Reddit, I am never giving you an email address

Please stop asking - I would happily flush my account and a hundred others before giving you an email address. If you require it I wont use your site. Just seeing a pop up asking for it pisses me off.

Posted Nov 6, 2019, 10:53 PM UTC

10866
ilikemyteasweet•

Installing Reddit Enhancement Suite and disabling ads combined with a browser ad-blocker means never seeing ads or "supported" content on reddit.

On mobile I use the 'redditisfun' app and disable ads.

I've used reddit for 8+ years and don't feel I'm missing anything by never have provided them an email address.

58
CommentariotOP•

My account is just as old I have not missed anything either.

3
yawetag12•

How about making a fake account that you never use again? Make it, link it, forget it.

56
hobo_law•
23
TriesToBeKind•

I use that site for soooo much stuff. At this point I think the only people who know my real email are my family, my employer, and my bank.

2
catsasss•

How tragic is it that I had to set up a separate “family” email account to keep my computer illiterate folks from putting my real email out there in Crazystan with all their turdly political email forwards?

My real email, which is for work, is shared only with other professionals who know better. 13 years and no spam on that one.

2
DJ-Salinger•

I've done this with a different account.

One day I got an email that there was "suspicious activity" on my account, and it would be suspended until I changed my password... Which can only be done via the back up email address which I no longer had access to.

17
rabidbasher•

YUP. I have a novelty account that's got the same issue. I think I still have the mail account but no idea what the password for it is.

3
nosoupforyou•

Years ago I set up a second yahoo account just for registering on sites that I didn't want to risk giving my primary email.

It's worked out ok, except for when a family member decides it's ok to hand out my email to a site without checking with me first.

But I get very little spam on my primary.

1
Benjamin_Grimm•

That's why I actually remember the password for the fake account. I just don't use it for anything except stuff like this.

1
CommentariotOP•

Why would I do that? What is the point?

-19

It literally solves the thing you were just complaining about. Creating a throwaway gmail account and giving that email to Reddit would take something like three minutes.

28
HexenHase•

I think the OP's concern is that giving people what they want ends up with one usually becoming a doormat, where the more reasonable solution would be for reddit to quit being such a fucking pest about it.

-2†

I mean, the site isn't going to stop asking - we all already know that, of course. What I'm saying is the two options are giving it an email or making peace with the fact that it will always ask.

He seems bothered enough that he might not ever become comfortable with the endless requests for an email. So if he wants to use the site in peace from now on, he can use this one simple trick.

Should he have to? That's a purely academic question, and whatever your answer for it is, it doesn't change the reality of the situation.

5
angelcat00•

But why is asking for an email such an unreasonable demand? What websites let you make an account WITHOUT asking for an email?

1
yawetag12•

So you stop getting the popup asking you to validate with ab email address.

22
toritxtornado•

to use email as 2fa if you forget your password

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-39
[deleted]•

[deleted]

36
ThePlum•

Man this post is one big "Ok Boomer"

13
obvom•

Mean there’s boomers and there’s boomers

6
beingmetoday•

That’s what she said....

4
angelcat00•

Why? Don't you have a secondary email address for online stores and things that are probably about to spam you with newsletters so they don't clog up your personal email? I gave them that address and they've literally never sent me anything.

29
ISvengali•

And this is just generally a good thing to have.

You know the trick about adding +<anything> to your email address to track which account is spamming you right? Im sure legit spammers get rid of the +<blah> but it can catch semi-legitimate places selling your address.

Basically, if you email is [email protected], when you sign up to something, say Nordstroms, you use [email protected]. Its still just your friend box, but the +nordstroms will be tracked through them selling it email and such.

I usually send myself an email saying 'I signed up to Nordstroms via [email protected]' Then later I can do searches for it, and remind myself where it came from.

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
yoda133113•

When you find out that it's being abused, you can easily set up a filter to trash anything going to +Nordstroms.

9
ISvengali•

Bingo! You can also setup trivial filters based on which email you used.

1
derfasaurus•

My only issue with this theory is that it assumes whoever buys or sells email addresses doesn't know this simple fact and is unwilling or incapable of running a very simple replace "+*@" with "@"

1
stacecom1970•

Them online stores ain't getting my email address! That's how they getcha! They're as bad as Reddit!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

27
CommentariotOP•

The problem is obvious - I don't want my data stored, tracked, sold, lost, or used in any way. I don't want them to contact me ever - why would I provide anything?

-11†
JonG311•

I hate to be the one to tell you this, but if you think your “data” hasn’t already been bought and sold a 100x over, you’re not really living in reality.

You own a smart phone? Game over.

You own a laptop? Game over.

You use certain TVs? Game over.

You have credit cards/take out a loan? Game Over.

You connect to the internet in any way besides a hidden IP/etc? Game over.

You ever jump on a public WiFi hotspot? Game Over

Do I have to keep going?

Create a throw away email and be done with this whole charade.

32
CommentariotOP•

I think you are wrong - a government with a specific reason might have the resources and desire to index all that shit into a coherent data set but without that kind of interest, protecting your own shit is needed.

-9
JonG311•

You can think whatever you want, its not a debate and it’s not changing anything.

And the government is just a small subsection of data collection. Banks, corporations, search engines, manufacturers, websites, social media, cellular providers, etc etc — and the list goes on. That’s where your data is being collected and sold. And for real, if you think it hasn’t and you’ve participated in the modern world at all, well... Game Over.

