r/truegaming•
vgambit

Is it possible to articulate the "X factor" that makes Death Stranding addicting to so many people, but boring to so many others?

Since 9 PM PST on Thursday, I've put in just over 60 hours. Aside from maybe 3 minutes of cutscenes out of the first 3-4 hours, I'd say I've enjoyed every minute of it. I also enjoyed Spintires, so I was always gonna love this game, but I digress.

I'll keep the spoilers to an absolute minimum (and I hope you do the same!), out of respect to Tim Rogers, who did the same knowing that having some rando just vomit plot points out of context would ruin the experience for people who haven't played it yet.


For me, it's an extremely well-executed systemic game full of ludonarrative harmony (which makes it difficult to discuss without spoilers). There's a lot more going on than I'm about to imply, but in this game's post-apocalyptic America, people live really far away from each other, underground, so they rely on couriers for basic supplies. "All you do" is bring cargo from point A to point B, regardless of whether it's a story order (literally orders you take on) or random side order. In doing so, you're helping to connect people, and ultimately bring an individualistic, divided country back together again.

I'm being overly general, and there's way more to it (both plot- and game mechanic-wise), but that's the basic gist. I understand that when I describe it that way, and maybe even when you watch someone play, it might seem really boring. But where the game shines, from the first moment of gameplay, is in how you interact with it.

More traversal means and assists open up over the course of the game (e.g. reverse trikes), but for the most part, you carry the cargo on your person while walking to your destination. Each piece of cargo has a size and weight, and that, combined with how you carry the cargo (you can equip small stuff to your arms and hips, and certain things to category-specific areas like a utility pouch) determines, roughly, how fast you can move, how nimble you are, and how difficult it is to keep upright as the payload sways while you walk.

L2 and R2 provide analog, context-sensitive control of your arms, which, by default, pull on your backpack straps to shift the cargo's weight left and right. On-screen prompts appear as needed to remind you to do so, but you can simply watch the stack and react with subtle trigger pulls as you move, or fall into a rhythm of anticipating how your changes in direction and the lay of the terrain will alter how the stack leans. I think, more than anything else, at its core, that last sentence sums up one of the best aspect's of this game's feel. Simply moving around under load is not easy, so doing it takes skill, and it's rewarding.

Death Stranding has a lot of things going on (I haven't mentioned the atmosphere provided by the music and sounds, nor how they combine with vibration to help link what you see and do with how it feels, for example), but to boil it right down, the game simply keeps throwing different traversal and logistical challenges at you, leaves the solution up to you, then grades you on it afterward, based on metrics like time taken and cargo damage. It's addicting for me because every aspect of the game (aside from things like reading mail or interview transcripts) is either that, or in service of it.

If that still seems boring, understand that a game like Super Mario Odyssey, at its core, is also a "point A to point B" traversal challenge, with some of the key fundamental differences (aside from things like narrative, presentation, and overall systemic scope) being that point B is usually unknown, and you have a less-intimate relationship between available traversal methods and the level's terrain (i.e. it's easier to do shit and harder to fuck up). There are several shared compelling aspects of both games, but one is far more approachable than the other. Neither is bad, but the appeal of one is far less obvious than the other. I think that's why even Kojima says it doesn't "get good" until further in, which, IMO, is just a trap to hook people until it "clicks;" as I said, I was enjoying it from the jump street.

I keep saying this, but there's so much more going on in this game that I can't go into for fear of making the reveal of that layer more enjoyable in context, due to how tightly it relates to the game's plot. And that's another part of why I enjoy it so much. The first two cutscenes introduce you to X and Y aspects of the game's world and narrative, and they impact your gameplay indefinitely. It's as if Kojima took this game design, then somehow formed a wildly compelling narrative around it, with both (sorta) making sense in their own context.


For those who have also been playing it (again, please, without spoilers), would you agree with my assessment? Whether you like the game or not, I'd like to hear what you think the "X factor" is. I dunno how not to come off as elitist while saying this (as someone who put many, many hours into "mainstream" games like both Breath of the Wild and Super Mario Odyssey), but for now, I feel less like "yeah, Death Stranding just might not be your thing" and more like "wow, do you also think reading is for nerds?" even though I know that some pretty nerdy folks in the gaming community don't like this game.

I wanted to say more about how people's distaste for the game might be based on unmet expectations from Kojima after 20 years of Metal Gear Solid, but this post is too long as it is. I'm very much looking forward to what hbomberguy, Joseph Anderson, and Matthewmatosis have to say about this game. I know from watching the Tim Rogers review that after I finish the game, I have some Russian novels to read and Criterion Collection films to watch.

Posted Nov 12, 2019, 9:52 AM UTC

446275
Loading comments…