AmericanResearch•

In this sub, we should aspire to link to the primary research article:

​

https://www.bmj.com/content/367/bmj.l6573

86
[deleted]•

[deleted]

66
pastaandpizza•

Studies in the sciences have reached similar conclusions. A textual analysis of approximately 7,000 research grant proposals to the Gates Foundation found that despite grant reviewers not knowing the identity of the applicant, women received lower application scores.

This is...surprising to me.

The gap could be explained entirely by the gender differences in how applicants framed their research.

Is that really reasonable though? That the same data, if just repackaged in a "man's voice" would score better? That kind of trivializes all of the other systemic issues women face that would limit their ability to generate sufficient preliminary data for major grants IMHO.

7
Special-Nerve•

I agree with the authors of the article that we need further research into this. I don’t know if it trivializes it but it might help us be aware of a preexisting preference for “male structured” language.

6
Lightning1798•

I think it’s certainly very realistic that the difference is due to framing differences (but not necessarily gender), just due to the nature of the writing process. The ability to package and concisely describe a project idea and why it’s impactful so that unfamiliar reviewers and admins determining funding allocation feel passionate about it is probably more important than the project idea itself in determining funding success.

I certainly would hesitate to guess that gender-based wording differences would be at play here though. Similar to papers, I think self-flattering wording might even be detrimental in this process: it’s a careful craft where every word counts and it may just turn reviewers off.

I think other systemic sources of bias are more likely to come into play. Men are more likely to be directly trained in grant writing by successful PI’s, either by advisor’s preference, or because they’re more likely to seek it out? It’s also significant to note that “blind” review processes often aren’t really blind, as scientific communities are closely knit and people can sometimes obviously identify researchers just by the nature of the project. So then established male PI’s might still have an advantage that, while probably less significant, could result in some correlation or trends. I’m sure there are other possibilities.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-34
personalistLab Manager/Tech•

And the point of your rambling is?

8
lindsayb43•

Oh, so just one word. Got it.

3
rpfflgtGroup leader, Germany, STEM•

It's funny, because the only thing I have ever been taught about talking up your own work is that one should not talk up their work. Some journals outright forbid adjective like novel, excellent, groundbreaking, paradigm-shifting in manuscript titles. And yet, this excessive self-promotion seems to be extremely prevalent.

34
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
garulous•

I was unable to read the article due to paywall (I've reached my free limit). But just the title reminds me of the book *Women Don't Ask*, which is basically about research into how women tend to feel uncomfortable seeing their work as having value and, in particular, communicating about it as if it does. The book is more specifically about negotiation and asking for raises in the corporate workplace (so more literal, monetary value) but it's a pretty similar logic. I would recommend the book if this article is one of your first times reading about the issue and you are interested in more information.

33
wantonyak•

Yes, that seems to be the gist. According to the article (and brief glance at the abstract) men flatter their own research in it's descriptions more than women: they describe their research as unique, novel, excellent, etc.... The article goes on to say this may also account for gender differences in grant attainment, if women are less likely to "talk up" their research in their grant proposals.

I agree, it seems very similar to women not negotiating for better pay. What the opinion piece didn't mention (idk if it was discussed in the original article) is that women are also more likely to be penalized for talking up their research. They are also more likely to be penalized for negotiating. While men are more likely to be disliked for acting humble in job negotiations. So it's a lose-lose for women (the tightrope bias).

27
garulous•

Yes the book also talks about that in the corporate context, too. I'm glad that this article is touching on this same set of issues, especially in academia where you may not expect it quite as much. That's fascinating (and disheartening). As a non-male person going the academic route, the idea of describing my own work as excellent makes me nauseous at first reaction (especially since I'm so early in the process but even later I'd really have to force myself to describe my work that way).

8
wantonyak•

Ah I should have guessed the book would talk about that and that you already know about it. I actually teach psychology of gender and talk about this stuff so much in class that I forget I'm not always talking to students.

And I (woman) feel the same way! I can't imagine ever calling my own work excellent. Even when I'm talking to lay people about my work that they say something like "Oh that's really cool" my response is "It's alright" or "I'm lucky to be able to do something I love."

11
ks_789•

I can’t speak for how men’s and women’s work may be perceived differently if their identity is known or subtly indicated but I’m a man and this has been a challenge for me too. Ultimately, though, I’ve had to learn because it’s the game and you either play to win or you don’t. I don’t necessarily feel that it’s fair, but from a purely pragmatic point of view that’s irrelevant.

