Is Burrows the 1.1 in SF drafts as a Bengal? What about Tua if he goes to Miami?

Rookie

Are they the 1.1 and 1.2 respectively (assuming Tua gets drafted early still) or does Tua slide way down rookie drafts?

Posted Dec 28, 2019, 7:36 AM UTC

1544
edcolombo127•

Burrow is in the conversation for 1.01 but it depends on team needs imo if you don't need a qb then try to trade back or just draft top rb in the best situation or whichever top 2 wr you believe in most. As for Tua, every thing depends on how his health and how reports of his recovery go. I think it's just as likely we (dolphins fan) go into the season with Fitz at qb than we are to draft a qb early. A healthy Tua should imo be a top 5 pick in a superflex league

14
[deleted]•

Need should be ignored during rookie drafts, just draft the best/most valuable player available, you can then trade that excess value to fill your needs. QBs will always carry a good amount of value in SF leagues and are a good investment no matter how many you already have, especially a young QB with great potential like Burrow.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1†
[deleted]•

What happens when the RB you reach on because you "need it" busts, and the superior WR you passed on goes on to be a star? It goes both ways.

The options in a rookie draft are far more volatile than in a startup draft and some years is lopsided to a particular position, but it's your only opportunity each year to bring in new assets to the team. You need to get the most value you can out of those picks, and it's not always going to align with your immediate needs. If you draft a WR despite already being deep at that position, you can use that depth to shop around to an owner who needs WR help and get what you need.

5
edcolombo127•

In general yeah but the question was the top pick in this year's draft which I believe is so loaded with talent at the top that you can pick a guy like swift/Taylor or jeudy/lamb at 1.01 with no issues if their landing spots are good enough. Burrow should definitely be in the conversation for 1.01 but that's exactly why you don't really need draft to trade, you can literally cover almost any glaring hole in your team needs with what is assumed to be instant production in those top guys.

That being said if you can flip the 1.01 for a proven top tier player then yes by all means that will almost always be worth it

1
Birdmane19•

Always go BPA, just like most professional teams during the draft process. Drafting for need is short sighted and a recipe for failure.

2
eflin202•

I expect Miami to draft a QB but keep Fitz around for a year to let the rookie develop. They might start the rookie towards the end of the year just to test the waters and give them some experience but it makes a lot of sense for them to keep Fitz for another year

3
Kkfootball18•

We should just wait till 2021 man

1
jdhepner•

If Tuas meds look good he’s the (relatively) easy 1.01 in SF for me

7
RoyGood•

People keep saying this but what does it really mean? There is a difference between being medically cleared to play and viewed as by NFL teams versus having no long term damage as a result of the injury. I am rooting for him 100% and was my 1.01 before this injury but the severity of the injury and potential long term impact on his career have me worried. The fact is the injury is so uncommon that we simply have no idea how anyone would recover and if they could continue such high level play.

1
Demaru•

I have the 1.02 so if Burrow falls to me I'll take him but otherwise I'm happy to take Swift.

7
darksideofdagoon•

Same here , my logic exactly

2
1197th•

Burrow would be my 1.01, but I could see somebody taking an RB instead. DO NOT take a WR over Burrow.

6
nubianjoker•

Why not a wr like lamb or jeudy?

3
Ham_PhD•

Not sure his logic entirely. I guess value in early seasons of RBs is generally higher than WRs.

Jeudy and Lamb are the top 2 players on my board in terms of talent so id say they could be 1.01 if you wanted.

9
[deleted]•

RBs carry the most immediate value and return on investment the majority of the time, it's very likely that you could acquire Jeudy or Lamb a year from now for a RB drafted after them, and get something extra in return.

5
1197th•

I like both guys, but I feel that neither guy is generational talents. They are regular sized receivers (maybe smaller when they weigh in at the combine aming other things) with solid, but not spectacular speed. They have a ton of good traits (I think both will test very well in agility drills) that should make them good, but they arent bust proof prosects in the way a guy like Julio or Clowney is. To be clear, not being bust proof doesnt mean they cant be the best receiver in the league one day.

