Next income property

I bought my first rental property nearly two years ago. Bought a single family home (3bd/2bath) close to a university. We got a killer deal at $79k. With 20% down our mortgage is under $500/month and I’m currently getting $1100/rent. It’s never gone a month without occupancy and the home needed minor cosmetic repairs when we bought, which we’ve knocked out over time.

My question... I’m ready to make purchase number two, and have enough cash in hand from the rental income + savings from our 9-5s to put 20 down on anything up to 230k and still have a safety net.

I’m torn between purchasing a multi-family home or another single family home.

Ultimate goal is to have 5 properties before I turn 37 (5 more years)

Thoughts? Anyone have crazy issues with tenants in duplexes hating each other and causing problems? (My wife’s fear)

Posted Dec 12, 2019, 2:52 PM UTC

16
Studentloanclock•

My guy, buy another property like the one you mentioned. If those numbers are legit, those type of deals are my dream lol If I can ask, what university are they close to? I also own a home at my alumni university that I rent to College students.

2
fullparttimeOP•

The numbers are legit and will prove them if anyone doubts me. Southeastern university in Louisiana.

1
DPDTV•

I have a split level duplex which I rent out.

I rent out for a bit under market rates so that I can be picky and choose tenants who I know won't cause noise problems for each other and won't be problematic. I've gotten pretty good at playing this and the tenants I pick tend to become friendly and spend time with each other.

I definitely do have to play therapist from time to time though.

2
kushhcommander•

This is a good point. Charging the most, depending on property quality, will get you top paying tenants but possibly not the best tenants. I dropped the rent price to a competitive, yet fair, montly price and it seems to be working quite well since I'm getting more applicants. I have a 6/4 SFH and all 4 tenants get along super well.

1
beaushaw•

Run the numbers on another single and on a multi. Buy the better one.

1
fullparttimeOP•

Yeah for sure. Just looking at other issues that may be prevalent in duplexes that aren’t in SFHs that numbers won’t tell. Thanks

1