r/zen•
mojo-power

Not Buddhism, not meditation? Or not Zen?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zen

  1. Zen is a school of Mahayana Buddhism
  2. The term Zen is derived from the Japanese pronunciation of the Middle Chinese word 禪 (Chán), which traces its roots to the Indian practice of dhyāna ("meditation").
  3. Zen emphasizes rigorous meditation-practice.
  4. The practice of dhyana or meditation, especially sitting meditation (Japanese: zazen) is a central part of Zen Buddhism.

Zen is basically a buddhist school, based on meditation techniques, taken from Yogacara, with world view inlfuenced with Taoism.

It's wikipedia. Or we have a more reliable member of our community to say what it is and what it isn't?

Posted Jan 1, 2020, 4:36 PM UTC

2157
country__zensōtō•

"It depends on what your definition of 'is' is." ~ Bill Clinton

11
LurkersimL👀K!•

Much to to the dismay to those noting how often I link to wikipedia my view of zen is completely detached from it. I see two forms of binding nicely presented here (eventually) that have no validity when it comes to what zen, at it's best, is: Pointing directly as possible at valid dharmic truth. Just an opinion, of course. Like everything presented regarding zen and its expedients. That said, I wish you a lively and insight provoking discussion.

6
mojo-powerOPyeshe chölwa•

I see how many people are confused with this stuff. I don't say I know what it is about - nobody really does. But it's definitely not about "everything is already fine". That's a New Age, not meditation. Zen masters spoke to people advanced in everyday practice, explaining them defilements in pure things. But those people were aware of their previous blindness, they cured the diseases of their eyes. If a person see things - there is no need to say that meditation isn't the point. But for many here it's a food they can't digest.

0†
LurkersimL👀K!•

Meditation has some dangerous pitfalls within it. It can definitively speed the journey but is also filled with byroads and focal traps. Bankei wouldn't be Bankei without his scarred ass and black phlegm but he worked towards sparing others scarred asses. I used it up to a point and return to it to get past a point. I feel the cautions are necessary and the knowledge of the form necessary.

But, that's just my opinion, man. 🧔🏼

5
mojo-powerOPyeshe chölwa•

That's true, the "deep pit of liberation", the "meditation sickness", the "intoxication by the wine of pure things". There are a lot of things one should be aware of in meditation. Still it doesn't mean that "Zen masters rejected meditation" and that's the only thing I wanted to say. Though probably I overestimated my abilities with this post, that's true too.

1
LurkersimL👀K!•

It's fine.

That said, I wish you a lively and insight provoking discussion.

1
[deleted]•

Who is this projection you argue against?

3
[deleted]•

Think back to when you woke up this morning and those few precious thoughts that came up before you started thinking about reddit and pwning people on it ... that's the "ordinary mind."

You weren't meditating because you don't need meditation to access it.

Wikipedia can say whatever it wants, why are you going to wikipedia for something that is right in front of your face?

It's like standing by a window and being like "hmmm I wonder what the weather is outside, better look it up on my smart phone."

3
mojo-powerOPyeshe chölwa•

So what do you need to access it then? If you need nothing - what's the point of Zen? Ever heard about anyone, who heard words like these and found a relief? Have you found it? Can you say that you have the same level of understanding like the master you like? If not - what you're going to do? Look at the window or use moments when you woke up? Are you aware that all masters quoted here had monasteries full of monks, who meditated most of their time? What for they did it?

1
[deleted]•

what's the point of Zen?

Indeed. This question was touched on several times. It's a pretty popular theme.

Asking the question didn't (doesn't) stop thousands of students wandering about looking for Zen regardless.

It was out of compassion that the Masters chose to give people turning words.

Ever heard about anyone, who heard words like these and found the relief?

On the one hand: no one. It doesn't go "Words -> 'relief' " (and I quote "relief" because I'm not agreeing that's the goal I'm just giving you the benefit of the doubt because it maybe could be phrased that way).

Did you?

Sure. I mean, again, I didn't go Words -> "seeing" it went Words -> me -> seeing ... or something like that.

Can you say that you have the same level of understanding like the master you like?

"Same" is tricky. Am I on here spinning one-word zingers to the delight of the monks like Zhaozhou?

Haha obviously not.

Do I feel like I get what Zhaozhou is saying most of the time?

Yeah.

Do I feel an unspoken experiential bond with the Masters?