-3†
cwkid•

Do you have more information about men being more likely to be disliked for acting humble? I'm male and don't like evaluating myself or my own research or negotiating. But I always assumed that this didn't really affect me very much, because... I'm a guy I guess.

2†
john_the_fisherman•

I partially mentioned this in a comment I made up above, but it was partially related to your question.

From the article The Confidence Gap, by the Atlantic

The fact is, overconfidence can get you far in life. Cameron Anderson, a psychologist who works in the business school at the University of California at Berkeley, has made a career of studying overconfidence. In 2009, he conducted some novel tests to compare the relative value of confidence and competence. He gave a group of 242 students a list of historical names and events, and asked them to tick off the ones they knew.

Among the names were some well-disguised fakes: a Queen Shaddock made an appearance, as did a Galileo Lovano, and an event dubbed Murphy’s Last Ride. The experiment was a way of measuring excessive confidence, Anderson reasoned. The fact that some students checked the fakes instead of simply leaving them blank suggested that they believed they knew more than they actually did. At the end of the semester, Anderson asked the students to rate one another in a survey designed to assess each individual’s prominence within the group. The students who had picked the most fakes had achieved the highest status. Confidence, Anderson told us, matters just as much as competence. We didn’t want to believe it, and we pressed him for alternative theories. But deep down, we knew we’d seen the same phenomenon for years. Within any given organization, be it an investment bank or the PTA, some individuals tend to be more admired and more listened to than others. They are not necessarily the most knowledgeable or capable people in the room, but they are the most self-assured.

“When people are confident, when they think they are good at something, regardless of how good they actually are, they display a lot of confident nonverbal and verbal behavior,” Anderson said. He mentioned expansive body language, a lower vocal tone, and a tendency to speak early and often in a calm, relaxed manner. “They do a lot of things that make them look very confident in the eyes of others,” he added. “Whether they are good or not is kind of irrelevant.” Kind of irrelevant. Infuriatingly, a lack of competence doesn’t necessarily have negative consequences. Among Anderson’s students, those who displayed more confidence than competence were admired by the rest of the group and awarded a high social status. “The most confident people were just considered the most beloved in the group,” he said. “Their overconfidence did not come across as narcissistic.”

That is a crucial point. True overconfidence is not mere bluster. Anderson thinks the reason extremely confident people don’t alienate others is that they aren’t faking it. They genuinely believe they are good, and that self-belief is what comes across. Fake confidence, he told us, just doesn’t work in the same way. Studies Anderson is now conducting suggest that others can see the “tells.” No matter how much bravado someone musters, when he doesn’t genuinely believe he is good, others pick up on his shifting eyes and rising voice and other giveaways. Most people can spot fake confidence from a mile away.

The article then makes note of possible reasons why women lack innate confidence relative to their male counterparts: Less likely to play sports in their youth (though this is slowly evening out), less testosterone, etc.

TLDR: "Overconfident" people in general tend to have higher self perception of themselves, which often translated to higher social status and group admiration. That being said, I am sure there is more nuance involved--particularly with the general societal views on different gender roles.

8
wantonyak•

Sorry I forgot to reply. This is the article I know off the top of my head. It's not about negotiation but it is about men being evaluated negatively for being modest. I'll see what else I can dig up later. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Laurie_Rudman/publication/232464622_When_Men_Break_the_Gender_Rules_Status_Incongruity_and_Backlash_Against_Modest_Men/links/0c9605324b3a96e0f0000000.pdf

1
intirbgot phd, went to industry•

To be fair, it’s possible that women are making the optimal call between a series of bad options. Some studies suggest that when women do ask, they end up getting penalized for it. It’s hard to recommend that women negotiate more without considering whether they should expect to see the same results for doing so as men.

14
garulous•

No I agree with you. The reason that women feel it would be wrong is probably also felt by other people (and there is also the evidence that they are penalized for doing so). Frankly I don't think it's a particularly good thing that men tend to speak so highly of their own work, as if that's necessarily the ideal-- but what it comes down to is whether it works for people, and it evidently does in some cases and not others.

3
1121314151617•

For everyone complaining about the paywall, may I introduce you to this extension?

26
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
doornroosjePhD*, International Security•

THANKS!

