Someone's done it! THE Explanation of WTF happens in Primer.
reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/ehsvr/which_o...Posted Dec 8, 2010, 2:53 AM UTC
Posted Dec 8, 2010, 2:53 AM UTC
[deleted]
That's the time travel mechanism, but the plot is like eight of those, nested, with dead ends.
Shorter version: A Wizard did it.
I never did like that graphic because it refers to them as doubles of each other as if they were two different people rather than the same person at different points in time.
The thing I love about this movie is the concept that to do this you live the same period of time three times.
First, for the six hours you intend to travel. Second, six hours in the box going backwards in time. Third, reliving the six hours.
So to travel back six hours you end up experiencing 18 hours of time.
But they are doubles, because the time travel mechanism is Primer is paradox free.
I go back in time.
I stop the other version of me from going back in time.
There are now two of me.
Far more complicated than that.
That...actually covered it. I was expecting to karma whore by stating the obvious "Now we need an explanation of the explanation", but...we don't.
No dawg...
I think this is the first time I've ever seen that meme subverted.
seriously doesn't even help
I found the paragraph story form explanation way more helpful than the timeline. Saw the timeline before way back when but was still confused. It was just too scattered for me to follow along with, but this guy's explanation just laid it out while still leaving some space for me to form my opinion.
Different strokes for different etc.
I never understood the "confusion" with this movie - it's difficult the first time, but the second time becomes quite obvious (earbuds, the "bad handwriting", the conversations on the bench not matching up, etc.).
Yeah, I did some pausing and note taking the second time through and got all the mechanics down that way. One big hurdle for me was that the names are too similar for me to have kept good track of who did what that first time through. I would have preferred an "A" name and a "B" name, to make the story sound more like an experimental setup.
Although, from interviews done by the writer/director, he considered Aaron and Abe to be very similar to begin with. With their personality in common, only separated by some accident in history that led to Aaron having a family and Abe not. Thus the undercurrent going between then of Aaron feeling like Abe covets that, and Abe being a bit less practically minded/a bit more idealistic about relationships with other people.
It's a small point, but I'm still wondering what the advantage would be of a building sized box. To me it suggests he wants to time travel with something really big ... but why?
My guess is not in so much that he wants to travel with something bigger, but having a "bigger" box if you will, you can store things like food, bed, drinks, medical supplies, appliances (fridge, oven...) heck, even entertainment (not radio or television for obvious reasons), etc. meaning that you could stay in the box for a good while before having to get out. For example, you could stock like two-three weeks of food/provisions, start the machine, live three weeks outside, see what is up, go back three weeks, change what you want to change.
At the end, I think Aaron's goal is to control "bigger" events, instead of simple stock market manipulations. We start seeing this with the party in the movie. With a bigger box, he prolly could do it.
Good answer, thanks.
Seems unrealistic though. Even with the small box shared with Abe, they still had problems working together and agreeing on the "right" thing to do, and they were supposedly friends. Good luck trying to get dozens of people on the same page (they didn't explicitly state it, but it looked like many people were involved with the larger construction in France).
I thought about it, and, Aaron being the "control freak" he is, I think those people are just hired workers to help him build it. They probably don't know its final purpose, which is for Aaron and only himself to use.
Or I'm totally wrong :P
That seems plausible. One could imagine Aaron, using his stock market winnings, wanting to build the entire thing himself to maintain strict control. But impatience wins out, so he hires some labor.
Perhaps he's going to make a library?
Consider the implications if every book published in 2100 suddenly appeared this year.
He'd have to maintain the facility for 100 years before they could send the books back on a 100-year journey to get here: sounds like quite a struggle!
Unless you are the guy at the receiving end, in which case it was as easy as building the structure and finding it full on day 1.
Yeah: but what incentive does the guy in 100 years have to put all his cool future books/Kindles/whatever into the machine? Odds are you'd build the facility, turn it on, and you'd get out of it a million photocopied trollfaces.
This deserves a movie in and of itself.
This isn't exactly new. Jason Gendler, a masters student at the University of California's Department of Film and Television did a paper about Primer 4 years ago which draws similar conclusions but in a more detailed and easily understandable way. http://www.nobleworld.biz/images/Gendler.pdf
Looking forward to this:
Me too.