Yes.

Can you do anything about that?

No.

If not - what you're going to do? Look at the window or use moments when you woke up?

Yes.

1
[deleted]•

Oh it's this post again ...

3
Jaethrandir•

Hey now, be fair. I havent seen one of these since last decade.

3
[deleted]•

Hey dad, I'm hungry XD

2
GhostC1pher•

What do you really want?

2
origin_unknown"Troll" defender•

Wikipedia is not a good PRIMARY source. It may lead to some, sure.

Anyone with proper credentials can edit a wikipedia page, and the credentials aren't even that "proper" to be honest. I'm pretty sure I have an old login to wikipedia that would allow me to contribute to articles, if I was even interested in digging that login up.

The zen entry on wikipedia was changed almost 150 times last year alone.
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Zen&action=history

2
ewk•
  1. Wikipedia is so obviously amateurish and illiterate sometimes that the contrast is shocking. If you want to know what "Mahayana Buddhists" believe, you are out of luck. If you want to know what Baptists believe, somebody who edits wikipedia actually knows: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baptists

  2. Dhyana never meant meditation, that's an obvious mistranslation: r/zen/wiki/dhyana There isn't any evidence that Zen Masters taught any specific sitting meditation practice. There isn't any evidence that meditation played a role in enlightenment.

  3. Wikipedia doesn't seem to know what "Buddhism" is either.

2
mojo-powerOPyeshe chölwa•

Wikipedia isn't reliable source in regard to Zen - I agree, but it doesn't make your claim that meditation was not the main practice of all Zen masters somehow more proven. That's what they did - the masters you quote - Mazu, Linji, Huangbo - they spent their life practicing sitting meditation. Ande, well, wasn't it the page you created where you say "Dhyana Doesn't Mean Meditation", when jhana - literally - translates as meditation?

3
ewk•

I have repeatedly quoted Zen Masters saying meditation wasn't anything to do with Zen.

Huineng, the last Zen Patriarch, questioned why anyone would practice sitting meditation in a famous poem he wrote and recited for his followers.

Zhaozhou, most famous of all Zen Masters, openly implied that sitting meditation was dead and that Zen was alive.

Dhyana never meant meditation. D.T. Suzuki wrote a book about it.

It seems like you want to repeat what you heard in church about Jesus inventing meditation to tame the dinosaurs, but you can't quote Zen Masters.

 Why can't you quote Zen Masters?

I think I hear a troll choking on the other side of door he closed on himself.

2
RottenCynicist•

I have repeatedly quoted Zen Masters saying meditation wasn't anything to do with Zen.

I promise you're misunderstanding the intended meanings of these quotes.

Huineng, the last Zen Patriarch, questioned why anyone would practice sitting meditation in a famous poem he wrote and recited for his followers.

"The Platform Sutra of the Sixth Patriarch" is attributed to Huineng. It has an entire section devoted to concentration meditation:

https://www.bdkamerica.org/system/files/pdf/dBET_T2008_PlatformSutra_2000_0.pdf?file=1&type=node&id=467

That being said, nobody is really certain of much when it comes to Huineng. Pretty much everything we know about him comes from the Platform Sutra, which itself is of questionable origin.

Zhaozhou, most famous of all Zen Masters, openly implied that sitting meditation was dead and that Zen was alive.

No, he did not. He implied meditation itself is alive.

  • Someone asked the teacher Zhaozhou, “What is meditation?” Zhaozhou replied, “It’s not meditation.” The student was puzzled. “Why is it not meditation?” “It’s alive! It’s alive!”

This is a warning to avoid becoming caught on rigid forms and concepts. The response "It's not meditation" is given to someone asking what meditation is. This is intended to say that the living, ever fluctuating practice of meditation wasn't identical with the common conceptualization of meditation. He isn't saying that meditation is dead. In fact, he's referring to meditation when he says "It's alive! It's alive!!!"

  • Zhaozhou ascended the hall rostrum and spoke: "Brothers! Don't stand for too long. If there are problems, discuss them. If there are no issues, it's better to sit by your robe and alms bowl to understand the principle exhaustively.

"Sit by your robes and alms bowl to understand the principle exhaustively" is another way of saying "meditate on the principle to fully understand it". 

