The conflation of veganism and health, the OG of strawmen

I'll begin by saying that health was originally what lead me to veganism, but not in the Raw Alignment or Tim Shieff kind of health journey. I'll also disclaimer that I knew little to no information on any aspect of health, besides carbs being food for energy (always talked about carb loading in my athletic team), and calories in/calories out.

I didn't even know what veganism really was until I met the two vegan friends that passively persuaded me to go vegan. But looking back I had a lot of cognitive dissonance so the ethical appeal was always there, I just didn't even know that it was possible. I knew very few vegetarians and even scoffed at the idea myself, using BBQ, an appeal to sensory pleasure, as a justification even though I knew it was fucked up how we treated animals. I was definitely one of those grassy pasture utopia ideologists even though I half-assed my own vegetarian stint with restaurant sourced animal products. I even went as far as to resists veganism and claim that abstaining from transportation and other modern capitalist luxuries was a more noteworthy thing to do. So when I accidentally stumbled upon the WFPB community on youtube, and was easily able to understand the language and topics discussed, I had this question answered for me when I didn't even know I asked it:

If we can not only manage but reverse the damage caused by modern western lifestyle with a plant based diet, and also live a long and healthy life on a plant based diet, isn't it our responsibility as the only advanced species to exist in the universe to CHOOSE to not cause suffering and death?

How I got to this question and it's answer was from these facts:

  • Dean Ornish has made the most significant reversal of cardiovascular damage by a diet that contains no animal protein and minimal saturated fat(some derived from animal products). There isn't a single study conducted to try and create the same results with the inclusion of any kind animal proteins.
  • David Katz has conducted some of the best nutritional research that exists in medical literature, has all the profits from his books go to help communities, he chooses not to eat animals because the results of his work show no evidence that we are required to eat animals.
  • The keto and paleo movements have no honorable accomplishments to speak of. Grassy pasture utopias won't feed the world population even if we were required to get certain nutrients from animals.
  • A marginal cases for supplements could easily be used to argue in favor of the vegan and health positions.

So ex vegans claim they were on a vegan diet, not a WFPB diet because only the former is true. The mainstream can't help but use the vegan word non stop because it's catchy and still technically correct, and can be used to produce negative results. Starving yourself could definitely be vegan. Eating raw foods and expecting to overcome the law of thermodynamics could certainly be vegan. But none of that is what WFPB doctors recommend, and what they recommend isn't even always vegan(The fiasco with Jaden Smith). The Game Changers doc never mentioned the word, yet we hear non stop about how the gladiators weren't vegan. No shit lol. This obvious strawman is in place to avoid the actual difficult questions:

  • why would someone choose to support the systematic killing of animals for no good reason?
  • Why would someone who has witnessed crimes against humanity be in the wrong for make the comparison between humanity's treatment of eachother, and our treatment of lesser animals?

Posted Dec 13, 2019, 9:41 PM UTC · edited

2328
Creditfigarovegan•

As That Vegan Couple likes to point out, people believe that eating animal products is "natural, normal, and necessary".

The trick is, if vegan diets truly are unhealthy, then they aren't entirely practicable.

That's why the health argument is so important.

Once the health argument is established in the mind of someone, the necessity of animal exploitation evaporates, and you are stuck dealing with the ethical argument, which is bulletproof.

That was my experience, and the experience of many many others. That's why the hard work that went into the game changers was so important.

7
cXTNeynOPveganarchist•

you are stuck dealing with the ethical argument, which is bulletproof

Bingo. It forces the burden of proof onto the opposition.

2
deten•

I find it very difficult to determine what is true.

For example, all meat eaters (and vegans) are not the same. If you take "all meat eaters" and compare them to "all vegans", you might find that the vegans tend to be healthier.

However, the reasons might be very diverse. Just like Theists vs Atheists, atheists tend to be smarter but that isnt necessarily because becoming an atheist makes you smarter, but smarter people have a higher chance of becoming atheists. Just the same, vegans might already eat healthy even if they had a omnivorous diet vs following a vegan diet.

Not only that but diet, exercise, lifestyle, income, etc all play huge roles in health.

We also have this issue with healthcare. When we look at the lifespans of people in europe, they have a longer lifespan. However, the US is brought down by poor people who are not covered by health insurance. So we have a huge weight of people pulling us down. When you look at the middle class people, they actually live really long and as long as europe. The problem in the US is distribution not plenty.

