Top 5 Wrestlers

So, when I find out someone I know is wrestling fan I ask for a top 5 and so here I am doing it on a subreddit about wrestling.

I used to like Kevin Owens and The Miz the most but it's been so long since I said that and need to update em.

I'll go with indie wrestlers too since y'all seem like a diverse bunch.

  1. Cody Rhodes, I'm not sure why. I usually find a rookie and just follow him through and he did alright for himself.

  2. Pentagon, never really liked lucha until he came along. I am bummed he hasn't been doing too well, but have a lot to catch up on him anyway.

  3. Matt Riddle, like a modern day Rob Van Dam. I thought his bro thing was weird but he's done alright and surprises me.

  4. Shayna Baszler, I liked her more than Ronda Rousey character wise and a plus for her going though NXT.

  5. Samoa Joe, he might be out right now but he is the one who got me into indie wrestling so it's nice to see him in WWE.

So, who do y'all like? I didn't name a team, but feel free to pick one. I wanna see The Usos, Bucks, and Briscoes in their own version a of a triple threat TLC match that they can come up with, but that is probably never gonna happen to be honest.

Posted Nov 4, 2019, 10:44 PM UTC · edited

087
BBQTuckA Murder of Corbins•
  1. King

  2. Constable

  3. Lone Wolf

  4. Big Banter

  5. Wrestling’s Favorite Son

Honorable Mention: Bernsen

Serious All-Time Favorites

  1. Scott Hall

  2. Chris Jericho

  3. Triple H

  4. Diamond Dallas Page

  5. Big Sexy The Giant Killer Kevin Nash

I like my Wrasslers charismatic and with kick ass finishers.

12
SSJSalgadoOP•

Hmm, not sure if each is a nickname for a different person or if it's all just one person. 1, 2 and 3 all fit Baron Corbin. I'm not sure who the other 3 are tho, could you let me know or gimme more clues? Unfortunately, I'm not as diverse as everyone here.

1
BBQTuckA Murder of Corbins•

They’re all Japanese wrestlers in New Japan.

3
WoopzEhTriple Crown Goddess•

Kayfabe me softly brother.

3
SSJSalgadoOP•

Thanks, well it's time for a resource hunt. Hopefully, I'll learn more about the other wrestlers listed here if there is any repeating names from other lists.

2
ItsClarke17You think you know me?•

I'm not too familiar with wrestling right now (just recently getting back into it) but I'll throw my list out there.

Current:

  1. PAC
  2. Jon Moxley
  3. Kazuchika Okada
  4. Kenny Omega
  5. AJ Styles

All time:

  1. Edge
  2. Bret Hart
  3. Undertaker
  4. CM Punk
  5. Shawn Michaels
8
RustinPeaceJeff•

Swap okada for ibushi and Undertaker for Chris jericho and that's roughly my list

2
ItsClarke17You think you know me?•

If I had included honourable mentions I would've had Jericho and Ibushi there. Love both of them but right now they're juuuust edged out.

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Thanks, PAC is awesome nice to see him first on your list. I'm glad Jon Moxley restarted himself the right way. Edge, I gotta ask why on that one lol he was good tho. Damn, that all time list is making me miss my WWE '13 roster.

1
ItsClarke17You think you know me?•

I'm Canadian and I was a kid when I first got into wrestling, and it was when Edge was a top guy and just have so many memories from watching his matches when I was 10-11 years old, and I remember being absolutely heartbroken when he announced his retirement after Mania 27.

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Damn, that is a really good reason. I see why you had Bret Hart too then, I feel ya man. I was pretty messed up about Eddie Guerrero passing away when did and stopped watching for a bit a year after when Chris Benoit died too.

1
elikmac•
  1. Walter he's the best modern big man. His matches against Tyler Bate and Pete Dunne are must watches from this past year.

  2. Kota Ibushi such an amazing talent one of the best in ring performers. Also has a wonderful years long story of the Golden Lovers with Kenny Omega.

  3. Andrade the man is such a smooth wrestlers, he makes botches look like that's what was suppose to happen. I don't think there is a more talented guy in WWE then him.

  4. Tommaso Ciampa, his feud with Johnny Gargano really showed how talented he is and provided one of the best stories in the last decade.

  5. Kenny Omega. The guy knows how to turn it on in the biggest moments and find another gear. He's partially responsible for arguably the greatest trilogy of matches to happen in his feud with Okada. I also enjoy his dorky personality he displays in and out of the ring.

