from the start has never been about realism, but fantasy action.

2
Tocallaghan95•

I mean, Brosnan is my second favorite Bond and Dalton my third. I'd say the slump wasn't Brosnan's fault, but he had bad scripts. Same with Moore (as well as his age). The "slumping" to me feels like devolving into over-the-top camp in "Moonraker" and "Die Another Day." They were always campy films, but like 40s pulp campy, not Batman '66 campy. Perhaps then the 'darkness' in "The Living Daylights" and "Casino Royale" might be an over-course correction.

I'd even say Craig might be my least favorite Bond, but I'll admit his tenure was a shot in the arm for the franchise.

1
TheLazyLounger•

Didn't see Spectre, eh?

2†
Pigmy•

What was wrong with spectre? It’s hard to follow up one of the best bond films of all time, but it wasn’t complete garbage.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AshIsGroovy•

The over the top silliness worked for 99% of the time while the darker stuff only worked post 9/11.

1
RobPlaysThatGame•

Honestly, Casino Royale was such a breath of fresh air and an interesting shift for the franchise, but then the following three films slowly became this muddied glob of the same thing, to the point that I can't really say I'm interested in this new one coming up.

I really wish after Skyfall they did another drastic shift to keep things fresh. New Bond. New tone. New style. Looking back now, my favorite James Bond films from the last 10 years ended up being Kingsman and The Man from UNCLE.

2
SpiderDeUZ•

Aside from the last Bourne movie the Bourne movies were pretty good. Even the Renner one

4
LukeMiller55•

I quite liked the last one

1
92tilinfinityand•

Decker

4
ZazzlesPoopsInABox•

Scream. I rewatched it for the first time in 15 years last month and id forgotten how brutal the movies really were. They never really lose steam because they are an examination of how mass media affects the mind. Blurred realities and weaponized media turning impulses into murderous rampage.

Neve Campbell drags the films some but the supporting cast really carries the franchise.

4
methodwriter85•

Scream 4 didn't do that great box office-wise but I thought it was still a pretty solid movie.

5
Emadyville•

Those voice changers in Scream tho...otherwise I loved the first 3 cause I grew up on them. Scream 4 wasnt horrible but I could have lived without it.

1
Beyonder_94•

Indiana Jones as far I as know. All three of the original films were hugely popular, then Kingdom of the Crystal Skull was a big hit despite its critical reception.

3
ExplosionsInTheRye•

I'd be really curious to see if people show up for a fifth Indiana Jones movie.

1
dewdd•

back to the future

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

2†
AnxiousNightFury•

I respectfully disagree

2
palabear•

I’d say it has a chance to get stronger. The problem is the best stories (Clone Wars) are not being told in the movies.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
tdl2024•

Oddly enough (and I still don't get why exactly) but the Fast and Furious films still seem to be doing fairly well, after like 10 films or whatever. A quick google shows that they seem to be making more money as they go on now cracking 1bil worldwide (after 200m for the first one). At this rate they'll be beating Endgame by Fast and Furious 18.

2
neoblackdragon•

The only "misstep" was the 3rd film which oddly enough is the only film that's actually about street car racing. The other films advertise it like it is but they are really crime drama's with cars as whipped cream.

I think the death of Paul Walker created a push with Dwayne Johnson's addition.

The increase in the ridiculousness also helped.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
neoblackdragon•

I don't agree with your examples.

Terminator isn't a case of franchise fatigue. It's a case of three meh to terrible films that's trying to ride the success of T2.

After T2 this is just not a successful franchise. Then let's remember T1 succeeded on an incredibly low budget. T2 was a well made movie with the star power of Arnold.

After Genysis , wtf would the general audience trust the franchise a 4th time?

​

Star Wars?

Oh boy that's just wrong. TLJ didn't fail at the box office. What happened was that in places like China, Star Wars was never big. After the huge marketing of TFA, of course the the same buzz wasn't going to happen again. Failure to move past the Skywalker family? What do you think this last film is going to be?

They killed Luke. Leia's actress is deceased. Just because some character is related to those characters means little as they are fictional characters. Also Rogue One?

Solo is an example of a movie nobody wanted. There are two live action series that have nothing to do with Skywalkers. Even the animations expanded beyond Anakin.

If you are looking at just the movies then you have missed a great deal of the franchise.

Star Wars is not dying.

​

Mission Impossible - You do know it's based off a long running tv series? What's really helped is stabilizing the cast and I think while Ethan is the lead, he is not the chosen one. It is a weird series. In any other case. MI2 should have been the course for the rest of the series and yet it wasn't. Not a bad flick but MI didn't even have Ethan fire off a gun. MI3 course corrected and made sure he wasn't a one man army. While he can take down a room, he's still very breakable and requires brains far more then crazy martial arts warrior stuff. It think it's just been solid and not getting two extreme.

​

Toy Story - Four films over the course of how many years. Helps that they are well written and seem to pop out at just the right time for their original viewers and their kids.

​

Franchise Fatigue is usually a case of "We made a series of crappy movies and no one wants to watch any more shite".

In cases like a Star Wars(really the internet), "We expected 2 billion, not 1.6 Billion, massive failure".

​

I don't really see it happen with well made films. I don't think have even one film a year creates fatigue. Seriously it's one film in the entirety of the year.

Solo was not a case of being too soon but a case of no one wanting a Han Solo origin movie not involving Harrison Ford. Then the background drama probably didn't help.

If anything should have been a tv series, it was that. A Mandolorian or Obi Wan movie probably would have done much better.

2†
[deleted]•

I agree with pretty much everything you said.

However, I will say I'm glad The Mandalorian and Obi-Wan are going to be TV shows rather than movies. I'm at the point now where I prefer serialized TV over movies.

If given a choice between 8 hours of Obi-Wan and 2 hours of Obi-Wan, I will choose the 8 hours.

2
InrauOP•

Disney realized there was franchise fatigue right after Solo. And now the CEO just came out and said what everyone already knew.

Franchise fatigue is not the cause, it’s the result.

As for Star Wars specifically, they have worn thin their movie universe. When they bring back Palpatine, and Luke is still doing stuff they haven’t moved past the Skywalker’s yet. People want new stories. Imagine if instead of TFA we jumped forward 200 years and had completely new characters and conflicts.

It might make a boat load of money, but Disney can no longer pump out a new Star Wars every year.

1