A quiet space in a university building ---???
Posted Dec 8, 2019, 2:40 PM UTC
09
That's a 3* shrug submission.
3
From my submissions for my university this is apparently a "School (K-12)". So easy 1*.
No but seriously those are horrible reviewers and it sucks we're seemingly stuck with them here since PoGo got access... As for this submission I would personally reject because a quiet room does not seem to meet any criteria I know of. The wall art/flags might meet criteria but the nomination should then be about them not the room they're in.
2
Here's more info (my first post here - uncertain of posting format).
Overall, the submission has issues since it doesn't ID the building - don't really know it's on campus nor if it's offices, classrooms, or dorms.
First question - if it was a good write up - does a room in a building qualify?
Next, if yes - What Type Is It? (Appears to to be a very large campus building so 'Building' category seems wrong.
Thanks
Eta. (It is described as being a quiet space for meditating and being awed by all the names on the wall - very bad write up - rejecting it based on that.)
0
Interior waypoints are permitted although they are more difficult to get accepted. The primary issue is verifying its eligibility.
Interior locations benefit from a series of photospheres that start outside the building, and go inside toward the nominated POI. Linked photospheres make it easier for reviewers (link them together under profile tab in street view, make sure all the photospheres share the same location name).
What is it being submitted? The flags fail to have sufficient permanence to be eligible. The room might be eligible with a sign, but it would need to meet eligibility criteria.
3
Overall, the submission has issues since it doesn't ID the building - don't really know it's on campus nor if it's offices, classrooms, or dorms.
You can see the exact spot on Google Maps where the pin is placed. It should be very apparent if something is in a building that is on a university campus.
0
No, its a school
-14
Colleges and universities are not included in that rule.
7
Universities and colleges are differentiated from K-12 schools.
4
If they had submitted their wall art as a mural, maybe.... but otherwise to me it is a room with flags in. They would need to say why the flags were significant, what they were actually there for. A contemplation room is kind of generic and any room could be called a contemplation room.