You've heard of the old and tired "actually, the Uyghur camps aren't even real" take, now get ready for the new hotness: "actually, the Uyghur camps are good and we should have them over here too"

Posted Nov 25, 2019, 5:54 AM UTC
858

Posted Nov 25, 2019, 5:54 AM UTC
I would love to see one of these people tell a black person the US needs "education centers" for people "at risk" of being criminals
Looked up this person twitter for laughs. Hardcore chinese government supporter. Defended his argument by saying countries like saudi arabia approved china's action, as we all know, SA is the gold standard for human rights.
Deflected the studies and criticism from other countries (like western europe and the US) by saying they are imperialist, forgetting china is also imperialist.
Basically, this kind of comment is what happen when a tankie sucks up anything with a red coat.
What's with their fascination of the state and ways to oppress and control?
And no abolitionist will ever say "yup that prison camp is a much better way to not oppress as much as our prison camps." Is it because they are "reeducation camps" so they are "rehabilitated" instead of "punished"?
Like forcing people of different cultures that have lived in the area for awhile I'm pretty sure, to adopt Chinese norms and customs, while diminishing non-chinese cultures through "reeducation camps" and cultural adoption through propaganda and force, is a pretty imperialistic thing to do, yeah? These tankies hate american imperialism, as they should. But when china invaded Tibet and destroyed their culture leaving behind a hollowed culture with chinese characteristics, and submission to the Chinese state, they either agree with china or deny it's the same thing. China has been with imperialism for a long time now. All they know is sinicization and oppression. And tankies love that shit.
Like what is the appeal? How does one rationalize that while saying it's also what communism is? I guess it's just another sad case of broiled brain.
Tankies will support anything that the "west" oppose and calls itself communist. For them, anything that can be seen against the regime must be destroyed. This is why they happily gobble down chinese propaganda and don't care for the mass murders made by the chinese government.
Im wondering if tankies actually know what communism means.
This is literally the same mindset as chuds. Just replace opposing the west with opposing liberals, they happily gooble down propaganda and don't care for the mass murders made by the American government.
Shit man, they really are red fash.
On they do. Communism is obviously what lenin said. "The state is violence. But usually it's on behalf of the moneybags. But this time, the state violence is on behalf of the people." Paraphrased, of course.
And then he ordered the wanton slaughter and imprisonment of those said people, even creating an all powerful police force that controlled nearly the entire government, doling out deaths with a discount.
He went the complete opposite way of what Marx said. But goon ass tankies just don't see that. Or it makes sense to them. Like they see the need of such a power dynamic because they are only capable of thinking in those terms. Marx-lenism is Marxism for dumbass bootlicks who still need a state and strictly rigid classes, but want to do what the cool kids are talking about.
He ruined any original potential about communism being even discussed seriously, as the next step. I'm pretty sure it's a ploy from when capitalists, in a last ditch effort to avoid an international revolution of the proletariat being successful, they either did some occult shit to change lenin, or it's some global capitalist psiop long con facade falseflag project bluebeam agenda 21 con to villify communism to such a large degree. We're only just recently having Marxism being seriously discussed. But MLs are definitely making it hard to be taken seriously. "LeTs MoDeL aFtEr ThE uSsR". Ugh.
I do have some mixed feelings about Tibet because they had slaves though
From what I can gather, it's possible the poor peasants would give up their kids to Lords because they were too poor to afford them. Or peasants were actually well off and not affected by famine. It goes both ways.
And in 1904, British dude was put in charge of a district, and he wrote that slavery was still practiced, was only a dozen or two in total, and "was of a very mild type." Apparently if a slave is mistreated, it's not too hard to run away. While in no way do I justify slavery, a lot of the tibetan slavery controversy was spurred on by China and their claims that tibet is "barbaric" for their justification of their sinicization and annexation of Tibet. While the total impact of slavery past that little excerpt is not well known, I guess, we can only say they definitely had slaves at one point.
But does that justify the destruction of a total culture and society that maybe didn't have slaves at the end? I don't think so. Not to china, at least.
They apparently practiced a lot of messed up punishments, though. Eye gouging, boiling, amputations, just a bunch of gnarly shit. But a Dalai lama did abolish a lot of that and the death penalty. So who knows, yo.