Command Chaos - Slinging fire is only half of it. How to sling it is the rest.

Command Chaos - Slinging fire is only half of it. How to sling it is the rest.

Posted Nov 15, 2019, 3:21 PM UTC

32
TorakaaOPI reject your hybrid and substitute multicolour!•

Aren't I so clever.

This card mostly came about from watching some 4c Saheeli Cat Pioneer Approach Control and lamenting that Deafening Clarion's secondary mode really doesn't get as much use as it should, aside from recovering life paid to an Adanto Vanguard. Somehow it keeps getting into my head that Clarion itself could gain lifelink, but sadly that is not the case. But what if it could? So here's this. You can deal a lot of damage, or deal some damage and gain equally as much.

The modes are intentionally situational in order to make the lifegain mode more enticing. For a while I had the first mode dealing damage to players or planeswalkers, but 4 damage is a lot and it would simply turn into a staple mode, whacking the opponent for 4 and then picking one more mode. That, and making it only planeswalkers meant I could fit each mode on one line which is simply wonderful.

Looking back at it, the second and third mode should probably have traded places. Not because there's any mechanical difference, but because a lot of people would expect there to be. Remember, damage doesn't kill anyone, state-based actions do. Even if you choose the second and third mode, the attacking creatures won't die until the spell has fully resolved and they have done damage to their controller.

Some might note the third mode as not feeling like a Boros ability, notably being like the third mode on Rakdos Charm and mimicking certain black cards in effect, most closely Revenge of Ravens. What can I say, Boros is just black in an overcoat. Plus, there's an important distinction. While I would say making each creature deal 1 damage to its controller is a red ability tending towards black, counting specifically attackers brings it more towards white's retributive theme.

Design seed: Seriously, how much life has Deafening Clarion ever gained?

2
Fenrirr(Z->)90° - (E-N²W)90°t=1•

The third effect seems firmly within red/black and is different from red/white justice effects.

1