I specifically used Clowney as an example. While he hasnt quite lived up to the hype he had entering the league, he is a perennial pro bowler and impact player based on his athleticism alone. Lamb/Jeudy dont have that trump card.

A rb with a clear path to the starting role will start for at least 2 years in most instances (see David Montgomery, Lindsay screwed Freeman). A guy like Fournette who I personally think is not good, is approaching not just year four as a starter, but year four as a workhorse, 3 down back.

A leage average qb (im betting om Borrow becoming at least that) is worth so much in SF, both guys would have to be top 5 wrs in the league to make it worth taking them over him.

1
aforehan18•

little late to this discussion post but how do you compare Higgins to these guys. While Ruggs and Lavishka get a lot of hype, i think Higgins has the best shot to dethrones lamb or jeudy as this class’ top WR (long term).

1
roodypoo_jabroni•

I'm hoping people keep comparing Tua's injury to Bo Jackson's injury so he falls and I can draft him late.

Same injury I understand that, but the major difference between Tua and Jackson's injury IMO is that A) Jackson popped his hip back in by himself and not a medical professional. And B) he didn't tell anyone about it till way later so the damage had already been done.

4
MecoleScottOP•

And 30 years of medical science ha. I agree with you on the Bo comparison being overblown.

9
roodypoo_jabroni•

True dat. Haha. Sports medicine has advanced eons in those 30 years

5
edcolombo127•

That's not the difference, Bo Jackson suffered from Avascular necrosis as a complication of his injury. It's where the veins stretch or tear and the bone loses its blood source. He also developed hip arthritis which lead to a full hip replacement. Avascular necrosis has already been ruled out for Tua. He can still develop arthritis but the severity is what we should look out for. All In all it will be a few years until we really know the severity of this injuries long term effects

3
roodypoo_jabroni•

I know what Avascular Necrosis is but thank you for mansplaining it for me! He developed that due to the fact that he tore his vessels when HE popped his hip back into place. That's like me doing open heart surgery. I think I'll leave things like that to professionals.

Do you have a source that says Avascular Necrosis has been ruled out for Tua? I know his chances severely diminished due to the timing of him getting medical attention, but I haven't seen anywhere saying that there's no chance he develops it. It's my understanding that it takes 4-6 months after the injury before you can tell.

-5
edcolombo127•

I'm sorry I didn't mean to offend you and I certainly wasn't trying to mansplain, my only intent to was clarify why Bo Jackson was forced to retire and how it was different to Tuas situation which I wasn't sure you were aware of from your post. As far as im aware there is no evidence of exactly what caused Bo Jackson's Avascular necrosis but I can see how it's likely he did it when he popped his hip back in.

As for Tua getting it you are right it takes anywhere from 8 hours to a few months after trauma to begin to show signs. I definitely spoke too soon when I said it was ruled out, his injury was reduced on the field and his chances of getting it are less than 5 percent but that is still a 5 percent chance so I shouldn't have spoken so assuredly. Sorry again for any misunderstanding or miscommunication on my end

2
roodypoo_jabroni•

No worries. I misunderstood your comment my apologies. Rereading my initial comment I should have clarified more on my end.

You're correct in no one knows why Bo developed Avascular Necrosis, but I firmly believe it was due to the fact that he put his hip back into place and in doing so tore the veins feeding the bone and didn't tell anyone about it till months later after the bone had basically died already.

I am in no way a medical professional so take what I say with a grain of salt, but any dislocation is something very serious and if not put back into place in the proper way can lead to more major issues down the road even if it's something as small as a pinkie finger on your non throwing hand.

Tua on the other hand had what I would assume to be one of the better sports medicine teams in college football tend to him immediately after. He could very well develop arthritis as you said down the road still.

