Addressing flood of homework posts @mods

Too many students are asking for help on their essays. Which I don’t mind, but they are ignoring the rules.

To make sure that they know what this sub is about, I think we need a bot that auto comments the post the rules, and that the OP has to edit their post or have it ignored, maybe deleted.

Posted Dec 11, 2019, 1:52 PM UTC

185
dmorinMODShakespeare Geek•

While I'll admit that I haven't been around as much as I've been in the past (what with the holidays and some other stuff going on), I do try to check the queue and this morning I saw only one reported post, which I removed. Prior to that I see a few from weeks ago, which were left up because of the conversation they generated.

If you like, feel free to flag me directly when identifying a post you believe to be breaking the rules -- I do check reddit regularly so I will see notifications immediately, while to see the reported posts I have to deliberately go into the mod queue.

As noted in the past, though, every homework question is not breaking the rules. If somebody sticks around an engages in the conversation, we usually let it slide. Sometimes it generates some very good conversation. Usually it takes a little while to let that develop and see if OP comes back to interact or just dropped a question and left.

6
zieglerisinnocent•

In the last six months or so I have seen far, far fewer homework posts, and the posts that have appeared (and hung around) have been of a higher effort, and sparked some good chat. Of course one or two have hung around before mods got to them, but on the whole they’re greatly diminished. I don’t think we need a bot or similar.

11
lvl99luckOP•

My main concern is that the students don’t show what work they have. Rule one asks that the OP lead the discussion with more than just asking their question.

I believe that a bot would remind OPs to add more to spur the discussion would benefit the OPs as it would make the post more interesting to subs of this subreddit.

1
belladonnatook•

Is there a separate set of rules other than what I'm seeing in the sidebar? What I see shows one rule: "1. Show Your Work." (Maybe I'm on an old version or something?)

Also, the wording of that rule apropos of homework essays says: "we're just not all that keen on being taken advantage of". How is it being taken advantage of to choose to answer a kid's question or not? I can't be taken advantage of without my consent, and neither can anyone else. If you don't want to engage with the kid, ignore or, dare I say, downvote the post.

My rationale for erring in favor of generosity is that kids don't have it easy in school these days (if they/we ever did). If I can help one kid a little on the fraction of her homework that deals with Shakespeare, I am so happy to do it.

As a teacher and regular on homeworkhelp, imho the format is a mess over there and the page is a thicket. I don't blame the few homeworkhelp-seekers over there coming here, when they have a Shakespeare question. There's a much better chance their question will be seen by a kindred spirit here.

My $0.02.

3

From the sidebar:

We Won't Do Your Homework

As large of an issue it is for students to understand their Shakespeare assignments, please refrain from expecting us to do your homework for you.

If you're looking for help, please include your own work thus far in the question. "Can somebody help make this essay on Hamlet stronger?" gets a better response than, "I have to write an essay on Hamlet can somebody tell me what to write about?"

1