4
Hopecon802•

Kota Ibushi has had such an amazing year. He’s a vicious striker my favorite.

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Nice, thanks for the recommendations man and for commenting, I'll try to get back to you when I check some of these out.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
SSJSalgadoOP•

Damn, I forgot about Pete Dunne thanks for reminding me. WALTER is new to me, but I saw the Imperium awhile ago. Didn't he and Dunne go at it once?

I should think of an all time list too.

2
elikmac•

It was one hell of a match

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Good, Pete Dunne has cooled down a lot since bruiserweight status but hopefully he heats back up. What's he doing right now, do you know?

1
elikmac•

NXT US now looks to be starting a feud with Damien Priest

2
INTDOTK•

Current: 1. Shingo 2. Takahashi 3. Naito 4. Okada 5. Miyahara

All time: 1.Shibata 2. Naito 3. Okada 4. Shingo 5. Takahashi

3
SSJSalgadoOP•

Damn, 4 of those are on both. Can you recommend anything for Shibata and Miyahera? I'll take anything for Takahashi and Naito too.

1
INTDOTK•

For Shibata his matches against Ishii are must watch. Though his match against Okada is the greatest match of all time imo. He also has had bangers against Tanahashi, Goto, Kawada.

Miyahara has skyrocketed to be one of my faves. His matches this year against Jake Lee, KAI, Suwama, and Zeus all are fantastic. He had a fantastic match against Marufuji in the Champions Carnival last year too

Takahashi has had great matches against KUSHIDA, Ospreay, Dragon Lee, among others. Naito's matches against Ibushi and Tanahashi are top tier stuff too

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Daniel-Caine-Lyon•

My current top 5

  1. Kenny Omega

  2. Shingo Takagi

  3. Hazuki

  4. Will Ospreay

  5. Okada

3
SSJSalgadoOP•

Hazuki, I don't know em. Can you recommend something of his? Thanks for commenting by the way.

1
Daniel-Caine-Lyon•

She. The best performer in Stardom. The equivalent of Sasha Banks in she gives her opponents their best matches

Hazuki va Arisa is my Stardom MOTY

Hazuki vs Kagetsu

Hazuki vsHana Grand Prix finals

3
JasSolus•

Hazuki is good, but the best performer in Stardom is Mayu Iwatani. Kagetsu would be second best.

3
Hopecon802•

Current Top 5:

Okada

Shingo Takagi

Daniel Bryan

AJ Styles

Tomohiro Ishii

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

I need some matches for Okada, Takagi and Ishii. I don't know them that well except Okada kinda but only from TNA and they didn't do right by him at the time.

2
Hopecon802•

Shingo vs Will Ospreay- Best Of Super Jr. Finals it’s easily match of the year for all promotions and hands down well over a 5 star.

Tomohiro Ishii vs Katsuyori Shibata - For all of there matches

Okada vs Omega - Wrestle Kingdom 11 - Dominion 2017 - G1 Climax Day 18 2017 - Dominion 2018 - Those are 4 of the greatest matches from there feud!!

Try those !

2
VikingPain•

Current I'll go:

Okada

Ospreay

Shingo

Ishii

Gargano

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Nice, someone else said 3 of those too. Can you recommend anything for Ospreay? I've seen some of Gargano's work, he is pretty good. Do you have a favorite match of his in mind?

1
VikingPain•

Basically 2019 has been Will Ospreay's year. He's been having incredible matches since the beginning of the year and is a shoe in for Wrestler of The Year.

But if you have to catch one match of his I suggest:

Ospreay vs. Shingo BOSJ Finals 2019

The unbeatable and unstoppable: Shingo Takagi vs. (Arguably) the Best Wrestler in the World: Will Ospreay.

Shingo's amazing, Ospreay's amazing, add in a hot crowd and that match becomes absolutely breath taking with no dull moment. There are things done in that match that can't be explained and needed to be seen to believe. Absolutely a fantastic match that flies by even though its around 30 minutes.

Meltzer gave it a 5 3/4 star rating and is the highest rated match on Cagematch this year as well.

