AITA for saying no to holiday dinner

Not the A-hole

Our story begins Tue, the day before a planned 325 mile journey to my hometown for Thanksgiving with my family. I call my mom at the behest of my wife to find out what the plan is for turkey day (we were thinking mid-day dinner at my aunt's house which is the case nearly everytime we join them for the holiday). My mom tells me that this year we'll be eating at the house of someone my aunt is a caregiver for. My wife nor I know the two men who live there but my aunt decided to have the dinner there because the house is "cleaner, nicer, and bigger" than her home. My wife has anxiety which gets worse around strangers (particularly older men) and I told my mom I felt like the situation would be awkward.

At the time of the first phone call my mom said she understood and when my wife got home from work we offered to take my mom out to some place that is open and even pay. Mom said that we could think on it and decide the next day (Wed). My wife had to work a half day before we could leave so we decided to discuss on the drive.

Wednesday morning my aunt texts me and says that my mom told her of our concerns but she didn't think it would be a big deal. It would be all my family plus the two guys and they know them from church so it's fine.

The more I thought about it the more I agreed with my wife. Having Thanksgiving at a strangers house is awkward and uncomfortable, especially with such short notice. The thing that got me is that this was apparently the plan all along and no one was going to tell us about it until the day of. They knew we were coming down and that this was going to be the plan, but no one reached out to tell me.

On the drive down my wife asked how I felt and said that if I wanted to go she would deal with her anxiety and go for me. I told her I would never ask her to ignore her anxiety to make me comfortable and that I also felt like the situation would be weird.

We called my mom to let her know that we got to the hotel okay and to tell her we understand my aunt's feeling but we would prefer not to go. My mom, who had said she understood the day before, no longer understood why it was such a big deal and got pretty annoyed with me over the phone. She rejected our offers to take her anywhere and abruptly had to end the call.

This morning she did end up texting me and asking if we wanted to do brunch with herself, my sister, and my wife to which we agreed. My sister later told my wife she told my mom not to be "mean and upset" on Thanksgiving and we did make the drive to see her.

I admit that I feel I may be the a-hole only because I failed to touch base with my aunt to talk about seeing her, my uncle, and cousin after the dinner. My mom was being an intermediary and I didn't reach out further.

So Reddit AITA for skipping Thanksgiving with my family at the home of two strangers to save my wife from having bad anxiety all night and avoid a situation I also thought would be uncomfortable?

Posted Nov 29, 2019, 1:40 AM UTC

320
paul131313Asshole Aficionado [12]•

NTA - She gave you the illusion of choice with no actual choice she expected you to come but said you didn't. Pretty manipulative.

7
Jujuj0•

NTA

You have a right to decline. Also I personally hate when somebody invites people I don't know to parties or gatherings without my consent. Your aunt should know better.

5
7thatsanope•

NTA. At all. You did the right thing as a husband and put your wife’s well-being first.

As soon as you were told of the plan, something significantly different than expected, you said it would be a problem for your wife, you offered an alternate option that is perfectly reasonable, you didn’t demand that anyone else change their plans to accommodate you and your wife, you simply opted not to attend and gave alternate options for seeing your family while you were there. You did everything right. Your family has no good reason to be mad. And most importantly, your wife knows you have her back and are looking out for her needs.

5
[deleted]•

NTA- if you were up front about it I don’t see the issue. I commend you for supporting your wife.

3
AutoModeratorMODAutomation Enthusiast•

^^^^AUTOMOD The following is a copy of the above post. This comment is a record of the above post as it was originally written, in case the post is deleted or edited. Read this before contacting the mod team

Our story begins Tue, the day before a planned 325 mile journey to my hometown for Thanksgiving with my family. I call my mom at the behest of my wife to find out what the plan is for turkey day (we were thinking mid-day dinner at my aunt's house which is the case nearly everytime we join them for the holiday). My mom tells me that this year we'll be eating at the house of someone my aunt is a caregiver for. My wife nor I know the two men who live there but my aunt decided to have the dinner there because the house is "cleaner, nicer, and bigger" than her home. My wife has anxiety which gets worse around strangers (particularly older men) and I told my mom I felt like the situation would be awkward.

At the time of the first phone call my mom said she understood and when my wife got home from work we offered to take my mom out to some place that is open and even pay. Mom said that we could think on it and decide the next day (Wed). My wife had to work a half day before we could leave so we decided to discuss on the drive.

Wednesday morning my aunt texts me and says that my mom told her of our concerns but she didn't think it would be a big deal. It would be all my family plus the two guys and they know them from church so it's fine.

The more I thought about it the more I agreed with my wife. Having Thanksgiving at a strangers house is awkward and uncomfortable, especially with such short notice. The thing that got me is that this was apparently the plan all along and no one was going to tell us about it until the day of. They knew we were coming down and that this was going to be the plan, but no one reached out to tell me.

On the drive down my wife asked how I felt and said that if I wanted to go she would deal with her anxiety and go for me. I told her I would never ask her to ignore her anxiety to make me comfortable and that I also felt like the situation would be weird.

We called my mom to let her know that we got to the hotel okay and to tell her we understand my aunt's feeling but we would prefer not to go. My mom, who had said she understood the day before, no longer understood why it was such a big deal and got pretty annoyed with me over the phone. She rejected our offers to take her anywhere and abruptly had to end the call.

This morning she did end up texting me and asking if we wanted to do brunch with herself, my sister, and my wife to which we agreed. My sister later told my wife she told my mom not to be "mean and upset" on Thanksgiving and we did make the drive to see her.

