Reddit has a hard on for Nuclear Energy that often ignores and downright underplays the dangers of radioactive waste

Something I've noticed here is that Reddit is overwhelmingly in support of nuclear energy. Don't get me wrong, I think for the 21st century Nuclear Power should be an important part of our energy pie so to speak but this idea that Nuclear is a completely safe green energy source with no pollutants or long term waste issues is frankly absurd. Often times die hard supporters of nuclear energy will suggest up to 50 percent of our energy or more should come from nuclear while ignoring the fact that they're being completely hypocritical of their own criticisms towards solar or wind that it's risky for us to be so reliant on them. Surely it's not good to be entirely reliable for any one kind of energy so why should we be for nuclear? Also, nuclear waste is absolutely a byproduct that cannot be ignored. Management of nuclear waste as it is now is already dangerous and difficult to eliminate. Not disposing of this waste (which lasts upwards of thousands of years) properly can result in horrific damage to our environment and our own people. Again, I'm not saying we shouldn't use Nuclear Energy or not research more into the field (fusion could be quite useful down the pike for a variety of applications) but Reddit's insistence of it being this miracle energy source are ridiculous.

Posted Nov 22, 2019, 6:01 PM UTC

59
SadSalamander5•

The waste could be fed back into breeder reactors and it wouldn't be a problem. Of course, that would create weapons-capable fissile material, so we got problems all around.

6
guystringofnumbersOP•

Yeah I didn't even touch on the security concerns regarding nuclear energy which is unfortunate

2
SadSalamander5•

Well, my point is that nuclear can really be a renewable and clean energy source, but we can't trust each other enough to not make weapons from the byproducts.

4
Symbiotic_parasite•

The biggest reality we have to face is that yes, they do pose some level of danger, and the slight possibility for a massive failure... So who's going to want them in their community / anywhere near their community? It's much more reasonable to take advantage of the fusion reactor we already have and use solar panels, in addition to wind, tidal, and geothermal

3
guystringofnumbersOP•

Exactly

1
turing_test_13•

if they are so reliable then why did this happen

*https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H9Sv82G9Qkg&list=WL&index=27&t=0s

2

The nuclear energy hardon Reddit has honestly just seems like the STEM circlejerk but more specific. You object? You’re just not smart and educated enough to understand how good it actually is! Let’s ignore the 1.5% meltdown rate to date, the fact it emits CO2 at a rate that surpasses the threshold set by the ccc, and the fact we literally cannot build enough reactors at a rate that would actually counter climate change. Don’t believe the thorium circlejerk either, it can be proliferated, the radiation is more severe, and independent agencies agree that it won’t phase out uranium. Just believe the ThoriumFoundation and ThoriumFluorideReactor .com, they can’t possibly have a conflict of interest...

2
UrHeftyLeftyBesty•

The failure of nuclear energy as a viable solution is a direct result of governments making nuclear infeasible to protect utility companies and oil and gas. Because installing nuclear requires massive scale investment (nuke plants can take 15 years from planning to bringing it online), governments can kill those projects relatively easily by making them economically infeasible after the investment has already began. Whereas large scale solar can be installed quickly and in phases, which reduces government’s ability to intercede.

0
WordSaladSlayer•

You phrase it like it's a conspiracy but latest news:

U.S. won’t clean up Marshall Islands nuclear waste dome but wants it free of anti-U.S. graffiti

US nuclear reactor shut down after officials discover leak - South Carolina

More likely it's just the usual political incompetence. US rolled back the protections for the gulf oil spill and Canada Ontario scrapped its wind mills.

1