The good news is you’re fine. Your data has been sold 100x over and the sun still rises/sets. Don’t worry about drawing lines at reddit. The war for personal data came and went.

Side note — Look into Google’s claims of cracking quantum computing. If their claims are true, what do you think a search engine company that mines data is going to do with quantum computing?

6
2cats2hats•

Neither of you are wrong you both have valid points.

1
imeddy•

I take it you're always on a vpn then?

1
zenmanson•

why would I provide anything?

So that you don't get the pop ups that bother you so much you felt you needed to type your tantrum in Reddit for Grownups.

19
toritxtornado•

so you can use your email as 2fa if you forget your password.

7
FudgingEgo•

You do realise they don't need your email to do all of that right? I work in this field, an IP address and a cookie on your browser will do the job.

3
kzivGet off my lawn•

I'm a web dev and while I appreciate someone actually taking their online presence seriously, it seems like there needs to be an easily understood class, maybe through the public library, about what you really do and don't need to worry about and realistic approaches to dealing with those issues.

Huh, I guess I just found a volunteering opportunity for myself.

2
Gonzobot•

I don't want them to contact me ever - why would I provide anything?

So they can contact you outside of the site if need be. Like if your account gets compromised because you never setup security of any type, they can verify it's you because hopefully your email account isn't similarly compromised. Your email address is meaningless bullshit, for realsies, you don't need to protect it like your dang social insurance number. But you definitely should be getting in the habit of using things like two-factor authentication - not only a username/password combo, but a secure predetermined handshake algorithm giving you constantly-changing secure unlock codes. Functionally, this is as simple as getting an email with a code in it, or using one of many apps on your phone for this exact reason (Authy, Google has a variant too, tons of options), but it means literally nobody else can ever login to your things without having physical access to your device - which is, again, hopefully not compromised with relative ease because you hate things like PIN inputs, and use 1111 to unlock your phone.

2
nosoupforyou•

Not to mention that it's only their promise that they will never sell it or abuse it, but they can easily change that with a notification that "they will only sell it 'some' companies".

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
Halaku•
17
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Halaku•

That subreddit doesn't exist, and I might be the wrong generation to catch the joke.

r/lostredditors does, and OP qualifies for taking his anti-Admin rant here instead of someplace where it would actually be relevant, like r/beta, or r/ideasfortheadmins, or such.

1
Septothorpe•
12
happinessiseasy•

Hey grandma, your can just type r/forwardsfromgrandma

5
AltitudinousOne•

lol

0
tway15q1•

And what? Do you want your money back?

12
gordo0620•

Then don’t use Reddit. I provided an email address for an account I don’t use, turned off all notifications under settings and have never had a problem. That was over 2 years ago.

11
CommentariotOP•

Then why did you give it to them?

-3†
gordo0620•

I counter with — why not? They asked for a verified email, like many sites do, and there was no good reason not to. Why make it an issue when it’s not? This isn’t even a real problem.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•

Its mostly used for forgotten passwords tbh. P sure reddit doesn't market to you via email.

Marketers get far more useful info from googlization (link to and from, tracking cookies, etc) than they ever will with email

3
Skiwithcami•

I have a spam specific email. Any website that requires one, I give that one. Also, on the first name I put the name of the store/website so if they sell my info I know which store sells it.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TheYearOfThe_RatTCK, Int'l professional•

If you don't need Reddit so much, why you're still on it?
Logic and consistency are severely lacking ITT.

1
Deadwood-Dick•

I simply deleted my old account from 2007 and created a bullshit email for this account.

1
Elminster_Aumar•

Say "thanks" to Big Tech and all the losers steering that wheel. Ethics, etiquette, and real leadership be damned: all your data are belong to us now...

But don't hold your breath on it improving anytime soon as long as the morons who whine about your whining have anything to say about it. They'd cut off their own fucking noses to spite their face while allowing their straws, guns, and identities to be taken in the name of virtuous brainwashing.

0†
wisdom_possibly•

In 20 years today's kids will wonder why we ever thought giving profit-oriented companies all our information, and thus power, would be a good idea.

1
Elminster_Aumar•

I doubt they'll ever realize it--they're too brainwashed to.

-1
Wolpertinger77•

Seconded! I just saw my first pop up the other day. Not happening...

-1†
randomfemaleIn the mix since 66•

Yeah, I am thinking very often about dropping reddit due to censorship. The PC, hate the rich, self-pity crowd are so frightened of dissenting opinions - and they're bullies.

I've been on reddit 11 years! (second account; 1st was too easily identifiable)

-4†
rabidbasher•

I wouldn't know what the fuck to do with myself if I gave up reddit. This is about the only place you can go online to learn about just about ANYTHING with fairly well-tailored feeds.

The community (generally) is pretty good at fact-checking or calling out blatant misinformation too. Save for some of those insular circle-jerk shitholes.

2
wisdom_possibly•

I agree with you, but only because the average redditor is like that - a moron.

0
HexenHase•

Jesus, the number of people who seem to think handing over an email address is "no big deal cos dey spyin on youse anyway".

Just... wow... Wow.

-4
AintNobody-•

I didn't see any posts like that. I see posts like "There are a half dozen easy and free ways around this."

3