Finally, theres studies that are being conducted, showing that all sorts of diets are very healthy. I can find studies showing Keto being health, but I am not keto because as I said, I dont trust that completely, but none the less, we have multiple scientific studies showing different things and leaving people overwhelmed with WHAT is true.

In these scenarious I think the safeist thing to do for health is to mimick the diets of our ancesters. Lots of vegetables, little sugar, and little meat.

The good news is that the advent of lab grown meat might alleviate the issue soon as we will be able to get essentially a "morally clear" version of meat in the not too distant future.

4
cXTNeynOPveganarchist•

I find it very difficult to determine what is true.

If we can calculate and figure out that we all came from the Big Bang, why do you believe that we cant figure out what is healthy for us?

"all meat eaters" and compare them to "all vegans...Just like Theists vs Atheists

Do you believe that this is an equal comparison though? This is diving into the conflation that veganism IS a WFPB when the actual argument is that they only overlap to a certain extent. People can choose to be vegan, people can't choose that TMAO and lack of fiber has serious long term health consequences.

showing that all sorts of diets are very healthy.

Do they show a reversal of CV disease in the long term? Has it cured people's T2D and lead people to become amateur athletes? Can you post them so we can compare and see if the results are indeed the same like you claim?

I can find studies showing Keto being health,

Let's see it. I bet you can't.

leaving people overwhelmed with WHAT is true.

The way people feel doesn't correlate with truth. Idk why you are bringing this up to try and bring down the topic. Being neutral when the truth clearly isn't neutral means you have a neutrality bias. Arguing from the perspective of CNN is hardly notable.

The good news is that the advent of lab grown meat might alleviate the issue

How exactly do you think that lab grown protein will have micronutrients and minerals that typically come from the plants that the animal ate? We will essentially be feeding plants to petri dishes instead of animals, and once again have the issue of something being a middle man for our nutrient intake. There won't be anything moral about buying expensive as fuck food that requires tremendous energy input to grow.

1
deten•

Idk why you are bringing this up to try and bring down the topic.

If your first assumption is I am being dishonest or malicious, then we wont be able to talk about this.

If your open to having a discussion then feel free to proceed!

If we can calculate and figure out that we all came from the Big Bang, why do you believe that we cant figure out what is healthy for us?

To put us on the same page, let me start with the first thing you say. I think in this scenario were conflating two things:

Just because something is possible to be known doesn't mean we have achieved it yet.

So I would agree that we can figure out, but I havent been convinced yet that we have done so.

With that out of the way, maybe I can ask a few questions from you? I am not trying to paint you into a corner, but how can we talk about it without knowing where each other stands?

Am I right in assuming that you believe veganism is healthier than being an omnivore? What would you say is the single most convincing point as to why you believe veganism is healthier than being an omnivore?

1
SoyBoy14800•

David Katz has conducted some of the best nutritional research that exists in medical literature, has all the profits from his books go to help communities, he chooses not to eat animals because the results of his work show no evidence that we are required to eat animals.

Have you read any of his books? If so which would you recommend? I'd love to read some of his work since I haven't heard of him before.

Dean Ornish has made the most significant reversal of cardiovascular damage by a diet that contains no animal protein and minimal saturated fat(some derived from animal products). There isn't a single study conducted to try and create the same results with the inclusion of any kind animal proteins.

I recommend you read Dr. Caldwell Esselstyn's work, his results are even more impressive, but the study populations are unfortunately lower. Here is the study if you're interested.

3
fudge_mokey•

Here is the study if you're interested.

https://dresselstyn.com/JFP_06307_Article1.pdf

Have you seen this one?

2
SoyBoy14800•

I have actually! A person linked it to me when I asked for criticisms of a WFPB diet on r/nutrition. You should read what they pointed out which was interesting if you have the time, my post is still up. Essentially they pointed out that the women in control group actually had regression too, without dietary intervention which was very interesting to me. It showed how important lifestyle factors are aswel.

2
cXTNeynOPveganarchist•

The Truth About Food by David Katz is quite the read.. I'm only 100 pages in. Also look at his speeches on youtube. I actually avoided referencing Esselstyn because he is indeed vegan and these two docs weren't at the time of their medical work.

2
SoyBoy14800•

I didn't know Esselstyn was vegan! TIL.

I'll also add the truth to my reading list, cheers.

