Getting away from cartridges.

Help/Advice

Hello,

I’m looking at getting back into the fish keeping hobby and recently for my birthday I received a Marineland Portrait 5g. I know sometimes that starter kits are a touchy subject, but for the space requirements I have, it’s perfect.

I’ve been watching a lot of videos from Aquarium Co-op, and Pondguru on YouTube about filtration and the such. I’ve decided to not use the cartridge system in the aquarium and take Cory’s advice where he said place a coarse filter sponge in place of the cartridge. But I was wondering if I could take it a step further and add a thin medium sponge behind that, and then place some filter media in a bag and have that around the pump – I was considering Biohome Ultimate for the media.

Would this work? Would y’all do anything differently? And what should I look out for when attempting this? I am planning on making this a planted tank and stocking it with ember tetras and amano shrimp.

Thanks!

Posted Dec 27, 2019, 5:37 PM UTC

14
Flleeaa•

Honestly, I’d consider getting an Aquqclear filter. There a HOB filter that is super easy to set up. It comes in many different sizes and a filter sponge, activated carbon, and some filter media are included. They do a great job of filtering, id def consider one of these.

5
d8ne4m6•

It's up to you how to fill AIO back chambers. Some like foam, one or two grades, others use piece of disposable filter floss on top of it, it's cheap and easy to replace. Only small piece of sponge is necessary to support floss, leaving more space for everything else.

Below, if space allows, could be chemical media: purigen and acivated carbon, in mesh bags instead of cartridges. Below them biomeda, any of them should work, sinthered glass small sized biomedia could take less space with the same surface are for nitrifying bacteria.

Above the pump heater is usually placed, but I had others, not Portrait, AIO tanks.

There are also plate shaped biomedia, like MarinePure, it could be easily cut to the size and doesn't need a bag, just flow through it.

2
ReximussOP•

Thanks, what I’ll probably do is cut some foam and see how I can Tetris it in there. Then add the biomedia.

1

I just stuff my hob filters with polyfill stuffing. A single bag has lasted me three years with a dozen aquariums.

2