  • "When the mind is singularly not arisen, without fault are the ten-thousand dharmas. To understand the principle exhaustively, sit for twenty or thirty years, and if you still don't understand, you can cut off this old monk's (Zhaozhou's) head."

I highly doubt he would suggest meditating on a principle for twenty years if he was opposed to the act of meditation.

There's also many passages in the Recorded Sayings of Zhaozhou that are prefaced with statements like "When Zhaozhou had completed his seated meditation...".

These statements give the impression that sitting meditation was an important part of Zhaozhou's practice.

Dhyana never meant meditation. D.T. Suzuki wrote a book about it.

The word has the same meaning in Buddhism as it does in the Brahmanic traditions that Gautama the Buddha learned the practice from.

"Dhyana" doesn't literally translate to "meditation". However, the concept is tied heavily to meditation practice. The assertion that there's no connection between dhyana and the meditation practices taught by Gautama the Buddha is ludicrous.

It seems like you want to repeat what you heard in church about Jesus inventing meditation to tame the dinosaurs, but you can't quote Zen Masters.

Why can't you quote Zen Masters?

I can, and I have, but I shouldn't have bothered. Treating Zen masters as irrefutable authorities goes against their teachings.

Here's Huangbo:

  • "Above all it is essential not to select some particular teaching suited to a certain occasion, and, being impressed by its forming part of the written canon, regard it as an immutable concept. Why so? Because in truth there is no unalterable Dharma which the Tathāgata could have preached. People of our sect would never argue that there could be such a thing. We just know how to put all mental activity to rest and thus achieve tranquillity. We certainly do not begin by thinking things out and end up in perplexity."

Asking for quotes of Zen masters and using them to make appeals to authority the way you are is something Zen masters adamantly opposed.

•••••••••

Aside from that, you don't see many direct mentions of meditation practice in the works of early Zen masters because those teachers relied on Buddhist sutras that already described the practice and its purpose in great detail.

Stating the fact that they were discussing Buddhism and clearly vocalizing the context of their writing isn't something they would've felt was necessary. It never occurred to them that a thousand years after they died, foreigners attempting to misappropriate their teachings would deny basic facts like their status as Buddhist monks in order to support misinterpretations of their works.

They never saw a need to directly state the fact that their writings deal with Buddhist doctrine. It'd be like one of us stopping to explain that we're on Reddit every thirty seconds.

3
ewk•

I got as far as your claim that Huineng had a section "devoted to seated meditation".

That's just not true, man. Stop lying.

Dhyana has no connection to sitting meditation. There is no evidence for that. Again, stop lying.

Huangbo warns people against sitting meditation. So tranquillity isn't achieved through sitting.

Stop lying.

0
mojo-powerOPyeshe chölwa•

You behave like religious fanatic, you know? With these anathemas and empty blames about choking and what I heard in church. Here is the quote I already gave you before:

Before the nine-part teaching had been expounded, living beings had no eyes; it was necessary to depend on someone to refine them. If you are speaking to a deaf worldling, you should just teach him to leave home, maintain discipline, practice meditation and develop wisdom. You should not speak this way to a worldling beyond measure, someone like Vimalakirti or the great hero Fu.

But you didn't offer quotes, you just mentioned some zen masters. Add quotes, so we can check what those masters really said, not how you understood it.

2
ewk•

Do you have the Chinese? Because I'm betting it says "practice dhyana". Which isn't meditation.

As I pointed out, https://www.reddit.com//r/zensangha/wiki/notmeditation

Either you have some trouble reading, or you aren't honest.

1
Jaethrandir•

Recently, as in this last month or so, I've seen you post a wikipedia page as a defense for one of your arguments.

How does this differ from you doing the same?

1
ewk•

Wikipedia is a big site... and the way it's managed is that specific people control specific parts of the site... so maybe you get somebody that knows lots about Baptists and that part of wikipedia is reliable, while the people who control the Zen pages are basically the same illiterate Buddhists who still list Richard Baker as a "master".

You have to verify the information on Wikipedia... it is a community encyclopedia, with a higher error rate than a real encyclopedia.

2
RottenCynicist•
  1. Wikipedia is so obviously amateurish and illiterate sometimes that the contrast is shocking. If you want to know what "Mahayana Buddhists" believe, you are out of luck.