1
ShadowStarshinenon-vegan•

why would someone choose to support the systematic killing of animals for no good reason?

The only thing that would make this a "difficult" question is that it is loaded. You've added "no good reason" as part of the question which makes it so anything I answer with is automatically not a good reason. Perhaps try asking a more neutral question.

why would someone choose to support the systematic killing of animals?

Because I don't see anything wrong with it.

Why would someone who has witnessed crimes against humanity be in the wrong for make the comparison between humanity's treatment of each other, and our treatment of lesser animals?

This is a confusing question, someone who hasn't witnessed crimes against humanity could also make comparisons. You can make the comparison, it doesn't mean I'll agree with it.

Btw, this particular point:

Grassy pasture utopias won't feed the world population even if we were required to get certain nutrients from animals.

I've always thought very odd. Is this assuming that people ONLY eat meat? If not, and there is no stated quantity, then it seems like a meaningless statement. Could grassy pastures feed everyone once a month with beef? Yes. Like, put a number on it so I know what you're saying.

3
cXTNeynOPveganarchist•

I guess it would be my assertion that there's no good reason to do it, with health being the only reason I consider good (up for debate obv). Being unhealthy isn't good, and if veganism could ONLY be unhealthy, then this could be a load question for sure. But ther's more pros to going vegan than not.

I don't see anything wrong with it.

It's needless. I already told explained it. If it's not needless, it's up to you to explain why you don't see it as such. Would you honestly respond with that answer to any other moral question that involves animals being being systematically killed?

someone who hasn't witnessed crimes against humanity could also make comparisons.

Yeah but this point is to specifically answer the question of why Jews are not allowed or are frowned up from making the holocaust comparison, and the flack that vegans get for referencing that analogy. Someone who hasn't witnessed something isn't as credible of a source. That's the point I'm getting at.

Is this assuming that people ONLY eat meat?

It's assuming the laws of conservation of energy and the trophic levels of energy. THere's a ton of research supporting a plant based diet using the least amount of resources to feed X people.

Could grassy pastures feed everyone once a month with beef?

They could without a doubt. There's even a study that suggests a vegetarian/minimal omni diet produces the most calories/acre. So they could be a supplement to the diet. But the obv question is why are we relying on a less efficient manner to feed ourselves? It's not as healthy, so the quality of calories/acre goes down. In certain situations that kind of inefficiency in a system is unacceptable. I'm no environmental major so this isn't my forte, but I can link you material and some personal analyses I've made.

1
ShadowStarshinenon-vegan•

I guess it would be my assertion that there's no good reason to do it, with health being the only reason I consider good (up for debate obv).

It's enjoyable, I think that's hardly disputable to most people. It's one thing to come and make an argument and say you think the bad reasons outweigh the good reasons, it'd be another thing to try and convince people there are no good reasons.

You may come and say "Things tasting good doesn't outweigh 1) Moral argument X 2) Health argument Y 3) Environmental argument Z."

Now, if someone isn't convinced by 1, 2 and 3, and is only left with one reason because it tastes good, then that seems convincing enough.

It's needless. I already told explained it. If it's not needless, it's up to you to explain why you don't see it as such.

Well one clarification, and then a counter argument:

  1. Clarification: Needless to what ends? Survival? To enjoying a steak? I'm going to assume you mean "It's needless for survival." If I have that wrong, please clarify.

  2. Counter-Argument: "Needless for survival" isn't a reason to stop doing something. Most things in life I do aren't needed for survival. That, as a sole criterion, is not good enough to make me stop doing them. I need to be convinced of reasons to stop.

Would you honestly respond with that answer to any other moral question that involves animals being being systematically killed?

This is what I'm telling you. I don't see why it's wrong to kill animals for food. I'm unconvinced of any moral argument.

Yeah but this point is to specifically answer the question of why Jews are not allowed or are frowned up from making the holocaust comparison, and the flack that vegans get for referencing that analogy. Someone who hasn't witnessed something isn't as credible of a source. That's the point I'm getting at.

I've been around vegan debates (online) for a long time, I've never seen anyone do this. But okay, I don't see a reason to contest this.

They could without a doubt.

Okay, I'm glad we agree there are non-0 amounts that would be capable of feeding everyone.

But the obv question is why are we relying on a less efficient manner to feed ourselves?