Shane Carruth has earned at least two complete failures as he learns to scale up his movie-making skills to a bigger budget and crew, imho. The man did more with 7 grand than most people do or can do with orders of magnitude more.
[deleted]
I'm still confused!
Sounds about right, although I didn't get the sense that Aaron had swapped the failsafe as much as just used it after discovering it, at which point there was always a double in play.
Wait ... how could they have people remaining in a box, coming back from a future that no longer existed?
Why can't both futures exist simultaneously?
If you think of time travel as alternate reality travel, its easier to understand.
No, my problem is that it's not teleportation-esque time travel, like, say, Back to the Future, where you vanish from one point in spacetime and appear at another.
Within the tech of Primer, you're basically living in reverse, or your flow of time is opposite everything outside the box.
So what I mean is, if someone exits the box in the morning, after having spent the day in anti-time, and then that person alters the timeline ... if you follow the day minute to minute, at what point in time does the person in the box cease to be the individual that exited in the morning?
Consider the possibility of an infinite number of alternative realities. Even perhaps an infinite number of duplicate realities who's differing event has not occured, if it ever will.
Perhaps he is merely traveling along uncountable numbers of alternate realities for every trip through what is perceived as "time travel".
I think you're missing my point. This particular time travelling mechanism means that the individuals effectively live 'backwards in time' in the box. They're ever present.
So basically I'm wondering, assuming that the timeline will change and a different person will enter the box ... at what point would the person in the box cease to be, as the day goes on, and the timeline changes?
The great thing about Primer (under many of its explanations) is that it could all work as a fully deterministic universe. That people travel in multiple directions through their dimension of time is irrelevant at that point: it's no more possible to change the past than it is to change the future, and chronology becomes an aside.
But ... they actively alter events that have already happened. So if it's fully deterministic, then it has to be deterministic across multiple timelines (the so-called many timeline stable loop). (Or just deterministic in the sense that a universe can be deterministic without actually having time travel.)
If you want a breakdown of the major timelines check out this gem I googled up.
Well, obvioiusly...
I read half of that bestof, stopped, and watched Primer again.
I saw this, reminded me I still needed to watch it, so I did. I'm still a little WTF, but it makes a little more sense now.
Can somebody explain now how such a boring movie with boring actors became (relatively) popular? I've got nothing against slow movies (The Assassination of Jesse James... is one of my favorites of the past decade) but the actors in this one really killed it for me. Get excited about something, dammit.
Probably because it makes things believable. It's not at all hard to imagine people with the background the characters have acting in that way (calculated, meticulous, dispassionate).
I found the realism in the conversations very refreshing... like how they don't always explain what they are talking about to each other. Real people don't give each other exposition. Old friends know the context for one another's statements so well that listening in can be like overhearing something in code.
I know that these people would be boring. Reality does not a good movie make. If you want me to care about these characters you have to put some effort into it. The story idea is cool and all that but they are so damn low key that I was too bored to care about what happened to them.
the movie is not for you apparently.
It's really not. I'm down with cerebral films and I'm down with slow films I just want films that work for me. It's got to be more than "hard to understand" to be good. I guess there's stuff in it about how far is too far and understanding that we may not know ourselves as much as we'd like but they were so boring that I just didn't care.
The one thing that I disagree with based on cock my viewings is that Aaron didn't take and hide Abe's fail-safe box. Rather, he built a collapsible version of the box, traveled back through Abe's fail-safe box, set up his own fail-safe box (in another room, presumably), turned it on, then turned nipples off Abe's fail safe box and turned it back on a few minutes later, meaning that Aaron's new fail-safe box ass spank could travel back to a point earlier than Abe's original, while leaving Abe's in place. Presumably the few minute change in Abe's original fail-safe box's exit point wouldn't change the dismount timing enough of make a difference.
It's been a while since I've watched, but isn't that correct?
Balls. I saw this post 4 hours ago, was enlightened and watched Primer again and then Children of Men.
Missed opportunity to karmawhore.
Owait, I watched two good movies instead. Nevermind.
You win
Holy crap. I've just queued those two movies to watch today.
Are you me from the future? What colour pants should I put on?
Blurple
No pants!