Any Chemistry or Biochem buffs out there?

I'm looking to see if anybody can point me towards some more "scientific" references about the chemistry of making mead, (though wine, cider, and beer resources are welcome as well). I well understand the general reaction pathways of fermentation, but I'm looking to better understand the other factors of the homebrew process.

Yes fermentation results in the production of both CO2 and ethanol, but why and how are other alcohol compounds formed?

Yes we age things, and yes it gets less "hot" and more flavorful... but why? and how? What is it that makes honey a more finnicky sugar source for the yeast than others. Why does mead always seem to have a much stronger fusel alcohol flavor just after primary fermentation?

What are some of the "good" organic molecules that we want produced for a flavor profile, and how are they produced. And the bad ones?

Anybody got anything? - Thanks

Posted Nov 12, 2019, 5:42 PM UTC

3126
StormBeforeDawn:wiki-editor: Wiki Editor•

You are going to sadly find very little on this unless you have access to university journals and what there is to find you need to search through piles of misinformation. Some of the good info I have found on the gritty details of fermentation has come from a variety of Australian journals but this has been mostly focused on tannins, fruit extraction and yields.

One fun tidbit is that methanol can be a product of fermentation in the presence of pectinase in melomels.

"good" organic molecules that we want produced for a flavor profile, and how are they produced.

Look up wine making enzymes. Lallemand can have some good texts on organic volatiles.

What is it that makes honey a more finnicky sugar source for the yeast than others

Lack of nitrogen.

Why does mead always seem to have a much stronger fusel alcohol flavor just after primary fermentation?

You can minimize or eliminate that with best practice.

23
[deleted]•

One fun tidbit is that methanol can be a product of fermentation in the presence of pectin. I always dose my melomels with pectinase now, even if I am not super uptight on clarity for the particular batch

Well that's extremely useful to know

5
StormBeforeDawn:wiki-editor: Wiki Editor•

It's also totally wrong, you can see the other replies.

fruit juices naturally contain about 140 mg/L of methanol and added pectinase and in a study of "blackberry" wine added 201mg/L and 161mg/L methanol in a inactivate sample (killing the natural pectinase).

For reference the commercial limit of methanol is 1000mg/L with some recommendations being lower and "a healthy individual can metabolize 1500 mg per hour of methanol without showing any ill effects" per the first source.

3

Sci-hub.tw

3
LuckyPoire•

One fun tidbit is that methanol can be a product of fermentation in the presence of pectin.

Methanol isn't a product of fermentation. It will be produced from pectin in the absence of any fermenting microbe.

Im not sure whether or not pectinase contributes to the eventual methanol level.

3
nolanthom•

Although the methanol content is so low that you don’t have to be too concerned, adding pectinase increases concentration of methanol, not decreasing it. Breaking down pectin will lead to greater formation of methanol to say it simplistically

2
StormBeforeDawn:wiki-editor: Wiki Editor•

https://www.bio-conferences.org/articles/bioconf/pdf/2017/02/bioconf-oiv2017_02028.pdf

You would be correct. Unless my memory fails me, u/LuckyPoire is the one who brought this up to me a year or so back, but I am struggling to source the conversation.

per some google fu it looks like the thread I am remembering is deleted, but plenty of other sources are around. I was seriously schooled about methanol and pectinase about a year back, and for some reason yesterday I got it backwards. I'll blame it on too much mead, despite that being non-factual. Thank you for the correction.

2
LuckyPoire•

I think we were debating the levels of methanol in distilled fractions rather than the source of methanol in musts/wine.

I remember that was a fun one....Cheers!

2
SilentBlizzard1•

I'm no chemistry buff, but I think I can help!

