How lenient should I be with my PCs, as this encounter today -should- be a total TPK?..
Reposted, because the Mods said my old title made me look like an aspiring serial killer...
We're running Lost Mines of Phandelver, I've got 4 lvl 4 characters, currently running at about half their resources...
They were warned about a dragon in a nearby tower. (Thundertree). They rolled well to know about the dragon. The thing telling them about it warned heavily it'd kill them all.
They then decided "oh there is a horde of gold the dragon must be protecting", and they've decided to sneak in.
The dragon caught them early on, we had a social encounter, it tried to manipulate them to doing some stuff for them. They feigned that they'd help him....
Dragon went off hunting for food in the nearby forest telling them they'd only be 10 minutes, and that he'd eat them instead if they were still there.
They attempted to sneak in anyway....
They rolled really badly to try to get into this place, and also investigate it, so its eaten a lot of time...
The dragon returned while they were attempting to loot the horde.... and thats where I ended the last session, with it rearing up to do an attack.
I cannot foresee a way that this is going to result in anything but a TPK. Being a green dragon, I feel they'd probably kill half the party, and capture the rest, hoping to ransom them or something... Or just save them for food later....
Without totally fudging the whole encounter, the campaign is done.... I've had 2 weeks to come up with an alternative solution, and I've drawn nought.... The session is in about 3 hours....
Any suggestions, or are we going to end up rolling new characters, and let them learn their lesson the hard way?
EDIT: Oh god damn it, they rolled really well and I rolled really poorly. They didn't kill it, but they survived, the thing fled near death. I've been panicking for nothing.
Posted Nov 9, 2019, 4:52 PM UTC · edited
Pasting my original response:
If they did their research, knew the risks and proceeded all the same then it is time for the dice to decide. Be true to your world and NPCs and be fair (but not soft) with your players. They might be disappointed, exhilarated and all things in between but that's all part of the game.
No mercy. Let them learn that they can't be insanely stupid. If a dragons like "imma eat you" and they defy it, they best be ready for it