Those of you who've dealt with an academic hearing, any tips?
So I've been implicated in a case of academic integrity over 17 lines of essentially identical code for a CS assignment. The other student being implicated and I do know each other, but both of us were completely unaware that our code for the assignment was the same (indeed, before we showed up to the meeting we speculated that it was us finishing our final exams early because we couldn't come up with any other reason).
Here are a couple of important notes:
-The professor provided us with a couple of methods we were to use in the assignment. (And a bunch of sample code as well, but that wasn't very useful.)
-Before the deadline of the assignment, me, the other implicated student, and a third student met for a regularly scheduled study session. In this study session, I did not at any point reveal my source code to him, but I did do the following:
-
I helped him with getting the required library for the assignment installed because he couldn't find the right version for it.
-
We went over the details of the assignment and the lecture slides related to it together, and collaboratively made a plan for the structure of the program.
-
He asked me how some of the methods in the library worked, and I explained them to him.
EDIT
-The bits of the identical code not related to the library are essentially boilerplate. Some of them are good coding habits we learned about together (like using with open(file) so that you don't forget to close the file) or very basic stuff (like getting a random sample of x numbers from a range of 0 to y, or reading lines from a file and using split to turn them into a (nested) list of words).
EDIT END
During the hearing I would like to bring up the following points:
-This case only happened because we were unaware of the content of each other's code, and consequently we were also unaware of the fact that they were identical.
-I am currently a scholarship recipient, with a spotless record throughout the three semesters I have attended this university. I have nothing to gain from allowing someone else to see and copy my source code.
And so, r/sbu, I'd like to ask for your sage advice. Do I even have any glimmer of a chance at getting the decision repealed? Is there anything you can share to help hopefully increase the chances?
Posted Dec 13, 2019, 6:33 AM UTC · edited
I haven’t been in a hearing before, but your case sounds very difficult to prove. My best thought is: do you guys use anything like git where you could maybe show the progress of your codes in development? In the end If you can’t come up with anything your best bet is probably to tell them exactly what you’ve told us. Maybe you can have that person 3 from the meeting come to talk about it as well?
Also if it’s coding, how is it that you guys had the exact same variable names and everything lol
Unfortunately not- I only use Github for code that I actively need to put on public display, and the other student doesn't use it at all.
Yeah, he's coming as a witness, as well as someone else who worked closely with administration that can vouch for us.
The variable names aren't the same, obviously, but as mentioned we came up with the structure of the code together for basically every assignment we had (It's because of this structure that we used the same nested for loops, as an example). We used the same methods in our code due to a combination of two factors: 1. They were methods from the lecture slides, and 2. The order of the methods used was a logical progression- e.g. rx.Observable.create(data).reduce(lambda x, y: x + len(y), 0).to_blocking(). You create the iterable, run reduce through it and then convert it to a different type, in order to output a sum of the lengths of all the elements in the iterable (This is RxPY, by the way).
I’m not a comp sci student and don’t know python so some of that sounded like mumbo jumbo to me but the details aren’t important.
Your reasoning sounds plausible, especially since the methods were from the lecture slide. As far as I’ve known you’re allowed to discuss the method of doing a problem, so long as you’re not talking line by line math/code. I’d just be honest and straight forward, it seems believable
Thanks for the feedback. I just hope that they actually listen- the professor's already pretty set in his opinion (given that he didn't really give us any room to talk during the preliminary meeting with him), and the panel is composed of 5 student affairs officials so I expect them to be pretty biased already, given that they're the ones who handle cases like these in the first place.