How lenient should I be with my PCs, as this encounter today -should- be a total TPK?..

Reposted, because the Mods said my old title made me look like an aspiring serial killer...

We're running Lost Mines of Phandelver, I've got 4 lvl 4 characters, currently running at about half their resources...

They were warned about a dragon in a nearby tower. (Thundertree). They rolled well to know about the dragon. The thing telling them about it warned heavily it'd kill them all.

They then decided "oh there is a horde of gold the dragon must be protecting", and they've decided to sneak in.

The dragon caught them early on, we had a social encounter, it tried to manipulate them to doing some stuff for them. They feigned that they'd help him....

Dragon went off hunting for food in the nearby forest telling them they'd only be 10 minutes, and that he'd eat them instead if they were still there.

They attempted to sneak in anyway....

They rolled really badly to try to get into this place, and also investigate it, so its eaten a lot of time...

The dragon returned while they were attempting to loot the horde.... and thats where I ended the last session, with it rearing up to do an attack.

I cannot foresee a way that this is going to result in anything but a TPK. Being a green dragon, I feel they'd probably kill half the party, and capture the rest, hoping to ransom them or something... Or just save them for food later....

Without totally fudging the whole encounter, the campaign is done.... I've had 2 weeks to come up with an alternative solution, and I've drawn nought.... The session is in about 3 hours....

Any suggestions, or are we going to end up rolling new characters, and let them learn their lesson the hard way?

EDIT: Oh god damn it, they rolled really well and I rolled really poorly. They didn't kill it, but they survived, the thing fled near death. I've been panicking for nothing.

Posted Nov 9, 2019, 4:52 PM UTC · edited

1022
Sundaecide•

Pasting my original response:

If they did their research, knew the risks and proceeded all the same then it is time for the dice to decide. Be true to your world and NPCs and be fair (but not soft) with your players. They might be disappointed, exhilarated and all things in between but that's all part of the game.

22
Novahkiin22•

No mercy. Let them learn that they can't be insanely stupid. If a dragons like "imma eat you" and they defy it, they best be ready for it

6
YakaryBovine•

Let the dice fall as they do. If you save them, you'll be telling your players that they are functionally immortal even in the face of very unsafe decision making.

Your players are probably fully aware that they took a risk. The payoff for success would have been high, and the penalty for failure high as well. You don't want to cheapen their decision-making by retroactively making a risky decision safe.

As a player, I really need to know that death is on the line, even if it doesn't actually transpire. It's the stick by which all risk is measured, and the only way you can truly bet everything.

17
Purpose2OP•

I agree, and understand.

Just trying to work out where in the hell do we go from here?

Kill a few off, capture the rest, ransoming them to Neverwinter or another nearby city?

Kill them all off? If so...

Do we start a new campaign? Or do we roll new characters and try to pick up -sort of- where they left off? Lower leveled, and brought in by the Zhentarim or Lord's Alliance as a band of mercenarys?

4
Dw1ggle•

Start new characters and continue the campaign, use the deaths of their old characters as a part of the lore. Maybe do a slight time skip? My last DM did that when some of my party got themselves murdered making similarly bad choices. It was actually kinda cool even though the time skip meant the world around us was a lot worse off than before. It definitely forced some much smarter decision making and even some diplomacy in order to gain allies to fight back against the "evil empire" that ran amok after killing the champions of the realm.

4
YakaryBovine•

Both options are great, particularly the second. A group of grizzled old mercs are hired to clean up after a group of adventurers, and have to piece together their clues to proceed. The first thing they come upon is the remains of the former party. You all have a laugh about adventuring newbies, and move on.

You could also have a bit of a send-off. You narrate the mercenaries finding various memorabilia on the corpses, and the players can describe what they are and what they meant to them - and then also how the veteran reacts to finding them.

This is, of course, assuming that the players even die. Who knows? They might surprise you with a cunning plan and defeat the dragon, or only suffer a few losses.

1
Purpose2OP•

I hope they do surprise me and get away with it! It'd be fantastic for the story.

That is a really good idea about the send-off, thank you very much.

2
ShadowAlec8834•

Just a comment from watching Matt Colville: The players (even though you have been clear with them) will be upset, and even angry, if you kill their characters. Let them be upset. Let them be angry. Don’t defend yourself (and agree with them that it sucks). Step away for a few minutes if need be, and everyone should be able to come back, talk it out, and get excited about their new characters.

As stated above, the PCs could surprise you and win. And I know that they earned it if they TPK. Just let them come to terms with that in their way.

3
Purpose2OP•

So session is over.... they did it! (Sort of)....

Young Green Dragon went down to about 20hp and fled. One of them was on 2 failed death saves (I make them roll death saves hidden, so only me and the player knows... drives a lot of urgency/stress if the party don't know how the saves are going)... and another one went down.... but they did it!

They're terrified of going back to the area without more backup in the future though, they don't know how close they got that dragon down.

Thanks for the help everyone, I've stored it all away for later use...!

3
Manuelm4n•

Hey...

They were warned...

7
Kevsch89•

Weather it’s new players or Vets, I vote TPK. It’s a brutal answer BUT while I want my players to enjoy themselves, I let the consequences be real. Not everyone makes its home, and if you make bad choices that lead to your doom? That’s your fault, I’m just the story teller. If it’s new players, it will teach them to re-consider their choices more carefully in the future, and if it’s seasoned players, maybe they needed a reminding they aren’t mini gods that get away with everything, that bad things do happen.

6
robot_wrangler•

Getting killed by the dragon is a totally valid way to finish LMoP. Start a new campaign from one of the source books, or homebrew your own. Maybe the missed parts of LMoP can be side-quests in the new campaign.

4
fungusm•

The dice might be forgiving to the group. You never can tell how am encounter will go.

Just play it out.

2
Mithrandir_DnD•

Ask the players what they want to do.

1
rkw1971•

When you were very young, <4 would be a good guess, someone at some point said "Don't touch that! It's hot." you likely touched it anyway since you really didn't know what "hot" was. They have been warned. You have given multiple chances for them to go elsewhere first. They want the loot that bad, let em "live" and learn. Be fair to the gameplay but don't be a smug asshat about it.

1
LordKael97•

Depends how big the dragon is. If it is the Adult or Young dragon in LMoP, then yeah, TPK is the likely outcome. But if it is a Huge dragon, then maybe the maw is large enough to swallow them whole, and they take acid damage while in the stomach, but could bust their way out?

1
Purpose2OP•

Its the Young one.

Being smart, and young... it'll try to flee if it gets below half I feel...

So I guess it isn't a guaranteed loss....

1
semiconodon•

They rolled well to know ....

For this reason I want to start my campaign with a whirlwind/plane shift/ shipwreck, not staging it in the town they all grew up in.

1
Purpose2OP•

To clarify: They rolled well in their engagements with locals in the area who informed them. Not prior knowledge.

1
semiconodon•

Yes I understand but I hate arcana and lore checks. It implies the party grew up in the next town over.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1