Small rant about aggro always prevailing the meta
Yes, I prefer to play control decks.
Power creep is off the roof (again) with the new set, examples include:
- A 4 mana 5/4 draw three (well you can't pull this off on turn 4 without coin, but still op when played on "on curve" on turn 5 after turn 3 and 4 invokes or just later on in the game);
- A 5 mana 3/3 summon two 2/1's with rush (with TWO invoke benefits for later on);
- A 5 mana summon two 5/6 with taunt (holy shit 10/12 for 5 mana is just nuts, AND has two taunts, AND can be played easily on curve).
- A 9 mana 8/8 "summon" two random dragons and benefit from their battlecries (did the math, on average it's 8/8 + 5.11/6.45 so 13/14 and two generally really good battlecries - okay it's conditional on not having duplicates, which evens it out)
Now, sure control can use these cards as well, but if both control and aggro can use them it's more beneficial for aggro or even worse, the player who plays it first! Being the first one to act is insanely efficient with power creep since you can end games even faster than before. This is problematic since boards get bigger than before and faster than before, which threatens lethal very fast. Without an immediate answer to a huge opponent's board, games are shorter than ever.
Would it make any sense to increase the HP slightly to accommodate the bigger boards? Or have similarly power creeping control cards? Healing used to be around 0.33 mana per 1 health (Holy Light, Healing Touch). Now it's generally 0.2 mana per 1 health (Radiance, Crystal Power), which is positive, but the problem is the inherent cost of card. It's not viable to spend a card slot for a card that does nothing but heals. The only exception would be rogue that would actually benefit from a card like Regenerate (heal 3 for 0 mana) due to combos. Yet Rogue has no such cards.
Cards like Flash of Light (heal 4, draw), Shield Block (5 armor, draw 1), and the keyword lifesteal is a great way around the inherent cost of cards and power creeping those would be awesome! The only really power creeped "healing" card I can think of is Ferocious Howl (draw 1, gain 1 armor for each card in hand). Yes, more cards like that would be good.
So what about making the initial HP to 35 or 40? Or have a card that somehow easily increases the max HP like Amari did. This doesn't make the power creeped cards bad (slightly worse), and allows more room for error when responding to immediate early-mid game threats. I'd really enjoy that.
I'm not blaming the power creep, it's quite essential for a card game in order to keep the meta fresh, but the power creep shouldn't always benefit aggro. An expansion where control gains the most would be a fresh cup of tea! Could be, for example, really powerful removal cards.
Posted Dec 18, 2019, 6:13 AM UTC