That dumb ranged house rule

:GCP: Glass Cannon Podcast

So I am currently on my 3rd listen through through the Glass Cannon Podcast and I am currently in the 70s. I seem to always forget about the ranged miss house rule and am so annoyed by it each time I relisten to it. The fact that a miss from a ranged attack has the ability to automatically hit one of your fellow companions just infuriates me. Seriously I'm so happy that they got rid of this thing. But that's just me what do you guys think about this rule?

Posted Nov 24, 2019, 2:37 AM UTC

4542
Nonegoose•

I detested that rule because it felt too far into the game to alter the table rules roo much. I feel the same way about how they handle bottlecaps now- they're way less fun as just a basic bonus.

54
gormley2088•

Totally agree. They dont even care about receiving them anymore either.

19
DarkCrystal34•

Yeah but the bottlecaps were gtting way too ovrpowered to be able to reroll that much and then if hit it make 4 attacks. Agree that bottlecaps have no real meaning now but feel it was a good transition to make.

5
Drigr:Nestor: Coyne By Nature•

I feel part of the problem is they were supposed to be more common with the new rule, but they're just as rare as before.

15
Spadie:Tumsey: Tumsy!!!•

I think they're more rare than before.

15
350:Troy: We're Having Fun!•

Statistically, the flat bonus is now actually better than a straight reroll.

12
DarkCrystal34•

True! But quantitatively, the fun-factor has gone down 67.83% since Book 3 in terms of Bottlecaps :-)

15

it really doesn't feel as fun

5
350:Troy: We're Having Fun!•

...what? My point is that if you thought the reroll was too strong, the flat bonus is even stronger. Not that it ends up mattering that much since Troy never hands them out.

1†
pogiepika•

It wasn’t that use of the bottlecap that was broken, it was forcing baddies to save twice vs a save or die that was so OP.

2
350:Troy: We're Having Fun!•

Then, just eliminate that use of it?

1
DarkSoulsExcedere:Satisfactory: SATISFACTORY!!!•

not true at all, a flat bonus that scales with level is VASTLY stronger than a simple reroll.

3
Dndfixplz•

Their house rules usually feel like they're more detrimental to the fun of the game than beneficial. I don't remember this house rule, but it's absolutely ridiculous and basically makes all ranged characters add CR 1/2 their level to all fights, since they're basically fighting against the party half of the time.

20
saskatch-a-toon•

Nestor hit teammates more than giants. It kind of fit his character though.

11
BurningToaster•

God their Prepared Caster houserule was the WORST.

9
Zanzibarr11Four more Bears!•

Could you remind me of that one?

4
bfevans19•

In early episodes Troy would only make wizards and clerics and such prepare the highest level of spell they knew how to cast, and any lower levels they could cast spontaneously.

9
Drolfdir•

That is actually almost like official optional rules set from Pathfinder Unchained. The official rules require you to prepare the three highest levels and you lose 1 slot on the lower, spontaneous slots though. So same principle but with game balance

4
chaos_cowboy•

So they critical roled it?

1
Zanzibarr11Four more Bears!•

Ahhh. Well I can see that being a good rule though. At low levels you get less than a handful of spell slots. Commiting to "bless" or "sleep" before encountering your first enemies, then realizing that you chose something ineffectual, kind of kills the one thing low level casters have going for them.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
cmd-t•

There isn’t a single house rule (69/86? on d100, exploding dice, which are almost as good as a crit) they use that I think actually makes the game more fun. Just like Skid, I think the fan crits and fumbles suck. They are detrimental to the game and to fun. I’m happy there aren’t any in AA.

13
mpschmidtleinOP:Troy: We're Having Fun!•

There are a ton of Fan Crits and fumbles in AA. One of the most memorable one for me where Skid got pissed at was the magnetic one in the jungle in. Ook 2. He got so pissed, I actually felt really bad for the person who wrote it. Honestly I even if i upped my patreon amount each month, i dont think I'd ever try sending in a fumble or crit in fear that Skid gets it and chews me out in the podcast.