Because efficiency isn't the sole criterion for food production. Even if the world was vegan, would you be against less efficient vegan options, or should we get down to, say, perhaps 5-6 food items that we only produce because they happen to get each nutrient and are of max efficiency? Or, would you actually prefer vegan options that may be less efficient so that you have variety?

It's not as healthy

I'm not convinced of this point myself. It could be true. But even if it was, people can make their own choices imo.

2
cXTNeynOPveganarchist•

It's enjoyable

Enjoyable doesn't necessarily mean good though. It can be placed under the good category, but to flip that order would be a little absurd no?

it'd be another thing to try and convince people there are no good reasons.

One tick under the good reasons would hardly make something objectively good. Again, in almost any other context this ideology could produce even greater suffering. That's what I'm trying to avoid and that's why I believe veganism is on the right path.

I need to be convinced of reasons to stop.

Not only does it absolutely create suffering, it's very likely to be unhealthy for you. And yes you are under no obligation to do what is best for you, but do you honestly believe that this type of mentality: creating systematic suffering for marginally good reasons, could in any way be looked as moral from any more progressive and advanced society? The problem is you are seeking the answer from your surroundings, when the answer can only come from you. Once again, this answer/line of logic WOULD NOT be acceptable in other common social situations and could lead to greater suffering.

I don't see why it's wrong to kill

See when I take you out of context, you sound worrying. Do that with my line of logic and lets compare results.

I 've never seen anyone do this.

If you drop that analogy on the discord servers you would get wrecked by even some vegans. It's even controversial here. It's VERY controversial in the omni community.

Because efficiency isn't the sole criterion for food production... would you actually prefer vegan options that may be less efficient so that you have variety?

I would say a bit of both, but depending on how our environment's condition is. Right now I am trying to eat more peasant food even though I could afford more. It's lower impact, a lot of it I can still source locally, and I definitely would say I have taken "a hit" on the "pleasure" scale but not by much. But I also have opportunity to make the choice, which I believe is a crucial part of being truly tolerant towards the entire community. If you can't trust someone to make a good choice, then we might as well not even have a society. Even predators can drink side by side with their prey at the water hole during a drought.

I'm not convinced of this point myself

I guess this is my problem in these debates. You can so easily brush off tremendous suffering with basic sophistry of "I'm not convinced". You would accept that attitude in a debate about the shape of the planet? About the existance of gravity? About the relationship between the Earth and our moon? If you do choose to use that reasoning, the only reasonable thing to do is provide the data that gives you doubt or which you think is convincing of the opposite. My two questions would be:

  • What about David Katz's and Dean Ornish's work isn't convincing to you?

  • What would convince you of this being the case [plant based diet is healthier]?

1
ShadowStarshinenon-vegan•

Enjoyable doesn't necessarily mean good though. It can be placed under the good category, but to flip that order would be a little absurd no?

I don't know what you're actually saying here. Can you reword this?

One tick under the good reasons would hardly make something objectively good. Again, in almost any other context this ideology could produce even greater suffering. That's what I'm trying to avoid and that's why I believe veganism is on the right path.

I wasn't making that claim. I'm not sure if it's because you took so long to reply, but here's how this particular back and forth:

You: There is no good reason to eat meat. Me: It's enjoyable is 1 good reason to eat meat. You: It is not objectively good.

Do you notice how what you're saying doesn't actually address what I just said? I didn't say it was objectively good. I didn't say 1 good thing means we should do it. I said there was 1 good reason to eat meat, and I further explained about how we would weigh that against reasons to not do it. Please, if you're gonna respond to me, keep track.

Not only does it absolutely create suffering, it's very likely to be unhealthy for you.

I do not agree that eating meat entails suffering. It entails life-ending. Unless, for you, life-ending always means suffering, in that case, it is the only suffering required, and it's fine by me when it comes to certain animals. I think that can be seen as morally neutral.

Once again, this answer/line of logic WOULD NOT be acceptable in other common social situations and could lead to greater suffering.

Well, I guess it's a good thing that I actually look at all the context before making a decision then.

See when I take you out of context, you sound worrying. Do that with my line of logic and lets compare results.

When you take anyone out of context they sound worrying. Hence why taking someone out of context is a dishonest thing to do. Is this supposed to be an argument against me?

I would say a bit of both, but depending on how our environment's condition is.