Come draft time though of he's taken Top 10 I see no reason why he shouldn't be at very very least be Top 3 in SF leagues. People can take Swift/Dobbins/Taylor ahead of him if that fits their needs better IMO. But for him to drop any further would be ludicrous IMO.

0
BillyScrimshaw•

Burrow is the easy call here. He appears to have it all.

The Bengals o-line was improving late in the season - Mixon benefitted quite a bit from it down the stretch. AJ Green should be healthy. Boyd in the slot again with A. Tate on the other side. Cincinnati is not so bad a landing spot as a lot of other 1st overall QBs have seen.

And again, Burrow looks like the total package. Accurate, mobile, secure yet aggressive, makes the right reads, size, release/throwing motion, you name it.

Edit: spelling

2
roodypoo_jabroni•

Yeah the guy is annihilating the Sooners D right now! 4 tds in the first half alone.

1
Birdmane19•

Did John Ross die?

1
eclipse1022•

for fantasy purposes, yes.

2
BillyScrimshaw•

He's the 4th WR option at best. His role is situational deep threat and little else if the others are all healthy. Burrow's success will not come down to John Ross.

1
barefootBam•

Dude after this first half. It's Burrows and it's not even close lol. Coming into that team with a healthy AJ Green and Boyd. That offense is going to be explosive

2
JJsFantasyWorld•

Depends on your team makeup. If you need a QB, I don’t see a problem with it.

It’ll be hard for me to pass up on Jeudy or Lamb if the Cardinals draft either though (especially Lamb).

1
migs2k3•

Given the injury I'm not touching Tua until the 2nd rd. I'll dare everyone else to draft him first. Which is a shame because he was the slam dunk QB #1 and likely 1.01 pre-injury

1
BillyScrimshaw•

I think my line is mid-1st, but the sentiment is mutual. The risk is too great at 1.02.

2
Jaydavus•

In super flex very unlikely he goes to the 2nd. I know that's your price, but for people here if you want Tua and have a mid or late 1st go with him there.

Just saying that won't be his market price if a team wants him expect to use a mid 1st in super flex.

1
migs2k3•

Long time between now and rookies drafts lots can happen that can drop his draft stock.

  1. Doesn't go in the 1st rd

  2. Poor medical reports

  3. Won't play in 2020

  4. Bad landing spot

That's all enough to drop him behind the other big 4 QB.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Flash_Gordon_•

Burrow yes, Tua no but he’ll be top 5 for me

1
bosnian_red•

Have the 1.01, not taking a QB. Going to take the best RB pick. Have Russ Wilson, Baker Mayfield, Daniel Jones and Teddy Bridgewater... dont need another young QB. For WRs have Michael Thomas, AJ Brown, Deebo, Terry Mclaurin, Anthony Miller, Manny Sanders and Brandin Cooks. So feel like I'm pretty set there too. Need a top producing running back.

0
jnmaniac1•

Trade back in that case. I'd go to the 1.02-1.05, as there will be many similar tier RBs in that range you can grab in Swift, Taylor, Etienne, Dobbins, etc. You can still get your guy and gain a lot of value from someone really in need of Burrow.

12
xctrack07•

This is the correct answer

1
DF1212•

I’m in same boat, SF and I have 1.01 along with mahomes, Baker, Tannenhill, Cam. What’s an appropriate return for the 1.01 when dropping back to 1.02-1.05ish?

1
bosnian_red•

Really dont think I'd have much to gain. We'll see what the offers are like closer to the draft but as of now everyone in my league is more hyped for the RBs and WRs, and the teams with high picks arent desperate enough for a QB to need to take one at 1.01.

1
Birdmane19•

Take advantage of this and double down on QBs. In every SF league I’ve been apart of they value after the startup and it keeps increasing, especially after all the QB injuries this year

1
Birdmane19•

This is a mistake

1