aberuggOP•

According to his bio, Jim O'Neill is:

a former chairman of Goldman Sachs Asset Management and a former UK Treasury Minister, is Chair of Chatham House.

So this sentiment coming from him is pretty powerful. Good to see a wealthy and powerful man, who for a long time blindly bought into laissez-faire-like capitalism that benefited him greatly, now questioning it and admitting there is a better way.

1
aberuggOP•

My comment there for potential discussion here:

It's refreshing to read someone reform their view on a system that they have obviously benefited so disproportionately from at the likely expense of others. Your authoritative position in society can be leveraged to help make the change you now realize needs to happen, a reality.

I'll at least reply in agreement with you toward the talking point that you were opposing, "companies cannot afford to accommodate such a policy-driven change," with some important facts and better framing than is common in the public media sphere.

  1. More often than not the mechanisms to pay for these social programs are proposed to be paid for by corporate profits and high income bracket marginal income tax increases. There is a subtle bait and switch that the defenders of laissez-faire capitalism are using when they make this talking point. Any profitable company can necessarily afford up to a 100% tax on their profits. All of them. Because they are given tax cuts (at least in the US) for capital expenditures, stock buybacks, etc... and the word "profits" is synonymous with net revenue, a number that is already counted in after labor costs. The "but what about the jobs creators" argument is a red herring. There is no real mechanism proposed that would prove companies are incapable of avoiding their profitable net revenue liability by spending profits on more labor and increasing pay (thus, increasing their bucket of tax-exempt gross revenue spending). Anyone that knows anything about taxes regarding business would know this. So either we've got a lot of leaders of companies that are liars, or they are overwhelmingly stupid and don't even know how their finances work. I think it's more likely they are dishonest, given the evidence.

  2. People that respond to policies designed to satisfy the masses' plights in a democratic society is necessarily a moral question, since it's regarding how moral agents ought to be treated. Therefore, cold human-less economic equations that many of those who oppose higher minimum wages appeal to, are actually total non-sequiturs to the discussion. While modern economists's criticisms of something like Marx's Labor Theory of Value are correct in saying it's explanatory power is inherently flawed, and they are correct to assert Marx WAS attempting to explain economic systems... The inspiration and theories that emerged after Marx, largely called heterodox economics, are starting from the premise that moral agents ought to be treated with some decency we could consider a minimum standard of living. So intelligibly responding with an argument which rests on a necessary premise that this axiom is false, is just begging the question. Unintelligibly responding in this way is just a non-sequitur.

  3. On the more fact-based side of things, there is an inverse relation between consumer goods spending per dollar earned and household income. This means as someone makes more, they spend less of a proportion of their income on consumer goods. All companies not willing to pay their employees well are directly contributing to unnecessary inefficiencies in our economic and a reduced potential economic output (GDP). All for short-sighted flawed thinking and/or quarterly earnings goals to satisfy primarily overly wealthy shareholders.

Hope this contributes something to the discussion.

1