As a highschool accounting student I really have no clue how this would be accounted for? How is it taxed? Anyone have an experience w it?

Posted Dec 24, 2019, 7:56 PM UTC

Posted Dec 24, 2019, 7:56 PM UTC
Non-interest income, fee based revenue. I think.
I guess I sort of do, as I am in FS practice.
Debit Liability for Consumer Interest Checking Accounts*
Credit Overdraft Fee Revenue
It would generate taxable income. In the US most banks pay federal tax at a rate of 21% on their profits. Most states also impose some sort of tax, either based on net income or net worth.
Things like this interest me so much and make me wanna study accounting, but everyone hating their lives deters me :((
The accountants out there who love their jobs aren't spending time complaining on reddit. What you see on reddit isn't representative of the actual profession at all
If everyone could AT LEAST understand THIS PART!
What you see on reddit isn't representative of the actual profession at all
It is of my firm, but we complain for the camaraderie
I love my current job and hated my time in public. It’s not one or the other.
Just find a niche in the industry you like. Most of the people here who hate their lives work in public accounting, which is just a suicide machine. You don’t hear a lot about industry, internal audit, forensic, or government accountants because they don’t hate their lives as much as those in public.
Agreed. I went straight into industry (healthcare no less) and I’m not much behind anybody I went to school with that went the big 4 route. I do hate sitting in an office but just turned 26 I get almost 6 weeks paid time off and only work my 40 hours with a couple rare exceptions and still pull 75k in a suburb. Not a bad gig at all for someone who never had to do the slaveship.
It becomes a different story if you aren’t performing in your industry job and your friends stay in the big 4 then 10 years down the road you will still be an analyst making 80k and they have a manager/controller/director job somewhere decent making 100-175k
Can I ask how/why you got into healthcare? I was going back to school next year to get out of "retail hell" and into accounting and was trying to decide between trying to go into industry or try the big4/smaller firms.
It’s literally a dumb meme to hate your life. There are negative and positive people in life. I know some really positive folks in B4 with very fulfilled lives.
I bitch and moan about accounting all the time, but I really actually like it. It's just blowing off steam, and it's healthy to do and people of all professions do it.
Most of the people birching on here are in public accounting and working insane hours. Staff accountants in industry jobs tend to be happier.
Not everyone hates accounting! If you have a genuine interest go for it! I didnt like it at first but once I found what I enjoyed in it I became the most enthusiastic worked about the accounting techniques I learned! I love accounting and nobodies views on it take that away from me, if you have a genuine interest explore it!
Things like this interest me so much and make me wanna study accounting
Then study it! The reason why people on r/accounting hate their life is because they chose to study accounting for the stable job, not the work that comes with it.
Part of becoming an adult is realizing life is probably not going to be as great as you thought it would be when you were a kid or even when you graduated high school and then college. Accounting is boring. But it pays well. There are less boring professions that pay less. There may be some more enjoyable professions that pay more, but they're usually very competitive, luck-based, and/or require some higher barrier of entry in some fashion.
Being an accountant is not living the dream, but most people do not live the dream. I don't particularly enjoy being an accountant, but I prefer it to all the other options available to me. Welcome to the real world.
[deleted]
You don't have to hate your whole life just because you study accounting. Studying it is fun (though sometimes stressful), and the many careers you can take in life that exist in the realm of accounting are not stressful unless you make it that way for yourself.
Wouldnt it make more sense to debit an asset? Debiting a liability for an overdraft fee would result in a liability with a debit balance with respect to that account, right?
It would likely not result in a debit balance. Similar to adjustments for writing off A/R with a credit to A/R, the account will still be a debit balance. In this case you could debit the liability account, however the overall balance would likely still be a credit as other customers have money that the bank has a liability on.
Right as far as the control account is concerned I understand that it would likely maintain a credit balance, but that's moreso a consequence of people not wanting to overdraft their accounts. The difference with an A/R account though is that it actually shouldn't ever have a credit balance, because you can only write off what you already have. With overdraft fees, there's really nothing from an accounting perspective that acts as any kind of backstop to prevent overdraft fees from increasing indefinitely. It just seems strange that a bank would say, as a matter of policy, that they can have negative liabilities with customers, as opposed to treating overdraft fees as some type of receivable.
I don't work in banking obviously so I could totally be wrong about all of this.
Oh ya I see what you are saying, maybe this has just developed as a practice because that would be incredibly rare. If they did happen the bank would surely go out of business, they must have some policy to stop all their customers from doing that obviously. It could just be that they do it because it’s easy and they aren’t worried about the extremes.
The bank is loaning you money you dont have when you overdraft. Nobody loans money for free. Get over it.
That being said It would be nicer for the bank to just decline any pull on the account once it hits 0.
Then you have to weigh up whether the overdraft establishment fee is worth the dishonour fee if it's a direct debit.
Still, $20 to establish an overdraft. Give me a break.
It'd be nice to have the choice. Rarely the overdraft is something I'd deliberately take when I was poor to get something I needed. Like getting fuel so you can go to do a bit of work to make some money. Then it's like find charge me I just needed the $20.