If you read the works of Zen masters, it's obvious from quotes like this one that they're discussing Buddhist doctrine:

  • "Whoever realizes that the six senses aren’t real, that the five aggregates are fictions, that no such things can be located anywhere in the body, understands the language of Buddhas." ~ Bodhidarma

Trying to pretend he isn't discussing Buddhist principles is ludicrous.

The entirety of all Zen teachings is dependent on Buddhist doctrine and practice for context.

There isn't any evidence that Zen Masters taught any specific sitting meditation practice. There isn't any evidence that meditation played a role in enlightenment.

There's mountains of evidence that they advocated meditation.

There's direct quotes like these:

  • "When you practice mind-control, sit in the proper position, stay perfectly tranquil, and do not permit the least movement of your minds to disturb you. This alone is what is called liberation." ~ Huangbo "On The Transmission of Mind" page 131

  •  "In bygone days I devoted myself to the vinaya and also delved into the sutras and shastras. Later, when I realized that they were medicines for salvation and displays of doctrines in written words, I once and for all threw them away, and searching for the Way, I practised meditation." ~ Lin Chi

  • "Those who turn from delusion back to reality, who meditate on walls, the absence of self and other, the oneness of mortal and sage, and who remain unmoved even by scriptures are in complete and unspoken agreement with reason". ~ Bodhidarma

In addition to these direct quotes, core sutras found only within Zen, (Ex: "The Platform Sutra") also give specific instruction for meditation and explain it's role in Zen practice.

There's also the extensive commentaries given by Zen masters on Buddhist sutras such as the Lankavatara Sutra which advocate meditation practice.

Zen's intense focus on mindfulness and meditation practice is what distinguishes Zen from other schools of Buddhism according to Buddhist scholars. It's the defining attribute that makes Zen unique.

Denying meditation's central role in Zen practice requires totally disregarding the historical context surrounding the works of Zen masters and interpretting the statements of Zen masters in a way that's inconsistent with their stated views on practics.

To be clear, Zen masters advised against overeliance on any school of thought and taught that all forms of practice are merely tools used to expedite realization.

Zen masters explicitly stated that the forms provided by their teachings must not be confused for the essence those forms are intended to reveal. They rejected the idea that meditation was a transcendent, unequaled means to enlightenment. They said doing anything for the purpose of attaining enlightentment will make that thing act as a barrier to enlightenment.

However, it's a well-documented historical fact that these men were Buddhist monks who considered extensive meditation practice very fruitful, but only if approached with a certain attitude.

Zen masters taught nondiscrimination. They emphasized the necessity of abandoning dualistic thinking and reified mental concepts. To say they were either wholly committed to meditation practice or that they wholly rejected meditation practice is itself a dualistic conceptualization that fails to grasp Zen's nondualistic, nonconceptual way of thinking.

  1. Wikipedia doesn't seem to know what "Buddhism" is either.

Buddhism is a wide umbrella that encompasses a lot of different schools of thought. This forces wikipedia to speak in abstractions.

The generalized explanation provided in this entry:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhism

... is accurate as an overarching explanation of the umbrella.

You can also find adequate explanations of Buddhist doctrine found within the various schools if you know what you're looking for:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_truths_doctrine

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_marks_of_existence

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Noble_Truths

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noble_Eightfold_Path

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_Way

Claiming that Wikipedia has done a poor job explaining Buddhism in order to facilitate your assertion that Wikipedia has incorrectly categorized Ch'an/Zen as a school of Chinese Buddhism is intellectually dishonest.

You're choosing to ignore facts because they conflict with your misconceptions.

0
ewk•

You are mistaken.

Your wall of text doesn't prove your point, in fact, it sort of proves you wrong, since my wall of text about Zen Masters rejecting meditation is longer: https://www.reddit.com//r/zensangha/wiki/notmeditation

Your are further mistaken in that you apparently don't know what Buddhism is. Provide a catechism or choke on it.

Finally, it is essential to understand that Zen Masters often use concepts that religious people bring to a conversation. This doesn't mean that Zen Masters follow those religions. Huanbo says "no unalterable dharma", for example. Your quote of him supposedly talking about meditation isn't about meditation... you can tell because nowhere else in the book is meditation recommended.

You obviously aren't familiar with either "Buddhism" or Zen. I suggest you study more.

1
RottenCynicist•

You are mistaken.

I'm not. Saying "you are mistaken" without providing reasons why is a great way to make sure nobody takes you seriously.