2
john_the_fisherman•

It's called the confidence gap and it disproportionately affects women across the board, regardless of industry. Another user mentioned the book "Woman Don't Ask," but I found this article from the Atlantic to be a little more accessible. The article discusses several studies or scholarly work, all of which find an acute lack of confidence among females. Some interesting quotes are highlighted below:

  • in studies of business-school students, that men initiate salary negotiations four times as often as women do, and that when women do negotiate, they ask for 30 percent less money than men do.

  • “We wanted to see whether your general perception of Am I good in science? shapes your impression of something that should be separate: Did I get this question right?,”...The women rated themselves more negatively than the men did on scientific ability: on a scale of 1 to 10, the women gave themselves a 6.5 on average, and the men gave themselves a 7.6. When it came to assessing how well they answered the questions, the women thought they got 5.8 out of 10 questions right; men, 7.1. And how did they actually perform? Their average was almost the same—women got 7.5 out of 10 right and men 7.9.

  • To show the real-world impact of self-perception, the students were then invited—having no knowledge of how they’d performed—to participate in a science competition for prizes. The women were much more likely to turn down the opportunity: only 49 percent of them signed up for the competition, compared with 71 percent of the men. “That was a proxy for whether women might seek out certain opportunities,”... “Because they are less confident in general in their abilities, that led them not to want to pursue future opportunities.”*

  • A review of personnel records found that women working at HP applied for a promotion only when they believed they met 100 percent of the qualifications listed for the job. Men were happy to apply when they thought they could meet 60 percent of the job requirements. At HP, and in study after study, the data confirm what we instinctively know. Underqualified and underprepared men don’t think twice about leaning in. Overqualified and overprepared, too many women still hold back. Women feel confident only when they are perfect. Or practically perfect.

  • We also began to see that a lack of confidence informs a number of familiar female habits. Take the penchant many women have for assuming the blame when things go wrong, while crediting circumstance—or other people—for their successes. (Men seem to do the opposite.) David Dunning, the Cornell psychologist, offered the following case in point: In Cornell’s math Ph.D. program, he’s observed, there’s a particular course during which the going inevitably gets tough. Dunning has noticed that male students typically recognize the hurdle for what it is, and respond to their lower grades by saying, “Wow, this is a tough class.” That’s what’s known as external attribution, and in a situation like this, it’s usually a healthy sign of resilience. Women tend to respond differently. When the course gets hard, Dunning told us, their reaction is more likely to be “You see, I knew I wasn’t good enough.” That’s internal attribution, and it can be debilitating.

  • Perfectionism is another confidence killer. Study after study confirms that it is largely a female issue, one that extends through women’s entire lives. [Woman] don’t answer questions until we are totally sure of the answer, we don’t submit a report until we’ve edited it ad nauseam, and we don’t sign up for that triathlon unless we know we are faster and fitter than is required. We watch our male colleagues take risks, while we hold back until we’re sure we are perfectly ready and perfectly qualified.

10
StrungStringBeans•

I have a couple issues with your comment here.

The first is that some studies have indicated that women who attempt to negotiate tend to face career repercussions men don't, even when they get they get the initial raise they've requested. These studies thus suggest that women choosing not to negotiate is in fact a rational and far-sighted choice.

I also wouldn't be surprised if similar social consequences were responsible for other differences as well.

But regardless, this engages in a "fix the women" style of addressing gender bias. I think instead it would behoove us a society to consider how men's socialization to be overconfident and unwilling to take responsibility for their own actions (which is another way of looking at your "facts" above) is not something to be encouraged in the populace more broadly and in fact is something that we should work on curtailing.

The "fix the women" approach is one that minimizes the effects of systemic sexism. It allows us, for example, to blame women themselves for the wage gap, rather than workplace bias. It also will never be successful, because it ignores why women tend statistically to behave in the ways that they do.

Instead of asking how do we "fix the women", which is pointless and unhelpful, we need to 1) fix systemic bias and 2) maybe focus on "fixing the men" for once.

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
StrungStringBeans•

Why can't we focus on "fixing the people" and "fixing the systemic bias"?

For example, just because, on average, men tend to be overconfident, doesn't mean that women have a healthy level of confidence.

Because we're already talking about fixing the women, and we've been doing so since forever. As a society we've given zero serious thought to the men side of the equation, and we'll continue not doing so unless we talk about men specifically.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
DrParapraxisSocial Psychology•

Why can't we focus on "fixing the people" and "fixing the systemic bias"?