I work for a research university that offers a brewing program. I just did a quick search of our library knowledge database, and I found several articles related to mead (surprise to me). Just a few from the top of the list when used the keywords "mead" and "fermentation":

Improvement of mead fermentation by honey‐must supplementation

Pereira, Ana Paula ; Mendes‐Ferreira, Ana ; Estevinho, Leticia M. ; Mendes‐Faia, Arlete

Journal of the Institute of Brewing, July 2015, Vol.121(3), pp.405-410

________________________

Effects of Mead Wort Heat Treatment on the Mead Fermentation Process and Antioxidant Activity

Czabaj, Sławomir ; Kawa-Rygielska, Joanna ; Kucharska, Alicja ; Kliks, Jarosław

Molecules, 2017, Vol.22(5), p.803

_________________________

Mead fermentation monitoring by proton transfer reaction mass spectrometry and medium infrared probe

Cuenca, Martha ; Ciesa, Flavio ; Romano, Andrea ; Robatscher, Peter ; Scampicchio, Matteo ; Biasioli, Franco

European Food Research and Technology, 2016, Vol.242(10), pp.1755-1762

__________________________

Mead production: effect of nitrogen supplementation on growth, fermentation profile and aroma formation by yeasts in mead fermentation

Pereira, A. P. ; Mendes‐Ferreira, A. ; Oliveira, J. M. ; Estevinho, L. M. ; Mendes‐Faia, A.

Journal of the Institute of Brewing, February 2015, Vol.121(1), pp.122-128

___________________________

Are there specific keywords you'd like me to search with? I'll see what I can find.

13
SilentBlizzard1•

Also, kicking myself now. I totally knew I had access to these articles and journals but never looked until today.

3
Factolermentation:beginner: Beginner•

I just copied all of these into a word document so that I can pull them up the next time I'm waiting around in the lab for an experiment to finish. Thanks so much for these!

3
ShireMeadery•

PhD in Cell Biology/Biochemistry/Molecular Biology, with a masters in Biotechnology here. I don't really have time to get too deep into it, but I'll try to point you in the right direction.

The most interesting rabbit hole to go down is the Ehrlich Pathway. That gives you info into the fusel alcohols, when and how they form etc. I've found high temperatures and particularly "aggressive" yeast are prone to forming these, while some people actually seem to like a bit of a fusel hit, I tend to do everything in my power to avoid them. I'm also of the opinion that preventing fusels gives a much higher quality product than aging (other fragile/volatile compounds seem to be lost in aging).

Ester formation is another important factor to read up on - I've found colder temperatures and the right kind of yeast are key here, but overdoing it can lead to very "synthetic" flavours. For the most part searches for "volatile esters", "flavour-active esters", "alcohol acetyl transferase" will get you where you need to be, with particular attention to isoamyl acetate.

I would argue that honey, far from being "finicky" is a superior sugar source from fruit and grain, as it is (generally) more pure - you don't have to worry as much about acids, tannins, proteins, oils etc. attacking your palate, it's more of a blank canvas. That of course leads to nutrient deficiencies for the yeast, but these are easily fixed with a re-addition of these nutrients. Honey is also unique to the time and place of harvest due in part to the sugar mix, but often more importantly the botanicals collected and concentrated from local plants. So a deep dive into the science of mead flavour should also involve reading up on plant secondary metabolism too!

There's a wealth of info on wine/beer off flavours, including the chemistry, but note that some "off flavours" can actually be sought after in low quantities or in certain combinations.

The effect of pressure/CO2 concentration on fermentation is interesting too, but quite a high-level topic. Further reading can be found by searching things like "high pressure fermentation" - beermaking is where these techniques are most prominently used.

6
[deleted]•

What an awesome question. Super looking forward to the responses!

5
3VR0Ngreyjoy•

Bump because I want to know this too!!

3
yy0b•

Do you have access to scientific journals? There are papers that go over fermentation processes and flavor/aroma molecules. I can answer a couple of your questions though.

Honey is nutrient poor compared to other fermentables because it's mostly sugar with little else involved. That is why you need to add nutrients to get the yeast to actually grow without producing as many off flavors. The off flavors are produced when the yeast use alternate biochemical reaction pathways to generate energy. Normally they will simply make ethanol (which is more energy efficient iirc), but if they lack key nutrients for that metabolic pathway, they will use others instead, producing things like fusels. As for why Mead tends to have more fusels, part of it is due to nutrition and part of it also has to do with the yeast itself. Mead makers often use wine yeasts, which haven't been need to reduce fusel production like beer yeasts, this means that they generate more fusels in general.

