Moved to a different city and have a house - to rent or to sell?

Investing

This year we moved to a different city an hour away. We have two properties in our old city, both are currently being rented out. House A is fully paid for, House B is 3 years old and has a mortgage. We have good tenants for both.

Next year we would like to buy a house in our new city and we’re trying to figure out if it’s worthwhile to keep House B since it’s technically not making us any money (the rent is exactly the same amount as our monthly mortgage) and probably won’t be for a couple of years. I understand that having property is a good investment but managing it and the outstanding mortgage has some stress attached.

We’re currently deliberating if we should sell or not - what would be considerations or things we should be thinking about as we go through this process?

Posted Nov 30, 2019, 9:20 PM UTC

03
Cynorax​•

If you really don't want to have to look after it approach a property management company. They usually charge 10-15% but then you never have to worry about collecting rent maintenance etc and they usually guarantee rent even when there's no tenant whilst they look for a new one.

I'd definitely keep both, especially until the second mortgage is paid off, then you can either keep them as a really good extra monthly income source or sell them both to get a baller house/yacht/holiday whatever.

1
LegoKenBurns​•

If you can manage both properties from a distance and still have a positive cash flow, collectively. Then why not. Your hedging in the properies gaining value for a later sale or refinance.

1
Stimperonovitch​•

When my husband and I got married, we each had a house and we sold both so we could buy one together. His house sold first, and I had mine until about six months down the road before it sold. I hadn't planned to rent it because I had done extensive remodeling and didn't want it to be trashed. A girl I worked with asked me if I would reconsider and rent it to her. She said she was very clean and would take perfect care of it. It was winter and I agreed to let her rent it at a very reasonable rate so I wouldn't have to pay the gas and electric bills. She had been traveling 50 miles to work every day, a 100-mile round trip and she had a baby. Big mistake on my part. When she moved out, she took stuff that wasn't hers and even took all the light bulbs and toilet paper. I doubt she ever cleaned the toilet. She really marred the woodwork, which I had just redone. She had a fire on the stove that went up the wall and onto the ceiling and never told me. She never cleaned the snow from the driveway, just drove over it which created a huge icy berm. Personally, I would never rent a property that was mine again. If you know you have good renters, that's different. I admit I was a sucker because I never inspected the house when she was there. I was lucky it sold given the condition.

0