2
Nomad_Trash•

Current

  1. Asuka
  2. Kenny Omega
  3. Io Shirai
  4. Daniel Bryan
  5. Young Bucks

All-Time

  1. Triple H
  2. Sting
  3. Shawn Michaels
  4. Daniel Bryan
  5. Steve Blackman

Fictional

  1. King Slender
  2. Nacho
  3. Bonesaw McGraw
  4. Randy "The Ram" Robinson
  5. Thunderlips

Honorable Mention: The Disciplinarian

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Lmao, fictional. I don't know any of those except Nacho and I think that's racist lol Triple H is one hell of a character. He went from The Clique's scapegoat to saving Smackdown with NXT.

How did you feel about Triple H v Sting? Damn, you got Bryan and Michaels together lol he is pretty good and reminds me a bit of Chris Benoit sometimes.

Asuka is one of the ones overlooked to me so it's nice to see her as your number one.

2
Nomad_Trash•

Triple H vs Sting was an overbooked mess and Sting should have won. Also, how does a baseball bat slice a sledgehammer in half. Shouldn't it have splintered????

2
frankiefieryo•

My current is always changing so I’ll go all time:

  1. Stone Cold Steve Austin
  2. Kevin Owens/Steen
  3. Mitsuharu Misawa
  4. Tomohiro Ishii
  5. Roderick Strong
2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Damn, you got Roderick Strong in your all time already? I liked when he joined The Undisputed Era, he kept my attention with that. I'm not sure who Misawa is tho so recommend something of his for me if you can. Ishii popped up a lot, I should just google that one at this point.

1
frankiefieryo•

Roddy’s been great for almost 15 years. Watch his old ROH and PWG stuff. Misawa is arguably the best wrestler ever. Any country, any time period. Almost anything from like 1990 to 2003 is great. Ishii from 2013 on has been the best guy to watch from NJPW, there’s tons of stuff out there.

2
[deleted]•

Currently I'd go with WALTER, Sasha Banks, Daniel Bryan, Matt Riddle, Tomohiro Ishii

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Sasha Banks, nice to see her name too. She is different since coming back but her versus AJ Lee will always be my dream match.

1
Hopecon802•

Good to see Okada, Shingo, Ishii, and Shibata getting love! Also guys Minoru Suzuki gotta put him in there somewhere if you want to watch a good match.

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Yeah, Ishii isn't high up on the list but comes up the most. Can you recommend anything from Suzuki for me?

2
Hopecon802•

Okada vs Suzuki at the G1 Climax 2017 Day 16.

Suzuki vs Ishii at Power Struggle 2018 on Nov. 3rd almost exactly a year ago.

Suzuki vs Hiroshi Tanahashi - New Beginning In Sapporo Jan 27th 2018

Okada vs Suzuki at Royal Quest August 31st 2019

Some recent ones!

2
jerseyjoegotch•

Current

  1. Okada

  2. Seth

  3. Mox

  4. Zack Sabre Jr.

  5. Minora Suzuki

AEW guys don’t wrestle enough to be considered.

All Time

  1. Ric Flair

  2. Lou Thesz

  3. Terry Funk

  4. Randy Savage

  5. Shawn Michaels

Females- both all time & right now because I think Female wrestling has never been better.

  1. Charlotte

  2. Becky

  3. Bayley

  4. Asuka

  5. Tessa

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Lmfao, don't wrestle enough to be considered. Mox as in Jon Moxley? I need something for Zack Sabre Jr if you got anything? I had to go back and watch some Randy Savage, he was really good for his time I see why he was on Spiderman now. Yeah, female wrestling is pretty good right now. It makes me miss some of the ones from back then tho sometimes. I should've saw Charlotte coming with Ric Flair lol how do you like the new Bayley and got any recommendations for Tessa?

1
jerseyjoegotch•

Zack full free match recommendations;

Zack vs. Kushida

Zack vs. Ricochet

Zack vs Matt Riddle

Zack can work his style successfully against any opponent.

2
jerseyjoegotch•

Savage vs Steamboat was classic at WM3. Another guy who could work with anyone successfully.

I love the new Bayley; finally something fresh & new. I think Bayley is unbelievably good in the ring. I have never seen a bad Bayley match.

Tessa has not had as many good opponents as the other girls. For Tessa full free match recommendations;

Tessa vs Brian Cage

Tessa vs Kylie Rae

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Yeah, I went back to watch WM1 and the other big three and that match was the one I wanted to do it for so I could watch it in the right lime light. I thought it was great, and Bayley too. I was a little surprised and bummed about it but she needed it. I'm glad she got the title back too, almost thought she was gonna lose it to Nikki Cross this early. Thanks, I'll check em out.

