r/madisonwi•
splopps

Who makes the best cheese and sausage platter around town?

I am hoping to step up my holiday meat and cheese game without actually doing any extra work.

Posted Nov 11, 2019, 2:08 PM UTC

39
katiebot5000•

Honestly Fromagination does, but with high quality cheese and meats comes a higher price.

11
sploppsOP•

^^ This is what I was looking for! A fancy cheese tray made up for me. Thank you for suggesting it, Fromagination totally slipped my mind.

3
Oo2agent•

Wisconsin cheese who just opened a new store off 14 by Oregon is pretty decent.

5
aft1083•

The Willy Street Co-op has a bin of cheese nubbins that's great if you're going for variety and willing to assemble your own. Everything in there is under $3 so you can try a bunch of different things. I'm into doing my own so I usually go there, get some nubbins, a few bigger nicer cheeses, hit the olive bar (or the one at Whole Foods, which is $$$ but has a lot of choice) and then grab meats from Jenny Street, Underground and/or Alimentari. I have a giant metal boot tray from Target (never actually used for boots) that I put it all together on. I am extra about cheese and meat plates.

That's a big asspain though, so if you want someone to just make one for you, Fromagination is most definitely the way to go.

4
desertcombat06•

"Stepping up your game" is going to involve work and assembly. Fitchburg Hyvee actually has a decent delicatessen (they have speck!) and a nice cheese selection. The Wisconsin Cheese mart that u/Oo2agent brought up is also a great option. (and how could I have forgotten about Fromagination!)

1
mugglesport•

It is definitely not cheap, but I've bought the Meats & Cheese tube from Underground Butcher a couple of years and its always been a hit. You can usually buy it in-store around this time of year but you can also buy it online.

1
proicecream•

We bought a platter from Underground Butcher for our wedding. Was not cheap but was delicious and well presented.

1
KinkyQuesadilla•

Underground Butcher definitely has their platters at a step up from other package deals you'd get in a grocery store. Alimentary has all of the individual items you would need to make a platter yourself, but I don't know if they have anything prepared and ready to go as a platter (If they don't, if you call them and talk to them I'd bet they would make you one).

1
princessmorbid•

Honestly just buying stuff from trader Joe's would get you pretty far. They even have prepackaged antipasto spreads by the other charcuterie meats.

0