I admit that I feel I may be the a-hole only because I failed to touch base with my aunt to talk about seeing her, my uncle, and cousin after the dinner. My mom was being an intermediary and I didn't reach out further.

So Reddit AITA for skipping Thanksgiving with my family at the home of two strangers to save my wife from having bad anxiety all night and avoid a situation I also thought would be uncomfortable?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
AutoModeratorMODAutomation Enthusiast•

If you want your comment to count toward judgment, include only ONE of the following abbreviations in your comment. If you don't include a judgement abbreviation, the bot will ignore you when it looks for the top voted comment.

JudgmentAbbreviation
You're the Asshole (& the other party is not)YTA
You're Not the A-hole (& the other party is)NTA
Everyone Sucks HereESH
No A-holes hereNAH
Not Enough InfoINFO

#Click Here For Our Full Rulebook

#Click Here For Our FAQ

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
LetsFuckOnTheBoatPartassipant [2]•

NTA You did what was right for your wife

Happy wife, Happy life

1
Samantha_Synister•

NTA - Theres no need to put your wife or yourself in a situation that could or would cause anxiety to make others happy or all feel goody. fuck what they think and you do you. you offered an alternative that was reasonable cause eating at a restaurant with your family is normal while eating at some fucking strangers house with your family for a holiday is not fucking normal and i would panic and burn the place down if it was me personally. so no, you are so NTA.

1
rcathar20Professor Emeritass [87]•

Have you ever lived in the real world?

eating at some fucking strangers house with your family for a holiday is not fucking normal and i would panic and burn the place down if it was me personally

No one should be listening to you about what is "normal". Also what is with all the xenophobia in this thread. How is it that fucking terrifying to eat in a house you haven't been to before?

0
Samantha_Synister•

wow thats a pretty transphobic/racist thing to say there mr "hur dur your xenophobia".

-1
Wickerhero•

are you the normal police or just another internet handle with an opinion? yta.

-1
WowSeriously666Certified Proctologist [20]•

"Having Thanksgiving at a strangers house is awkward and uncomfortable, especially with such short notice. "

I have a feeling the Pilgrims and Native Americans probably felt the same way...

1
rcathar20Professor Emeritass [87]•

YTA

Unless I'm severely misunderstanding something, I agree fully with the rest of your family. Why should it matter what house you eat in, how is this less comfortable than going to a public place which you offered to do? Your whole family will be there, I assume heavily outnumbering the two men you don't know, yet those two men (even though vouched for by your aunt) are going to make this so uncomfortable for you that you are going to throw a big fit about it and not show up? I'm sorry but unless you guys seriously have some sort of crazy intense clinically diagnosed mental illness that makes this hard for you, it sounds like your family decided on a very reasonable change for dinner that should not matter to you and you threw such a big fit about it that you decided not to go.

Edit: Everyone in this thread is saying NTA and making it out as if his family is asking something crazy unreasonable of him. Literally they are moving to a nicer venue with 2 people (compared to OP's entire family) that they don't know, and everyone in here is acting as if their family seriously wronged them, wtf

0†
7thatsanope•

You clearly don’t understand anxiety.

8
rcathar20Professor Emeritass [87]•

That's not true. It's very tough sometimes to judge these posts when people throw in the phrase "x person has anxiety". This is because everyone gets anxiety towards various activities to some extent, but then there are people who literally have anxiety disorders that cause them to experience insane amounts of anxiety that normal people don't experience. The post didn't indicate any specific anxiety disorder, so I assumed this to just be the standard sort of social anxiety that a large portion of people have and can be very manageable. I specifically said in my post that my judgment was made assuming they don't literally have a clinically diagnosed disorder. I just don't like how lightly people throw around the terms depression and anxiety on this sub sometimes, because it seems like people use it as a catch all to excuse them of any behavior whatsoever. I am fully supportive of making accommodations for people that have diagnosed ailments though of course

2
ThedownsidedOP•

The main issue was in the very last paragraph. They do this kind of thing all of the time. We didn't "throw a big fit" or expect them to change their plan. We simply declined to attend and offered an alternative.

2
rcathar20Professor Emeritass [87]•

Maybe this is a semantics issue here, but in my opinion if you agree to plans, then there is a slight change to the plans and not only do you take issue with it but literally decide you are no longer going, I think it's fair to call that "throwing a fit", but maybe I can understand if we are going by exact definitions it might be unfair to call it that. But I think to say that it's just "simply declining" is also unfair. And also if they do this all the time, that's sort of a separate issue that isn't in the scope of this post.

Maybe I'm biased from my family, but it's just boggling my mind and I can't understand how this was reasonable on your end. I'm trying to imagine a situation where it's something like:

My family organized a meal at house x with them, I agreed to go. Then my family told me at the last minute, "hey we are actually going to my friend Y's house instead". And then I'd turn around and say "well i don't know Y , this isn't what we agreed to and I'm not coming". This just seems insane to me. Hell most people I know wouldn't even say it much in advance, they'd probably just text me earlier in the day and say "hey actually go to this new address for the meal instead"

1
ThedownsidedOP•

They told us nothing of their plans and likely would not have until the last minute. We asked before leaving out of curiosity and were told the plan.

1
rcathar20Professor Emeritass [87]•

Maybe try to empathize with them a bit more and you can understand the situation a bit better. Rather than jumping to accusing them of not being accommodating of you and your wife, perhaps their thought process could have been something like this:

"Wow, now we get to have our dinner in a nicer house and I can introduce my family to my friends from church. I'm sure no one will have an issue with this".

I agree that they probably should have told you a bit earlier, but I don't think it's too crazy to think that they probably just thought it wasn't a big deal so didn't think it was particularly important to tell you early

1