[Consumer] Item not as described, stuck with vouchers

Consumer

Hello LegalAdvice community,

Thanks for providing such useful help online, legal cases can be really hard to understand.

I recently used my employer's benefits to obtain £1700 in Currys vouchers, as I intended to buy a high-end laptop advertised online. I discovered after I received the laptop that there was an issue with the ad :

  1. The laptop that they are selling me is not the high-end, but the mid range model of the same series.
  2. The title of the ad says "Pro" series - which is misleading as only the high end are named with the "Pro" label
  3. The picture on the ad is a picture of the High end model. They look similar but the proportions and key layout is slightly different.
  4. The tech specs page do however describe the mid-range item, as it should.

Although this was probably only a mistake on their website, I fell into it and realised too late that this was not the high-end model. I have got the item returned and what they propose me is :

  • Re-send me a new laptop, same as I received (mid-range)
  • Refund me for the item ... except this is only possible in Currys vouchers.

I appreciate that there are tight anti-laundering laws and that I can't get a cash refund. But since this was caused by an error in their online catalogue, I feel like I a getting screwed and they don't want to take the blame. From my point of view I see that :

  • I saw a (misleading) ad that interested me
  • I obtained vouchers that Currys provides to my employer
  • I realised that this is not the item advertised
  • I am stuck with 1700 in Currys vouchers.

After reading some legal websites like this : https://www.slatergordon.co.uk/consumer-law/consumer-law-for-shoppers-rights/ It seems like they are only obliged to reimburse me in vouchers, that's all. Is there anyway I can get something more useful than vouchers ?

I tried to ask them for a bit of help in buying the higher-end model, or to give me some sort of reparation package, but they did not think they had any obligation to. What do you think ?

Thanks

Posted Dec 6, 2019, 6:38 PM UTC

77
Afinkawan•

they did not think they had any obligation to

They're correct. They refunded you so you've been made whole.

9
_Ulan_OP•

Makes sense, thanks : )

1
FabergeEogg•

Unfortunately, you don't really have a legal standpoint here. They've fulfilled their part of the Consumer Rights Act (2015) by offering to refund you in the same method you paid. Your only option would be to escalate through customer services and hope they will offer a goodwill solution of the premium laptop. I'd push a little harder with customer services, but know you're not in a strong position. Could you take the laptop and sell it on eBay for cash? Will probably end up being a loss for you, but at least you'll have the cash.

Alternatively, you could contact Advertising Standards about the advert being misleading, but this is unlikely to sort out your issue with the vouchers.

2
ThatBurningDog•

Alternatively, you could contact Advertising Standards about the advert being misleading, but this is unlikely to sort out your issue with the vouchers.

I used to work for PC World (when them and Currys were separate brands under the Dixon Group banner) and they were regularly given a slap on the wrist for pulling stuff like this. The problem with the ASA is that it is literally all they can do - they have very little to no legal clout to prevent companies putting out misleading adverts. Dixon Stores Group know this, and they'll be doing the same thing in a few months with another promotion. Like you say, unlikely to help OP besides making them feel like they've done something about it?

2
_Ulan_OP•

Noted, thank you very much for the help

0
AutoModeratorMOD•

###Welcome to r/LegalAdviceUK

To Posters (it is important you read this section)

To Readers and Commenters

  • All replies to OP must be on-topic, helpful, and legally orientated;

  • It is your duty to read and follow the rules before and while participating in the subreddit;

  • If you do not follow the rules, you could be banned without any further warning;

  • Do not advise OPs to tell people to "f*ck off" or advise them to "go to the media";

  • Do not offer to PM OPs;

  • Please include links to reliable resources in order to support your comments or advice;

  • If you feel any replies are incorrect, explain why you believe they are incorrect;

  • Report posts or comments which do not follow the rules

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
CNash85•

Your problem is that you bought Currys vouchers as a separate transaction to the laptop purchase. Currys don't care that your intention was only to use them to buy a laptop; they've refunded you to the payment method that you used, and as far as they're concerned you have been "made whole".

1