Sony MDR-F1 impressions

Posted Nov 10, 2019, 9:06 AM UTC

Posted Nov 10, 2019, 9:06 AM UTC
I am a big fan of Sony from that era. Owned the cd1700 and cd3000. 3000s gave up the ghost a long time ago, but I still use my 1700s to this day. I only managed to afford these as they were made obsolete and a company was selling stock off at -66%
The F1s are one of my dream phones. I tried on a pair when I was much younger in a mall in Germany and fell in love with the comfort and style. Couldn’t afford them at the time.
They are rare and generally poor condition if you do find them. So kudos to OP for finding a nice pair.
I have the CD1700 and really like them - they are warmer than most vintage headphones i've heard, with solid staging for (semi)-closed headphones. I had the F1 and prefer the CD1700 by a small margin.
Never owned the CD3000, sadly I'm not ready to pay the current used values (sitting around 400-500€) for a CD3000, especially if it doesnt come with original pads. Most pairs I see are with chinese pads, which probably make the sound balance worse.
Great impressions. One interesting tidbit is that they are one of the few headphones with built-in crossfeed, so a bit of each stereo channel bleeds into the opposite.
This actually helps it’s imaging. Personally, I found it actually has one of the largest soundstages out of the box, and that is said having owned both HD700 and HD800.
It is a warm, relaxed sound, and yes not the last word on detail. I don’t find mine particularly shouty, though it’s treble and sub-bass are recessed.
Really unique oddity and one of the most comfortable headphones every made.
Hard to find in good condition mostly as the pads deteriorate. Pads are not easily replaceable either.
Oof... These are warm.
Nice impressions, thanks man.
[deleted]
Great impressions and very interesting. I haven't much experience with older headphones and it's great fun reading about them. They look really cool aswell. A nice looking set. Thanks.
The MDR-F1 are bucket list material for me. The openness of the design is just absolutely mouth watering. I love the idea of ear speakers, but I hate their usual ergonomics with awkward head straps and pads above the ears. This design in theory is the perfect fusion of the sound of ear speakers and the around ear pad comfort of headphones. And then there's the space age magnesium material. Maybe the sound leaves something to be desired by modern standards and needs to be tweaked, but otherwise these are a high point in headphone design that's sadly never seen a comparable successor.
Also, what were those other Japanese boutique headphones for several thousand bucks with a similar design called again?
That would be the Kurada KDP-1. And I agree the design is awesome. Definitely prefer the comfort of this to something like the K1000.
Thanks, those are the ones. By the way I used to have the budget little cousin of the MDR-F1, the MDR-605, when I was a teen, and I loved them.
I owned the successor to this for a while, the MA900, and it was a very nice alternative to the HD600. A little too polite in the mids though (I like a bit of shout), so I sold it.
Recently I got my hands on a pair of sony MDR-F1 in what I can only describe as quite incredible condition from fellow Reddit member u/hanouk. I’ve had it for about a week now and will do my best to outline my impression of this headphone, both stock and with EQ (you will soon see why).
The MDR-F1 is a premium free field headphone. That is to say both the front and back volume are completely open. This naturally gives Sony a lot of challenges in terms of design. If one would liken this headphone to something it would be something like the K1000, SR1A, MySphere, KDP-1 or even Sony’s other alternatives with a similar design.
The headphone feels very premium and luxurious, made almost entirely out of magnesium. It weighs in at about 200 grams, making it the lightest headphone I’ve ever used. It has quite supple and soft pads that are some kind of cloth material, the headband has an auto adjustment strap that does a very good job of distributing weight, it fits my head with no problem (not a given for many headphones). The single entry solution is quite ingenious in my opinion, the entirety of the cable that goes to the right cup is inside the headphone, running along the yoke and into the headband before it exits at the end of the yoke on the right side, this means the cable is not even visible and naturally makes it very hard to ruin. Stock cable is attached and 5 meters long, for good and bad.
So, how does it sound? The MDR-F1 in stock configuration can only be described as one thing: shouty. It has a rising response all the way from the bass to about 1KHz before it starts dropping again. I’m quite used to stax so 1KHz energy is not exactly new to me but the F1 was quite simply too much, especially coupled with too little lower midrange. Listening to You Want It Darker by Leonard Cohen was just an absolute travesty. Other than this there was some really ugly sibilance stemming from around 6-7KHz. Putting the sibilance aside the F1 sounds very relaxed in the treble and is incredibly enjoyable to me.
Before I talk about the EQ’d F1, some measurements: https://imgur.com/a/Ml6kJZS
This shows both the EQ I made and the stock response. The 4.5k is just EARS being weird and I can not hear it. Other than that the measurements seem to match quite closely with what I hear. EQ was naturally done by ear.
So, with EQ F1 goes from being a pretty meh headphone to being one of my favourite dynamics ever. It maintains good extension down to 50hz which is enough for 90% of music and with the shout and 6-7k peak tamed female vocals become a lot better. After this EQ it still exhibits very low levels of distortion, I measured it at sub-4% THD in the bass@95dB (and that is mostly limited by noise in my room). The best compliment I can give the F1 with EQ is that it sounds really normal, there is nothing that sticks out like a sore thumb and the general presentation is well rounded and enjoyable. It won’t have the biggest soundstage, the best detail or most precise imaging but I can’t fault it for lacking any of these either.
Overall I really like the F1, and while it isn’t the last word in fidelity it makes for an incredibly enjoyable listening experience due to the inoffensive sound and superb comfort.