7
Decicio:Tumsey: Tumsy!!!•

There are only fan fumbles in AA not crits

5
N7DarebearFor Highbury!•

They should have gone with the one about believing in Beary's theories

12
flipkitty:Joe: Hummus and CHIPS!•

I think you could possibly justify a version where a miss on a grappled enemy could hit the grappler. But if you're going to play with hitting adjacent characters, then it should be possible to hit adjacent enemies!

9
absolutbill:Nestor: Coyne By Nature•

Or if you roll a Nat 1, then a Nat 1 on confirmation.

5
Sorcatarius•

It's a garbage rule and an instant red flag anytime I play and the GM tells me this is a house rule they play with.

No one should play with it and whoever is responsible for it should have their d20s melted down and poured in their eyes.

7
SquirrelOnFire•

In their eyes you say?

4
adagna:Satisfactory: SATISFACTORY!!!•

Hmm, that sure escalated quickly...

2
jokershigh83•

I never liked it because it implied any miss would be wildly off target and potentially hit someone else. Against a high AC opponent this makes no sense - a 25 against a creature with AC 28 doesn't mean it's off target in my mind, but rather hitting the tougher armor and not dealing damage.

I'd maybe consider it if the miss was larger (say, a 5 rolled against a 23) AND there were allies around/behind the target, but even this feels a bit tough on the players.

6
Zachpi•

To me, 10 is the off target number, since that's the ac of someone with no dex or armor who isn't dodging. That said, that's a rule that would almost never happen after low levels, so there isn't really a point to implementing something like it either

4
gmjustaworm•

This is one of those house rules that every GM thinks is a good idea at one point , “because it just makes sense” , tries it out, and then realizes it is stupid and annoyingly penalizing. Hopefully the GM move on quickly.

The penalty , and subsequent feats, assume that the character is trying to be careful and not hit allies. There should be no chance to hit allies in normal circumstances. The crit cards already do this kind of stuff if the GM wants something like it.

What there should be , though , is a mechanic to “shoot hastily” that is a risk - reward situation: Trade an attack bonus for a chance to hit ally on fumble. This way, you give the player the decision.

3
DefendsTheDownvoted:Lorc: Desk Ranger•

After reading the comments it seems I'm the only one who wasn't bothered by it. Although I don't remember the exact rule. If it was something like:

"When targeting an enemy with a ranged weapon, if shooting through an allies square, or if there is an adjacent ally, there is a 20% chance to hit an ally on a missed shot."

that just make sense to me, honestly. But if it was a flat 20% to hit an ally in your line of sight, yeah, that's bullshit.

Edit: Downvotes. Wow. I'm so sorry I contributed my opinion to the conversation. I thought we could maybe have a friendly discussion. My bad. It won't happen again. This community is such shit.

1†
Thatguy_Koop:Torag: Wash Your Hands!•

as someone who doesn't play, i thought it was hilarious. but if i were playing the ranged character I'd feel like i was being punished for not wanting to be a frontline fighter or caster.

5
bfevans19•

The reason it's a bad rule isn't because it make no sense physically. Shooting an enemy next to an ally should be harder. It's a bad rule because shooting an enemy next to an ally already is harder, you take a -4 to all such attacks unless you spend a feat to buy precise shot. Throwing another handicap on a play style that is already pretty hampered is just kind of a dick move, especially since there is no way to really avoid shooting into melee in most encounters.

4
mpschmidtleinOP:Troy: We're Having Fun!•

The big issue for me, and I have no issue with you enjoying the rule to each their own, is that the game already penalizes ranged characters by either making them take a penalty to their attack roll, or making them use a feat not to. Adding this, though having the potential to be funny really makes ranged characters less efficient than melee and makes the game worse for them.

4