1
DonkeyPump•
  1. Ishii

  2. Okada

  3. Cody

  4. Fenix

  5. Penta

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Oh, we got an Ishii at number one. I was wondering if it would happen lol got anything for Fenix by himself? I'm open to promos, matches and interviews.

1
DonkeyPump•

The recent Fenix vs Omega match in AAA

2
WoopzEhTriple Crown Goddess•

Current, in no order.

Aj Styles

Ricochet

Becky Lynch

Okada

PAC

All time would be, again in no order

Triple H

The Rock

John Cena

Jeff Hardy

Shibata

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Nice, no order was needed so that's cool. Already, another John Cena and a Jeff Hardy outta nowhere lol but who is Shibata? Can you recommend anything for em so I can check em out?

1
WoopzEhTriple Crown Goddess•

Katsuyori Shibata is a wrestler from NJPW, he's stationed in my favorites of all time because I LOVE how stiff he is (Sadly to he detriment :( ) If you want to get into him I would watch his Wrestle Kingdom XI match against Hirooki Goto and his Sakura Genesis 2017 match against Okada orrrrrr any match against Ishii

Here's a moves video for Shibata that showcases how stiff he can be.

2
lilSHIBBY•

Currently?

Matt Riddle Tessa Blanchard Timothy Thatcher Jay White WALTER

All time? HBK Edge CM Punk Chris Jericho Bret Hart

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

I never heard of Timothy Thatcher, got anything of his I can look into? I'll probably need something for Jay White and Tessa Blanchard too. I saw a lot of CM Punks in the all time list, he must really be missed. I miss him too.

1
ItsClarke17You think you know me?•

I can't speak for why anyone else likes Jay White but his match at the G1 Climax finals against Kota Ibushi is a great match. One of the best I've seen since I started watching wrestling again.

2
jqncgNAITO 2 BELTS 2020•

Top 5 active wrestlers:

  1. Hiromu (he's finally back to this list!)
  2. Naito
  3. Mayu Iwatani
  4. Kagetsu
  5. AZM
2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Oof, I feel ignorant as hell on this one. I'll need some recommendations on all of them except number 2 unless you have something you really like from em.

1
emshaq•
  1. Asuka
  2. Mustafa Ali
  3. Shibata
  4. Tanahashi
  5. Humberto Carrillo (Mainly because I don't understand how he can just stop midair but it's amazing to see.)
2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Yeah, Humberto is coming in on a good note for sure. Asuka number one again already lol I haven't seen Mustafa Ali yet so cool to see him finally, why did he make it to number 2 for you? I barely heard of Shibata and Tanahashi so if you got any recommendations on em, let me know if you get the time.

1
shrudeg•

1)Mick Foley

2)Steve austin

3)Jon moxley

4)Zack Ryder

5)Sonya deville

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Mick Foley outta nowhere, nice one. Zack Ryder and Sonya Deville? Please, tell me why if you don't mind.

2
shrudeg•

Everything about Zack Ryder makes me smile, his gear, entrance theme is one of the best. And I really enjoyed watching the nonsense that was wwecw and he was one of the best in that

For Sonya deville I've really enjoyed watching her on smackdown

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Cool, thanks for answering. I'm glad Zack can make you smile and Sonya caught your eye. I'm also glad you were unique and thanks for commenting.

1
zandog1874•

Current

Jericho- always been a great wrestler and fun to watch really got a new appreciation for him from his work with kevin Owens; The whole thing was the best thing about wwe for about a year.

Pac. The man gravity forget -his in ring work is phenomenal

Luke harper- was always my favourite outta the wyatt family and I recall him hurricaranaing somebody and that just blew my mind. I want to see him used more . I know he isn't the best wrestler out there far from it but he is still one of my favourites.

Samoa joe- a nasty peice of work , great promo skills and frightening agility and has a fantastic move set.

And cesaro - it's scary at how little he has been pushed throughout his time in wwe he is such a talented wrestler

2
SSJSalgadoOP•

Nice, glad to see Luke Harper and Cesaro on a list and with Chris Jericho as number one. I really like Luke Harper too, and was bummed he never did much after his IC title reign. I was hoping the Bludgeon Brothers would work out but it didn't.

1