CloudRouter Switch - not working well on routing?

I have a few mikrotik devices, including a Cloud Router Switch I can dual boot.

However, when I boot it into RouterOS, it seems that when doing any significant routing at all, it locks up the CPU, crashes, and then comes back. Its perfect in swos.

Granted, I'm not super familiar with it yet, so it's possible I'm misconfiguring something. This, however, has occured on several devices.

Am I doing something dumb, or is it a well known secret that mikrotik CRSes don't work well for routing, and they're better switches?

Posted Nov 29, 2019, 1:41 PM UTC

04
djgizmoMTCNA, MTCRE•

CRS Routing is done in software, which is usually a single core low end cpu.

What isn’t working for you? Can you throw us a bone and give us some information, like model and tests?

1
scohesc•

Sort of a misleading name - the CloudRouterSwitch line act more as "Layer 3 Smart Switches" in that their primary job is switching traffic Layer 2 (CRS has hardware switching chips inside) while providing most/all of the functionality of Routing Layer 3 Traffic, which would be done on an underpowered CPU depending on what Layer3 features you're wanting to throw at it.

I have a CRS (unsure of model, one with 8 gigabit ports and 2.4 Wifi AP) and I fell into the pitfall you did where "it has router in teh name, it must be good at routing!" My CRS starts to get high CPU usage with at least 10-15 firewall rules, and with various NAT and Mangle rules on top of that it starts to get dropped packets, etc. etc. (granted I'm not sure it's configured 100% correctly, but the CPU is pretty weak on the CRS line of products anyways).

1
zib123•

I complained at them on twitter and got the answer "well it's a switch". They are really dumb in naming their products. Calling it Cloud Router Switch just because it can run RouterOS because route traffic faster than a turtle it can not :D

1
scohesc•

Yeah, it's definitely kind of odd how they named it - makes you think it's a router with switching as an afterthought.

1