Advice for Second Card for a skewed spending portfolio
- Current cards:
- UCU Classic Mastercard, $5000 limit (no benefits)
- FICO Score: e.g. 742 Experian
- Oldest account age: e.g. 1 year 2 months
- Chase 5/24 status: e.g 5/24
- Income: e.g. $88,000
- Average monthly spend and categories:
- Airfares (primarily SouthWest) $1500
- Uber: $500
- Dining: $200
- Groceries $20
- Gas: $20
- Amazon: $50
- Hotels (Marriott): $0* (*Currently $2000, expected to drop in to $0 early 2020.)
- Open to Business Cards: e.g. Yes
- What's the purpose of your next card? Cashback
- Do you have any cards you've been looking at? Citibank 2x, WF Propel, Uber Visa, Chase Freedom, Airline cards
- Are you OK with category spending or do you want a general spending card? Both.
Key factors:
- As you can see my spending is highly skewed due to high travel expenses for business, which are payed personally and then reimbursed. Dining is the next factor.
- My capital and credit score is good, but my history is limited, so i am worried about not getting tougher cards.
- I would strongly prefer $0 AF. Unless you can make a compelling argument that the fee will pay itself back consistently through natural use.
- SUB are nice but not my primary interest. I will not have the desire to remain active in card shifting.
- Zero exchange rate is valuable but not critical, as someone who goes home abroad 1/year.
- I am open to two cards if one is outstanding but specialized, with the other more general. Or if one were much better for my use but less universally accepted (Amex/Discover). I am not particularly interested in juggling more than that.
I have read through plenty of posts on this sub and am aware of the love of Chase cards. I would be open to banking with them, in general i need a new primary bank, but would i need to wait long? Also, while i am also aware of the 180 on the Uber card, it appears it may still be good, even great for my uses. Open to alternatives though.
Posted Dec 18, 2019, 1:55 AM UTC
The Uber card is probably in fact still pretty good for you, at least for Uber use... I personally wouldn't count it as one of your options in your shoes, nor would I carry it... just get it, save it in the app, and sock drawer the physical card.
Option B there would be an Amex Platinum, and use it for airfare, hotels & Uber. High annual fee, but a decent bit of applicable benefits for you.
The Southwest Priority would be good if you're interested in Southwest points, either for personal travel or if you could get reimbursed for using rewards for a work flight at a decent rate. Lower AF, but you're pretty much locking yourself into just Southwest points.
I'd personally be going for a Sapphire Reserve if I were you. You've got pretty ideal circumstances for it... lots of travel spending, with someone else's money. The fee sounds high, but even my rarely-traveling self can use the $300 travel credit no problem. I'd strongly advise you to reconsider your adversity to annual fees, and look at what you'd be getting out of it and subtract the fee from that... if things change in the future, most offer the ability to downgrade to a cheaper/free card.
As far as credit, I'd see if you can get a limit increase on your current card, wait til it reports, and fire away. You're over a year, you've got decent income, I think if your payment history is good and you don't have more than a couple inquiries, you've got a decent chance with most cards.