It's great that you are environmentally conscious. I strive to be as well, I just don't agree that eating a non-0 amount of meat is required to hit equilibrium with the earth's ability to be renewable.

I guess this is my problem in these debates. You can so easily brush off tremendous suffering with basic sophistry of "I'm not convinced".

Wow, "basic sophistry" huh? For not readily accepting a claim you made? If you're passing that as a useful sentence to put into your argument against me I don't think that speaks well for you.

You would accept that attitude in a debate about the shape of the planet? About the existance of gravity? About the relationship between the Earth and our moon? If you do choose to use that reasoning, the only reasonable thing to do is provide the data that gives you doubt or which you think is convincing of the opposite.

No, because I don't doubt those things. I understand the mechanisms of how they are proven. I have seen photographs of earth, I have witnessed gravity and I don't doubt gravities application to things like the moon and earth. What I don't know, is how to make sense of nutrition data.

What about David Katz's and Dean Ornish's work isn't convincing to you?

Any of it, because I've not seen any.

What would convince you of this being the case [plant based diet is healthier]?

Actually sitting down and understanding how these things are determined and getting some rudimentary knowledge of how studies are conducted. Nutritional science has changed a lot since I've been alive, things are overturned all the time, I don't know if it's any better now. But it would take a time investment. But as I said, personal health with food is a choice and not an obligation to me, so I don't put it high on my priorities. The vast majority of people consume meat and, in my country, the average life span is around 80. So I can probably look forward to at least that on average.

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

Thank you for your submission! Some topics come up a lot in this subreddit, so we would like to remind everyone to use the search function and to check out the wiki before creating a new post. We also encourage becoming familiar with our rules so users can understand what is expected of them.


When participating in a discussion, try to be as charitable as possible when replying to arguments. If an argument sounds ridiculous to you, consider that you may have misinterpreted what the author was trying to say. Ask clarifying questions if necessary. Do not attack the person you're talking to, concentrate on the argument. When possible, cite sources for your claims.

There's nothing wrong with taking a break and coming back later if you feel you are getting frustrated. That said, please do participate in threads you create. People put a lot of effort into their comments, so it would be appreciated if you return the favor.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-12
cXTNeynOPveganarchist•

The Systematic killing of animals happens every day in nature... . Whales devour thousands of pounds of Krill in one bite.

Only advanced species can create systems that are outside of their internal DNA. A whale doesn't breed dolphins and eat them for no reason. A whale does only what it need to survive. Nothing more and nothing less.

Think of all the suffering defenseless Krill go through

How about the Gazelle that gets ripped to shreds by the Cheetah?

If you want to compare your level of intelligence to these animals, I won't stop you.

is just an excuse to promote a fad diet and impose guilt on other people.

Which part about being able to feed an additional 800 million people if we consumed less animal products is a fad to you?

The truth is, humans need the essential B12 and omega 3 fatty acids to survive

We can manufacture them because we are intelligent. See what I mean about supplements being an easy argument for vegans?

All species eat, kill, and consume what is needed to survive

All animals. Animals don't have a choice because they haven't evolved beyond the natural laws. Humans have clearly created something different, or at least crossed a certain intelligence boundary. If you want to compare your level of intelligence to just an ordinary animal, I won't stop you.

To impose moral superiority over another species

Who is imposing moral superiority over what species? It's a humble notion to acknowledge that other animals may suffer just like us, even though we are clearly more capable. Are you projecting something?

ignore the ceaseless killing by another (animals vs. animals)

You ignore the countless starving people who can't afford to eat animals. Feel free to discuss your plans to solve the humanitarian crisis.

then take laboratory synthesized supplements (B12 / Omega 3 oils) is hypocritical

Written by someone on an internet message board. Solid points. You said that in your last post. It was super enlightening learning that pills are made by people and not mother nature.

Vegan: I'm better than a meat eater, because I do not eat animals.

Meat Eater: Well how else am I supposed to get all my nutrient needs?

Vegan: (Pops B12 / Omega 3 pills in his mouth) - Try living a more sustainable life.

Are you going to refute that? Do you have any data that compares "lab produced supplements" which A: vegan D3 is just algae, so its more of a processed food than "big pharma lab grade pills". B12 is just bacteria grown in a lab, and vegan Vitiamin D is just powdered mushrooms, so again a processed food. You consider all that unsustainable and hypocritical but forget to provide evidence for that claim? Oh you poor and confused thing.