Recent research finds that when people hear "lean in" messages where the solution is women's behaviour, they also make the assumptions (a) that women are responsible for the gender gap and (b) systemic factors are less important.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
KareBear03•

I am not a big time researcher (yet!), awesome publications on the horizon. One criticism I have received regularly from male advisors is my use of tentative language. I shouldn't be making unfounded claims but the claims I make should expressed with confidence. I generally feel uncomfortable making assertive claims. Hypothesis in my field are always one fossil away from being disproven.

5
ritox92•

"Awsome publications on the horizon", cant tell if sarcastic or not.

0†
KareBear03•

Really just trying to convince myself.

4
cwkid•

Personally, I would like to think that if I see a paper that describes its work as being "novel" or "excellent" I am more likely to be critical. Now my expectations are high, and either they are met but the abstract has gotten in the way my ability to evaluate the result, or they are not and now I am annoyed at the authors for their spin. But I'm not very sure if I end up actually feeling this way, and this piece makes me wonder if maybe unconsciously, I actually do the opposite.

3
camilo16•

Can anyone resume the article? Paywalls are bad, mmmkay?

-2†
papayatwentythree•

The gap is probably partially due to the fact that those seats are taken up by old tenured people.

-4
[deleted]•

[removed]

-7
mafematiks•

This is pointless because I really doubt anything I say will change your mind, however, the fact that women are underrepresented in science does not mean that merit is removed. If the gender makeup in science doesn't align with the gender makeup of the general population, then women are not represented.

That's legitimately all it means, the gender makeup of people in science does not represent the gender makeup of the population. Keep in mind it's not something like 47 vs 53 percent, it's well beyond a statistical anomaly.

3
ThiccaryClinton•

Women are not underrepresented in science. They are represented, just less often than men. To say their representation is “under” a certain value implies that men and women

  1. Merit equal performance in science and
  2. Make the same life choices as men
  3. Require an arbitrary quota on a profession

And yet, certain fields are male dominated, while others are female dominated. Men and women think differently. Why is that bad, or indicative of some patriarchal conspiracy? When I worked as a carpenter one summer, I met a female roofer. She was perfectly competent at her job, yet she wasn’t complaining about there not being enough women. Why are you?

ACT section scores by gender show males scoring higher on science and math while scoring lower on reading and English, despite being uNdErRePrEsEnTeD when compared to women. Women outnumber men in math classes, score higher grades in the class, but then get lower grades on the standardized test. Why is that?

Does that mean some women are treated unfairly because they are the minority? Probably. But that’s in no way indicative of a patriarchal conspiracy.

-4
Queen_of_Dirt•

Do you have any sources that show the difference in how men and women think is inherent and not social?

0
ahmadove•

Academic and affords an NYT subscription? Got ourselves an intrinsic limitation

-10
restricteddataTT Asst Prof, PhD, History of Science•

NYT digital subscription is $7.50/mo. for educators ($90/yr), $4/mo. for students ($48/yr). While I'm sure that might still be a significant amount of money for some people, we don't have to indulge in "poverty porn" culture of academia.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
ahmadove•

Yep, it was a joke (PhD salaries where I am are arguably the highest in the world). Would it kill people to relax?

2†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

-18
restricteddataTT Asst Prof, PhD, History of Science•

Ah yes, the old "I'm sure this is just broad generalizations and can be safely ignored as pseudoscience" from the person who didn't read the article.

18
gutfounderedgal•

You see enough of these you see the patterns.

-10
restricteddataTT Asst Prof, PhD, History of Science•

Indeed: I see enough of people commenting on things they don't know anything about to see the patterns.

13
DrParapraxisSocial Psychology•

often based on sloppy polls or some other weird manner of garnering their information

Wrong, it's based on a BMJ article published last month.

it seems it's a book promo piece, so of course the idea is to drum up a bit of debate.

No book mentioned.

I can't read the article, paywall limit

But you still felt free to criticize methods you haven't read, and attribute uncharitable motives to the authors?

12
MelancholyBeet•

The science article is open access, you can go straight to the primary source to examine in detail how they came to their conclusions. It's not based on polls. It's based on the language that researchers choose to describe their own research.

https://www.bmj.com/content/367/bmj.l6573

It's not a book promo. It's an opinion piece by the researchers themselves. Talking about their work in a broader context. I suppose it's marked as "opinion" because researchers can't report objectively on their own work.

11