And what has Ms. Eliza Hardy done to help people with 0 balance? Overdraft is a lifeline for many people. The expectation is that "hey I know you one broke ass nikka right now, so I'll give you some money to spend, charge you a fee for it, and I expect it will all be accounted for when you can stand on your feet again and continue banking with us."
Some overdraft is based on a monthly charge and some is based on how much you cross 0 balance by.
It's extremely clutch for people who more or less live pay check to pay check but have a random expense out of the blue or as a brokeass student needing a bit more to survive until their student loans come in.
Man fuck these liberals who present everything in an emotionally charged sphere to make everyone who questions it sound like an asshole. Their fascism and discriminatory beliefs are not any different principally than what we have seen from numerous evil regimes. The only difference is that it is based on banking on manipulating people's empathy and to invoke guilt in anyone who dares question it.
Exhibit A: "Oh so you're saying it's okay for rich people to charge people that literally have no money??!?!!!!"
Two-three lines and my whole schpiel gets ignored. With the short attention span of most people these days and emotional immaturity/vulnerability it's pretty obvious which view point they are going to process. Boom. Hook line and sinker. The left cannot be defeated
Downvoted, not because I disagree with you about overdraft fees, but because you presented this as a problem unique to one side, when the right does it just as much about the issues they care about.
I agree but the left has a strangle hold on all the major corporations and the schooling system. People on the right have cognitive dissonance too but usually it's predicated on less virtue signalling and hence a lot easier to break down. . The one biggest area where the right has lots of cognitive dissonance on the left is too brainwashed to talk about. If there's any white privilege people need to talk about it should be the white privilege of the US Army and all its allies and the huge double standards as if their lives and causes are more superior than other non white lives. There is no bigger bully in the world than the US Army and all those who help them. The fact that people on the left or right don't speak about that tells me that people just believe what they are brainwashed to believe by those higher up which is why arguing over this stuff is futile.
Identity politics will be the death of Western civilization. It was better when we all saw an individual as an individual instead of breaking down if there's enough diversity present. I saw an advertisement for my college with a pic of 5 white boys just chilling with the caption "students love it here." Keep in mind there's multiple of these ads with various students. 5 years ago my thought woulda just been "okay people chilling, that one probably slays" but now my first thought is "oh God I already know at least one comment" and surely enough one comment is someone bitching about diversity just cause there's a picture of 5 white boys together. Our society is broken.
The right has lots of idiots too but things were still fine up until 2012. Now everything seems to be heading towards a direction of being very politically and demographically charged. Didn't bother me at the end of the day if some moron on the right doesn't understand that there's no such thing as pure 100% capitalism or why the statement "you can only have equal opportunity not equal outcomes" is a moronic idealistic stance. To have equal opportunity you need to rearrange outcomes to a certain extent but not so much so that the incentive to rise to the top diminishes. That stupid stance also breaks down when you consider more than one generation. Conversely on the left people think if outcomes aren't exactly equal by the parameters they define that it is oppression. There are extreme segments of the right but generally they are vilified by society and no one would dare express those stances in public without consequences. The extreme side on the left filled with their vitriol seems a lot more open to express themselves publicly which is dangerous. Also, not white.
[deleted]
Dr. CASH Cr. TAX PAYABLE Cr. INTEREST REVENUE
This is just a form of interest income, it's from lending money, just like a loan overdraft is a SERVICE provided by BANKS for people who need money for their bills. A completely legitimate form of income and overdraft is necessary for many people especially when living outside your means, a completely legitimate and non-exploitive revenue stream.
Should be taxed at whatever rate interest revenue would be, likely corporate. I'm in Canada and here there would be no capital gain or dividend this is business income from operations because it's a bank, taxes as such. If the fee isnt a percentage and a fixed amount than it would be overdraft fee revenue, still a income stream subject to the same taxes.
It's either revenue or an expense. Looks like income. Boom.
[deleted]
They should have to make it opt-in I think.
I mean, it technically is opt-in when you sign all that paperwork to open an account.
Technically but I'd argue its not a choice in a practical sense because can you really even live without a bank account?
"I for one, believe that everyone should be able to charge whatever they want on their debit cards, whether or not any money actually exists in their accounts, for eternity with out any penalty like a credit card with 0% interest."
I get why fees exist, and I even agree that they can exist “morally”, but let’s not pretend that the banks couldn’t just cancel overdraft privileges for someone with an average account value of $20. I
To be honest her argument isn't completely off base it's just the "in your faceness" of it while providing no solutions and honestly being unrealistic. Her tweet is just a clout chase for followers. In my opinion overdraft fees should work off of the charge amount. Charge like a 5% on the total dollar amount over, so for like $20 charge $1 in fees. This prevents people charging couches with no money in their account while not screwing over someone who bought a pack of gum with $.50 in their account.
And why would they do that if they can make billions every year on something that’s based on people being financially smart? Not the bank’s fault some people are careless
I take it you're a big fan of payday loans too.
With exception to auto-pay Billings (which if your financial situation is not good, those shouldn’t be on anyway), overdraft fees are related to people being careless with the money they have (usually).
Payday loans I don’t like because the businesses that do that are intentionally manipulative and market it in a scummy way.
Plus there’s lots of ways to avoid overdraft fees.
I am. I enjoy the karmic retribution of when stupid people are taken advantage of.