The conflation of veganism and health, the OG of strawmen
I'll begin by saying that health was originally what lead me to veganism, but not in the Raw Alignment or Tim Shieff kind of health journey. I'll also disclaimer that I knew little to no information on any aspect of health, besides carbs being food for energy (always talked about carb loading in my athletic team), and calories in/calories out.
I didn't even know what veganism really was until I met the two vegan friends that passively persuaded me to go vegan. But looking back I had a lot of cognitive dissonance so the ethical appeal was always there, I just didn't even know that it was possible. I knew very few vegetarians and even scoffed at the idea myself, using BBQ, an appeal to sensory pleasure, as a justification even though I knew it was fucked up how we treated animals. I was definitely one of those grassy pasture utopia ideologists even though I half-assed my own vegetarian stint with restaurant sourced animal products. I even went as far as to resists veganism and claim that abstaining from transportation and other modern capitalist luxuries was a more noteworthy thing to do. So when I accidentally stumbled upon the WFPB community on youtube, and was easily able to understand the language and topics discussed, I had this question answered for me when I didn't even know I asked it:
If we can not only manage but reverse the damage caused by modern western lifestyle with a plant based diet, and also live a long and healthy life on a plant based diet, isn't it our responsibility as the only advanced species to exist in the universe to CHOOSE to not cause suffering and death?
How I got to this question and it's answer was from these facts:
- Dean Ornish has made the most significant reversal of cardiovascular damage by a diet that contains no animal protein and minimal saturated fat(some derived from animal products). There isn't a single study conducted to try and create the same results with the inclusion of any kind animal proteins.
- David Katz has conducted some of the best nutritional research that exists in medical literature, has all the profits from his books go to help communities, he chooses not to eat animals because the results of his work show no evidence that we are required to eat animals.
- The keto and paleo movements have no honorable accomplishments to speak of. Grassy pasture utopias won't feed the world population even if we were required to get certain nutrients from animals.
- A marginal cases for supplements could easily be used to argue in favor of the vegan and health positions.
So ex vegans claim they were on a vegan diet, not a WFPB diet because only the former is true. The mainstream can't help but use the vegan word non stop because it's catchy and still technically correct, and can be used to produce negative results. Starving yourself could definitely be vegan. Eating raw foods and expecting to overcome the law of thermodynamics could certainly be vegan. But none of that is what WFPB doctors recommend, and what they recommend isn't even always vegan(The fiasco with Jaden Smith). The Game Changers doc never mentioned the word, yet we hear non stop about how the gladiators weren't vegan. No shit lol. This obvious strawman is in place to avoid the actual difficult questions:
- why would someone choose to support the systematic killing of animals for no good reason?
- Why would someone who has witnessed crimes against humanity be in the wrong for make the comparison between humanity's treatment of eachother, and our treatment of lesser animals?
Posted Dec 13, 2019, 9:41 PM UTC · edited
As That Vegan Couple likes to point out, people believe that eating animal products is "natural, normal, and necessary".
The trick is, if vegan diets truly are unhealthy, then they aren't entirely practicable.
That's why the health argument is so important.
Once the health argument is established in the mind of someone, the necessity of animal exploitation evaporates, and you are stuck dealing with the ethical argument, which is bulletproof.
That was my experience, and the experience of many many others. That's why the hard work that went into the game changers was so important.
Bingo. It forces the burden of proof onto the opposition.