r/pokemongo•
mp55404

Niantic Wayfarer Ratings in the Red !!

Discussion

I have been doing Waypoints reviews on Niantic Wayfarer recently. Been taking them very seriously. Even reviewed the rules a few times, review a few youtube videos a few times, and checking with some resources to make sure that I am doing it to the best benefit of the community. After all, we want much more high quality pokestops/gyms.

... but ... a few days ago, my ratings went from green to yellow. And this morning, it went from yellow to red. And of course, I was offered to be able to take a retest -- sort of like a make up test to not fail out of school.

I am not sure what I am doing wrong ... and not sure what to do next. I am not sure if I am too strict, or if I am too lenient. I really want to help the community, and have been trying my best, but there is something amiss. At this point, I am thinking of stopping, as it seems that my reviews are not what Niantic wants/needs.

Anyone else running into this issue?

Posted Nov 26, 2019, 2:36 AM UTC

06
theesado•

Your rating is based on your agreement with other reviewers, not what niantic wants. Several ingress reviewers with thousands of reviews before wayfarer have had their ratings decrease once pogo players could review. Assuming you're interpreting niantics wayfarer rules correctly, your rating could be affected by people who don't know what they're doing outweighed correct reviewers.

3
mp55404OPInstinct•

Looks like Reddit would prefer that this is discussed in a different location, so, I am going to keep my responses short -- and let this topic die on it's own. I did take a look at the other location, so, hopefully, will learn some stuff to help out.

The agreement concept, while nice, doesn't really help to improve reviewing. For disagreements, I can't tell what they are, and hence, can't tell how to fix it.

Anyway, I think I am simply going to hold off for now... perhaps, in the future, there will be better tutorials on how to better review. For now, it is just too much effort, for little value add (as my ratings imply that I will not have any affect) to help get more quality submissions.

2
TastyRollz•

Same thing happened to me and my son. I believe that the second chance quiz will clue you in to what you were doing wrong. My son received a number second chance questions about signage. (He told me he had rejected a fancy Buca De Bepo neon sign submission as a “generic business” since it’s a national chain restaurant. Obviously that was not the right choice!) As for me, I received a number of second chance questions about what star ratings to assign to the google maps pin locations. I realized from looking at the multiple choice answers on the second chance quiz that I had been rating those incorrectly.

1
Fuzzy974•

Well I’m guessing your reviews are too harsh. Lots of reviewers are being too hard on validating.

People wants to have Pokéstop next to their home, and they don’t all have a historical landmarks...

If you look into my City, half the Pokéstops are commemorative plaques... And that’s before they opened Wayfarer to PoGo players. Immagine if anything below that is not accepted. We’d get 0 new stops, that’s not the point.

So maybe just be a bit more relax and go with the flow?

1
mp55404OPInstinct•

Update... it looks like, after a week of not doing any more reviews, my rating went back to yellow. So, I guess I did finally get some agreement.

Unfortunately, this whole thing left me thinking about it a bit. I don't enjoy doing reviews. It is a lot of work, just to get told how bad I was at it -- and being told to have to take a test to prove myself again (which I did not do by the way).

So, I guess I will just play the game, and maybe submit a pokestop once in a while, and leave the reviewing to those that enjoy doing them.

1
AutoModeratorMOD01000010 01001111 01010100•

Hello trainer,

Automod here. It seems this post may be related to the creation of new pokéstops/gyms and/or the nomination & review process.

For questions and discussion about eligible waypoints, nomination criteria, reviewing nominations, and other Wayfarer specifics, the community at r/NianticWayfarer are the experts!

Please post over there so all Wayfarer reviewers across Niantic's games can answer and learn :D

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-2