mikedehaan•

As the 9th paragraphs says: overall the system does not violate thermodynamics, since the scientists are pumping energy into the electric field, etc.

3
Cordite•

Thank you!

As soon as I heard the bit about a demon allowing only certain speeds of atoms to pass I thought: Okay and that decision/action requires energy... So?

The whole experiment is pointless because there is no such thing possible as described by the thought experiment... Energy must always be consumed somewhere, and therefore there is still balance. The object in this case is being manipulated by voltage, resistance, and kinetic forces.

This is like claiming magic was involved 25% of the time because it was less resistance to go a certain way after being moved. What a crock.

0
Cthonic•

Well, to be fair the experiment has applications in nanomotors according to the researchers. They're fully aware of how impossible toe actual scenario is, they're merely testing related principles.

1
creativesquid•

"Life" is already a real life maxwells demon.

2
Cordite•

I fail to see what you mean, care to elaborate? :)

1
TwopackShaker•

I guess I'm not fully understanding this article, but it seemed complete irrelevant.

I think what they're TRYING to convey is that energy can be converted into "information" and vice versa. And this occurs via the statistical nature of entropy. Basically the more probable the configuration the more entropy a system has... the more "disorder." However, information theory dictates that the more probable an event is, the less information is required to produce it. In that sense, the less entropy an event has the more information is needed to specify that configuration. So in a sense, due to Gibb's free energy equation:

dG = dH - T*dS

A system with 0 total free energy change (an isolated system in equilibrium) equates to dH = T*dS, implying that and increase in the information content would serve to decrease the enthalpy of the system (i.e. as Information increases, dH becomes more negative).

Eh? Maybe that was the gist of it... but I still don't quite see how the experiment is relevant.

Edit: But then again, Maxwell's Demon actually completely violates this in every way.

2
Titanomachy•

Thought you might like this: a much more literal version of Maxwell's Demon.

1