r/Coffee•
bigemike76

Barista Express Extraction Question

I am on a #1 grind with the time set at 6pm, the grounds complete overflow the double shot basket. I tamp them down and I am getting about 11 clock on the pressure meter.

I feel like the grind might still not be fine enough? Or I am not tamping hard enough? It seems weird that I need to have that much coffee overflow the basket to make a double shot.

​

Any tips?

Posted Dec 30, 2019, 3:03 PM UTC

412
speccoroSpeccoro•

Don’t go by the timer. Weigh out the beans first and then put them into the hopper, grind until empty.

2
bigemike76OP•

Is this just to dial in the grind, I don't have any interest in weighing out beans every time I grind. I am not a perfectionist with this, I just want a to pull a good consistant shot.

-4
speccoroSpeccoro•

It’s what I do every time and what many here will recommend. I suppose you could use it to dial it in, get the timer set such that it ends as the last of the weighted beans is ground up.

You’ll likely have to recalibrate it when you change coffees though.

And while it sounds tedious, it takes all of 3 seconds to weigh out the beans— it’s not as much of a fuss as it sounds

3
PhantomA12•

The thing is if you want to pull "good consistent shots" weighing is the easiest and more necessary thing to achieve that. You can't get consistency when the amount of coffee you put in changes every time. Just not going to happen.

3
MyCatsNameIsBernieCappuccino•

The advantage of weighing the beans first instead of using the timer is that you can grind until the portafilter is full, stop, tap the portafilter on a hard surface to compress the ground coffee a bit, then finish grinding. This will prevent grinds from overflowing the portafilter.

As others have said, there is no way you will be able to get a consistent shot by using the grind timer.

1
Bohjio•

Other posts indicate that the automatic dosing on the Barista express isn’t very good.

Read this https://www.reddit.com/r/Coffee/comments/81jy6b/a_noobs_journey_with_a_breville_barista_express/

You could also have stale beans. When were your beans roasted and how dark? Stale beans or super dark roasts can tend to cause below.

2
mylstogo•

I was in the same boat as you, but soon realized that consistency can only be achieved once the variables are controlled. I’ve had the BBE for a little over 2 months now and the one thing I’ve come to realize is that the dose control is pretty useless. Sometimes, on back to back shots, I get a difference of 1-1.5g at the same setting and fineness.

I weigh out my grinds before pulling my shot every time. It adds a few extra seconds, but it’s worth it because now my shots are fairly consistent with all other variables unchanged.

I’m still nerding out on the science of it all and trying to WDT before pulling my shots, changing temps, etc. But overall, when I return settings to what I had dialed into, I know what to expect of my espresso because I’m being consistent with what I’m putting in.

My suggestion is to weigh out your grounds before every shot, but program the actual pull so that you get your desired ratio and don’t have to keep looking at a stop watch.

P.S. I’m using Lavazza Super crema, manufactured mid November, fineness at 2. 18g in, 45g out in about 43 seconds (with preinfusion) and default temp. This gets me, what I consider, a tasty shot every single time.

2
docmn612•

When I grind 18g for a double shot in the Sette, I do have to shake the grinds around so they set and don't overflow. When I used the attached BE grinder, they did always over flow. I dunno if the BE portafilter is small or what.

1
orcriss•

I've been on number 3 grind and 1PM on the timer to deliver 18 grams. There is a little overflow but not much, and I get a consistent 12 noon on the pressure gauge. I'm really a stickler for freshly roasted beans though. I rarely have any get more than 3 weeks old.

1
BrandenRage•

11 on the pressure meter is fine. How is the taste?

Have the same machine.

1
bigemike76OP•

its good, I was more worried about the mess of grinds, but its not alot and I can deal with it, just seems my settings are extreme. But the shot is good, might try to back it off and tamp it harder, I wasn't using much force dialing it in

-1
BrandenRage•

Tamping harder wont do much. Just tamp it so it does not fall out when you hold it up side down. Tamping pressure does not do anything.

Google tamping pressure research.

2