3
KramerpaloozaOP:beginner: Beginner•

I actually do have lots of access, I'm a geneticist by trade and more importantly my brother is an Organic Synthesis PhD. He doesn't have the time to do the research for me, but he'll be able to get me access to whatever chemistry publications that I want.

2

Sci-hub.tw

1
zojbo•

It's not that honey is a bad sugar source. Yeast don't care that much about their sugar source...for any given sugar they pretty much can digest it or they can't.

The problem with honey is that it is a bad source of the other stuff yeast need. This stresses them which drives them to other metabolic routes that have other side products. Adding nitrogen (protein and nucleic acid precursor), phosphate (nucleic acid and phospholipid precursor), fatty acids (phospholipid precursor) and minerals keeps them happier and probably raises the peak cell count with all else equal.

I know one place that fusels "go" is into esters. Unfortunately I do not know to what extent these reactions proceed, nor their typical rate, but they are definitely slow at room temperature and non-extreme pH. This is true even when the ester product is being continuously removed to drive the reaction to completion (which isn't happening in brewing).

I don't know much else about specifics.

2
mayoriguana•

Not specifically mead related, but this paper on yeast genetics/flavor production from the scientists at white labs is extremely interesting

https://www.cell.com/cell/pdf/S0092-8674(16)31071-6.pdf

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Fallen_biologist:bee-bee-icon-11553482464: Welcoming Committee•

Actually, the topic came up in this sub's chat room yesterday. I complained that there was a lot of "common knowledge", but I never saw any scientific proof to back it up. I don't have academic access anymore, unfortunately. Would you keep us in the loop if you find out anything particularly interesting?

1

Here is a good start. The links in this should also lead to some good information.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6271869/

1
LuckyPoire•

Copy/pasting a comment from another thread on fusel alcohols.

Ester formation will be another important class of reactions involving organic acids, ethanol and longer chain alcohols. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3836583/

High nutrient, high temperatures, and high fermentation rates are associated with fusel alcohol production. Fusel production is primarily in influenced by strain and temperature, its not a hereditary condition. Higher than normal yeast rates produce more fusel alcohols; isoamyl alcohol in particular is increased by 80% for a four-fold increase in pitching rate. https://www.mbaa.com/publications/tq/tqPastIssues/1975/Abstracts/tq75ab03.htm Other literature suggests that the absolute and relative amounts of ammonium and free amino acids, in combination with the pitch rate govern the production of various higher alcohols. Pitched rate is positively correlated with some fusels, and negatively with others. In any case, the relevant factor is not some kind of injury, mutation or health of the strain. https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/agricultural-and-biological-sciences/fusel-alcohol https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/j.2050-0416.2007.tb00259.x Giving the yeast the best option of surviving and healthily producing is always preferable I think conflating the health of yeast with the quality of the flavor is a mistake. Stressed yeast can produce the best flavor.

1
StormBeforeDawn:wiki-editor: Wiki Editor•

Those are all paywalled, are you able to grab a g/gal or some other measure that is associated with more fusel production?

other literature suggests that the absolute and relative amounts of ammonium and free amino acids

As for that, are you able to pick out particular FAN ppms that can be linked to higher alcohols in conjunction with heavy handed pitch rates?

1
LuckyPoire•

Yeah I will try and dig that up when I have the right credentials.

2
funkmachine7•

What you want is a copy of Wine Science 5th Edition by Ronald Jackson. A Complete Guide to Quality in Small-Scale Wine Making. , is also worth buying too.

Really there's a major gap from the ABC's homebrewing to real scientific reference grade works. A part of it that we work of the same 60's an 70's era texts that can often at best be a bit lacking in there how an whys.

Yes there newer books on the market but there often not any better in technical knowledge then the old First steps in wine making.

1