10
[deleted]•

[removed]

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SoyBoy14800•

Findings from this meta-analysis indicate that processed meat consumption is positively associated with pancreatic cancer risk.

Conclusions High intake of red and processed meat is associated with significant increased risk of colorectal, colon and rectal cancers.

This comprehensive meta-analysis reports a significant protective effect of a vegetarian diet versus the incidence and/or mortality from ischemic heart disease (−25%) and incidence from total cancer (−8%).

Here is a meta-analysis showing that a vegetarian diet is associated with lower blood pressure.

Here is a meta-analysis showing that a plant based diet is associated with decreased total cholesterol.

Here is a meta-analysis (of observational studies) showing that a vegan diet is associated with lower heart disease mortality, and a reduced risk of total cancer.

Here is a meta-analysis showing that vegetarian diets are significantly better for weight loss than non-vegetarian diets.

Here you can see one of the multiple studies that shows a vegan diet is proven to reverse heart disease (the only diet ever that has been proven to reverse heart disease), whereas here you can see the meta-analysis that shows dietary cholesterol (only found in animal products and high density oils) has been proven to impact serum cholesterol which is what causes heart disease. Here is the European Atherosclerosis Society Consensus that LDL cholesterol causes heart disease, and here is a meta analysis showing that dietary cholesterol is associated with the presence of early heart disease in patients without disease, the number one killer in almost all developed countries.

This is the largest meta analysis ever conducted on the environmental impact of different foods by Oxford University. Here is a few key quotes;

"Moving from current diets to a diet that excludes animal products (table S13) (35) has transformative potential, reducing food’s land use by 3.1 (2.8 to 3.3) billion ha (a 76% reduction)"

"In particular, the impacts of animal products can markedly exceed those of vegetable substitutes (Fig. 1), to such a degree that meat, aquaculture, eggs, and dairy use ~83% of the world’s farmland and contribute 56 to 58% of food’s different emissions, despite providing only 37% of our protein and 18% of our calories."

6

The Systematic killing of animals happens every day in nature. As much as Vegans want to believe nature is a beautiful peaceful Utopia where there is not suffering of animals, it isn't true. Whales devour thousands of pounds of Krill in one bite. Think of all the suffering the defenseless Krill go through when consumed. How about the Gazelle that gets ripped to shreds by the Cheetah?

Vegans don't say that there is no suffering in nature (you might find a vegan who says that, but the good arguments for veganism don't say that).

Suffering in nature is not seen as a good thing, but it is not the focus of vegans because we cannot really do something about it and because animals are not moral agents, so they are not acting wrong when they kill other animals.

It seems that your argument is either that what is natural is good or that it is not wrong to harm animals because some animals will suffer regardless of what you do.

Both have problems.

You can find many things that are natural but wrong, it's natural to rape for many animals, but it is still clearly wrong for a human to do, so that justification doesn't work.

For the other justification you could similarly use it to justify nearly every crime, because even if you don't do it there will be murders, rapes and so on, but still it is wrong to do those things.

"Less suffering of sentient beings." is just an excuse to promote a fad diet and impose guilt on other people. The truth is, humans need the essential B12 and omega 3 fatty acids to survive. All species eat, kill, and consume what is needed to survive. To impose moral superiority over another species, and ignore the ceaseless killing by another (animals vs. animals) - then take laboratory synthesized supplements (B12 / Omega 3 oils) is hypocritical.

It seems that humans can get all nutrients they need in a vegan way, so we don't need to consume other animals to survive.

Vegan: I'm better than a meat eater, because I do not eat animals.

Meat Eater: Well how else am I supposed to get all my nutrient needs?

Vegan: (Pops B12 / Omega 3 pills in his mouth) - Try living a more sustainable life.

Veganism is about the treatment of animals, it's usually more environmentally friendly but that is not the goal, so even if it was worse for the environment to take some supplement instead of killing and eating an animal that is not hypocritical.

3
BondDerek007•

If a Cat was a Moral Agent, and able to distinguish right from wrong, what would it eat?

1
kenzzizi•

What's the point you're trying to make?

2

Moral agents do wrong things all the time, look at any crime that is committed, so what they would do in that situation doesn't tell us what we should do. Also a cat is a carnivore and has much less options than humans, so they would probably be forced to kill other animals to survive, but as omnivores we are not, except in some special circumstances.

1