Non-insurance therapist fails to grasp just how stressful it is to pay the full fee and wait around for reimbursement, thinking of terminating

I’ve been seeing my therapist since 2014. Today she made an announcement to me regarding her fees. I don’t know about the rest of you, but talking about finances is one of the topics I dread most in therapy. This announcement was ill-timed IMO because we won’t be meeting again until Jan. 9 (holidays) so I have to stew over it for 3 weeks. She wants to raise my rate and I got upset.

“But you get 70% of it back.”

“I know you know that, but it’s stressful for me because it’s still $XXX every week and I have to wait around for Aetna to reimburse me, and you don’t give me a statement every week. I’m sorry I’m not one of your more well off patients who can afford to give you the money up front and doesn’t have to worry.”

Then [I’m ashamed to admit] I started crying and all the feelings about the times I fuck up with money (instead of remembering that I have to set it aside for therapy) came up to the surface. Part of the tears were also a knee-jerk reaction that I’m just another customer to her.

I really wish she could have picked a week that wasn’t before such a long break. This therapist made me really angry about 6 months ago when she neglected to tell me until the penultimate session that she was going out of town on a long vacation, which caused a bunch of underlying resentment on my part and now this new thing is bringing up resentment again.

She is a skilled therapist but she is really careless when it comes to timing “announcements.” and because I’m a sensitive snowflake they end up feeling traumatic. I’ve read a lot out there about how terminations shouldn’t end on an angry note, but I’m tired of always talking these things out only to never have my grudge totally go away.

I really want to end this and just see my psychiatrist as needed. The stress of paying for it all up front is just too much to bear and it’s getting in the way of the therapy and causing me more anxiety. My city doesn’t have many therapists who even take insurance anymore, and this trend is probably occurring all over the US.

Posted Dec 20, 2019, 1:13 AM UTC

76
norashepard•

I felt this way too. My substitute therapist didn’t take insurance and it was really stressful waiting. It also requires organization; I lost one of the receipts and was too embarrassed to go back so I ate like, $100. I wouldn’t terminate over it because I can afford to wait, but if the stress was accompanied by a legit financial burden I would probably also consider termination.

3
CozyJumpers•

You're not a sensitive snowflake, anyone would be upset by that situation, I know I would too.

I'm curious as to how her demeanor was when you reacted that way? Did she seem sympathetic to your struggle? Did she seem to empathize with how difficult this must be on you? Or offer you any words of support or explanation?

If you feel like you're able to talk to her both about this and her general behavior of not letting you know things til the last second (i.e.: the situation of her not letting you know she was leaving for vacation), I'd highly encourage you to talk to her about it and let her know how stressful these short-notice experiences have been on you. Generally speaking, therapists are indeed supposed to provide sufficient notice for these situations, and it's a bit of a misstep on her part to not have let you know at a good time.

I completely empathize with you on the stress of paying for therapy, it's absolutely criminal how bad mental health coverage is in the U.S, I pay for therapy 100% out of pocket, because like you, my city has virtually no therapists that accept insurance. I sincerely hope things turn around soon, but until then, please don't lose hope in therapy overall. I know things look pretty bleak for you right now, but they can pick up with time, this situation is painful but temporary.

3
fitzbarOP•

Hi, before I reply I want you to know that upon reflection about this upset I’ve realized that what happened is way more about me than it was about her. I’m not letting her shitty sense of timing go, though, and I’m asking for an apology when we meet again. I told her I wanted to initiate termination over next month, but now I’m having second thoughts now that I’ve had more time to think about what happened. I just don’t know if I can afford this anymore. It’s so stressful. She told me in an email that she was “so sorry that what happened between us yesterday was so distressing”.

In the session, she emphasized that she hadn’t raised my rate in the 5+ years that I’ve been seeing her, it was “only” by $20, and that I would still get most of it back from my insurance. I said “well, I guess it’s so long then” and she bristled at that. “That’s your decision even before we’ve talked this over?” I restated for the 1,000th time that it’s hard waiting around for Aetna to take 3 weeks+ to reimburse me, and how when it comes to finances the word “only” gets me into trouble because “only’s” add up. She gave me the company line “I know this is difficult for you.” She admitted that she didn’t want me to spend the next 3 weeks being upset about this or beating myself up, but I don’t remember her apologizing for dropping a bomb on me before a holiday break. If she had told me at the beginning of the month it would have been different, I would have had 2 more sessions to deal with it.

The 2nd half of the session was spent mostly in silence because I couldn’t stop crying. Like I said in my original post, this upset was twofold - she has the world’s worst timing and it stirred up feelings about my bad financial behavior which have nothing to do with her. She didn’t say much during my sobfest because she’s one of those therapists that makes clients “sit” with their feelings. I told her I wanted to leave early because I didn’t have anything else to say, and she said no because she didn’t want to end the session before the break with me walking out. I don’t get what difference it would have made, we only had 5 minutes left.

I’ve been in therapy with various providers for over 20 years, and I’ve never had as many ruptures as I’ve had with this one. I don’t know if that’s a good or bad thing, or just a thing. I think her intentions are good, it’s just her carelessness that sticks in my craw.

I genuinely worry about the state of mental healthcare in this country. It’s great that more people are talking about it and the stigma is slowly fading away, but things were very different just 15-20 years ago. You looked up a therapist in the insurance company’s system and there weren’t any “hiccups” (at least for me). I have no idea how many times the therapist was refused payment by the insurance company. Now places are fleeing the system - 3 of my providers don’t take insurance (psychologist, psychiatrist, and even my physical therapist). When I went to a physical therapist that participated with my insurance, Aetna interfered with my care and stopped paying saying I didn’t need treatment anymore.

1
CozyJumpers•

Wow, that sounds like a rough session for sure. That's awesome that you're willing to give it another go though, it's definitely worth bringing this all up to her. Therapy can be super complicated in the sense that you realize that sometimes the reason you're upset is your own baggage, other times it's genuinely the therapist's actions, and sometimes it's both at the same time. Luckily a big part of therapy is being able to process all of the above with the therapist.

It sounds like from what you're saying that she did want to help and did care, but just dropped the ball on how she handled the timing of this revelation, that's really awesome that you're willing to talk to her about that. I hope you manage to have a good conversation on it all and that you can repair your relationship with her and move forward with your therapy. I know the holidays are a rough time, especially with how they often involve a break from therapy, so I hope you can manage to practice some self care these next few weeks til you can see her again. I've had rough therapy sessions before and I know how much they can leave you feeling drained and depressed for a while after, but I can promise you it always passes x

2
fitzbarOP•

I saw her [fucking finally!] 3 days ago and we patched things up. She explained where she was coming from and how her timing and word choices were bad. She apologized. For my part, I was completely honest and shared with her that for about a day or so I had entertained the thought of completely ghosting her. We’re back on track now.

1
CozyJumpers•

That's awesome! I'm really glad you were able to patch things up :)

2