Changes that could be made to Climbey to get on the Oculus Store
I heard about Climbey being the most popular SideQuest game, and saw a bunch of people shocked about how Oculus could possibly refuse it. Apparently, the only feedback was that it's "not polished enough." Finally gave the game a shot last night, and I noticed more than a few problems, which strike me as red flags for a game that's been in early access for over 3 years:
When the game starts, the Climbey Demo logo overlaps with the game, and the "depth-fighting" is pretty off-putting; there's no smooth transition from loading to playing.
The buttons on the options menu don't work. Part of the problem is that interacting with the menu involves using big hands with thick fingers to press small buttons; it feels like there's actual collision with all 5 fingers on each hand, so trying to use one finger while holding that hand horizontally to press one of the higher buttons on, for example, the Comfort menu, will result in pressing the "Start!" button.
Another issue is that even when you hear the "button clicked" noise, the button press doesn't seem to actually register. You keep trying to hit the button, and sometimes the light comes on, if it's on, it probably stays on, if you were just trying out the option to see what it was like before turning it off. I'm not sure why it uses that system over something simple and intuitive like this.
Still on the menu, the most obvious problem with interacting with it is that when you boot up an Oculus Quest for the first time, you play the Oculus First Steps app, which introduces you to the CapTouch sensors on the controllers. You get a really nice hand presence feeling because the headset knows when you're resting your fingers on each button, and has a matching animation for all of that. Climbey gives you hands, but doesn't use any of that.
Continuing with controller issues, Climbey is effectively a 1-button game. The current "VR meta" is that on Vive wands, because the grip button is a crappy, tough click that you don't wanna rely on too much, the "grab" input is generally gonna be with the trigger, or a toggle with the grip button, depending on the game. If you pick up something with a trigger, then it will pull the trigger (i.e. on a gun). On Oculus Touch and Index controllers, however, because you have a nice grip input in the form of grip sensors or an analog grip trigger, you're expected to use an intuitive 3-finger squeeze to pick things up, and continue holding that squeeze to continue holding the item. To let go, simply ease up on the squeeze. Climbey instead puts arm swinger locomotion on the grip trigger and the grip action on the front trigger: as a binary input! It feels awful. If I squeeze the trigger halfway, I should see a half-grip. Just pick an activation point; I hear 20% works well enough as a threshold.
The haptics are no good. I eventually realized that you can't climb on dark surfaces, even though the tutorial robot says you can climb on "any surface." But the haptics should tell you when your hand is overlapping with a climbable surface, maybe combined with an animation change.
The framerate is wonky. There's a jump right before the end of the tutorial level, and the first time I tried it, the game decided to drop something like half a second of frames while I was in midair, causing me to plummet all the way to the bottom, completely resetting my progress. There wasn't a second time.
Movement is also wonky. I usually like arm swinging locomotion, but it's so stilted in this game. It doesn't feel snappy like H3VR, and I don't feel like I'm in control, even when I set it to controller direction. Also, enabling snap turn seems to rotate the level rather than the player's VR origin, so things like flags will react to the turn action, which makes no sense.
The tutorial robot mentions the Steam workshop. Not sure why that line wasn't edited out of its dialog. As a user, how am I supposed to react to that, knowing that the Steam workshop is inaccessible on Oculus Quest? Does that mean I'm only getting the 20 levels mentioned? Am I missing out on tons of content because I'm getting this on Quest and not Steam? Not to mention, that tutorial robot looks like it was ripped straight out of Portal.
That's all I have for now. There are other issues, like the Forfeit button porting you seemingly to the next level from the tutorial level, but this post is too long as it is. If I worked at Oculus, I'd refuse the game for the reasons laid out above. I saw the dev respond to someone else bringing up some of these issues with a sentiment along the lines of "yeah, well, that's how I like it," which is their prerogative, but it might be useful to adopt a more "user first" mentality to this sort of thing, especially when it comes time to try to get into a walled garden like the Oculus store.
Posted Nov 19, 2019, 7:22 PM UTC
I was really looking forward to trying the game/demo but I have to agree with some of your points. The horizontal movement and jumping system in particular felt really iffy and didn't seem to give me the same results each time I tried something.