r/whiskey•
pulliamjs

Whiskey Advocate snubs BT again

I think I know most of the Buffalo Trace product line. I don't see any of them mentioned yet again here: http://whiskyadvocate.com/top20/

Wondering if there's a back story here? I subscribe to WA and do see BT ads in the magazine. So it's not like they're not paying WA.

Posted Dec 6, 2019, 10:54 PM UTC

214
carlovmon•

BT fans seem to be a very passionate bunch in my experience lol

6

W.A. states pretty clearly that availability is one of their major criteria for making this yearly Top 20 list. It isn't a list of best new whiskies, or even best new whiskies you can afford if you can find them. It is, at least in theory, a list of the new best whiskies which you can both find and afford, in most markets.

I don't think it is unreasonable to conclude that under current conditions this automatically disqualifies a large swath of Sazerac's lineup.

Now whether some of the stuff they picked should be equally disqualified (I've probably seen less than 1/4 [correction: more like 1/3] of the bottles on their 2019 list show up in my area) is a different conversation.

3
Silent-Quail•

Which is funny because I can’t find any of the top 15 around me easily In a city of 4million +

2

My market tends to lag behind the rest of the country by 6 months, so I'm in [shrug] mode, but that W.A. list has been more of a curiosity to me than a serious guide to purchasing for several years now.

2019's list does seem more oddball than previous years though, and I've had conversations with retail store spirits dept managers who've had the same reaction.

1
Silent-Quail•

Yah seemed oddball to me as well. I guess that might be what they were going for because my initial reaction was wow I haven’t heard of a lot of these

I guess it’s good because you could just put Lagavulin 16 on there every year but that would get old

2

I don't have a problem with it being a list of available & affordable whiskies. That is IMHO a laudable exercise and not fundamentally different from much of the conversation here on the reddit subs. The qualifier new is crucial to their list however, and while I get that it would be boring to just keep listing the same stuff, it does has a distorting effect on what makes the list and what doesn't.

That this year's list seems even more odd than usual is I think an accurate symptom of the state of the industry lately, in which fragmentation of product lines seems to have taken hold, turning everything into a special edition. I remarked on another thread wherein we were discussing this W.A. list that the whisky industry, having gone thru a Baroque period for several years, now seems to be heading into a full blown Mannerist phase, with a side helping of Japonisme.

Although I'm kind of liking New Riff, as a Neoclassical Revival in this metaphor.

1
axmantim•

Or Buffalo trace just isn't good enough for the top 20.

1†
saltedfish•

This. Why does there need to be a conspiracy? There's probably thousands of whiskey brands.

3
WhiskyDingo87•

The alternative is reading Jim Murray's top picks of the year, which are bottles you will never see in person. I think it's his "whiskey bible" or some shit.

1
UncleBaldric•

Lots of people found Crown Royal Northern Harvest Rye after the 2016 Whisky Bible came out... (and then wished they hadn't?).

3
BarneyFife516•

I first picked up 1792 during my drives through the “ hollers” in Kentucky/Tennessee, as I make a drive through that part of the USA a couple of times each year. I like making a few stops at the off main highway stores to inquire about what the locals are drinking. Three years ago I was in a little shop and I clearly recall the person telling me that 1792 was moving pretty good- so I picked up a couple. Last year I stopped by the Party Source in Florence, Kentucky for a walk through. The store had purchased a a Barrel of 1792 Full Proof- just verified I’ve got two in the locker. In my opinion, 1792 is good, however it’s not great. To me it’s a bit ethanol forward.

1
BabyHuey206•

What BT products do you think really need to be up there? Have they released anything recently that's both good and widely available?

1
WearableBliss•

I would have said it seems like a random list but if they restrict it to bottles with a certain number, like 100k bottles or whatever, fair enough.

1