Your wall of text doesn't prove your point, in fact, it sort of proves you wrong...

It does, you just don't want to accept things that conflict with your point of view.

... since my wall of text about Zen Masters rejecting meditation is longer: https://www.reddit.com//r/zensangha/wiki/notmeditation

Length =/= accuracy.

Your are further mistaken in that you apparently don't know what Buddhism is.

I'm actually very familiar with Buddhism.

Finally, it is essential to understand that Zen Masters often use concepts that religious people bring to a conversation.

No. Zen masters discuss Buddhist concepts because Zen is a school of Mahayana Buddhism.

This doesn't mean that Zen Masters follow those religions. Huanbo says "no unalterable dharma", for example.

You're right to an extent, in that Zen masters said the underlying fundamental truth of their teachings transcends all words and all doctrine, so no religious doctrine can be considered necessary or superior.

However, those were warnings intended to differentiate forms used as expedients when teaching from the underlying essence those forms are intended to reveal.

His exact words were "There's no unalterable dharma the Tathagata could've preached." Just by constructing his statement using Buddhist terminology, Huangbo made this a statement about Buddhism.

He also talks extensively about the Three Vehicles of Mahayana Buddhism, discusses teachings related to the bodhisattvas path, and regularly references Gautama the Buddha's teachings as his source.

Your quote of him supposedly talking about meditation isn't about meditation... you can tell because nowhere else in the book is meditation recommended.

Do you mean this quote?

  • "When you practice mind-control, sit in the proper position, stay perfectly tranquil, and do not permit the least movement of your minds to disturb you. This alone is what is called liberation." ~ Huangbo "On The Transmission of Mind" page 131

If so, what do you think he's talking about right there?

The claim that Huango doesn't allude to meditation elsewhere in his book is categorically false, but also irrelevant.

Not mentioning it elsewhere doesn't mean he isn't discussing it there.

You obviously aren't familiar with either "Buddhism" or Zen. I suggest you study more.

Really? You got that from a statement that short? Okay then, elaborate on what you feel I've gotten wrong.

For the record, I've studied quite a bit which is how I know for a fact that you're the one with no real knowledge on the subjects of Buddhism and Zen.

1
ewk•
  1. You aren't able to defend the translation "meditation".

  2. You aren't able to talk about the etymology of "Zen".

  3. You use mistranslated quotes out of context, and can't deal with quotes from elsewhere in that text that clearly disproves your interpretation.

  4. You say you know about Buddhism, but where is the catechism that distinguishes Buddhism as an actual religion. You don't seem to have it. You don't even seem to be aware of what the debate in your religion is...

1
mackowskiAmbassador from Planet Rhythm•

counter proposals to your definitions

  1. zen is a school of zen master teachings
  2. etymology is irrelevant
  3. zen masters do not emphasize meditation
  4. i agree buddhism likes meditation and says its central sometimes

zen is not a buddhist school, zen is a bunch of zen masters' output

thats the difference, youre trying to define it a priori rather than a posteriori

also why do you mention wikipedia and reliableness?
we cannot say X is true because the most reliable source said it is

2
RottenCynicist•

zen is not a buddhist school, zen is a bunch of zen masters' output

Those Zen master's output was almost exclusively discussing the doctrine of Mahayana Buddhism.

thats the difference, youre trying to define it a priori rather than a posteriori

The claim is evidenced by their use of Buddhist terminology and their concern with providing interpretations of Mahayana doctrine.

To say the claim isn't based on an objective observation of Zen teachings requires one never assessing those teachings objectively.

also why do you mention wikipedia and reliableness?
we cannot say X is true because the most reliable source said it is.

Using this logic, we can't say anything is "true". If we aren't going to consider the information provided by the most reliable sources and we aren't going to rely on the subject matter of the source material, what prevents anyone from asserting anything that supports their agenda without evidence?

2
mackowskiAmbassador from Planet Rhythm•

How can those zen masters be discussing Mahayana buddhism if Mahayana is also a discussion about buddhism? Also zen masters contradict Mahayana and almost every other Buddhism imo.

If Buddhism is the Buddha's original teaching, whatever that may have been, then buddhism might mean the object of Buddha's interest aka enlightenment, rather than his teachings.

1
RottenCynicist•

How can those zen masters be discussing Mahayana buddhism if Mahayana is also a discussion about buddhism? Also zen masters contradict Mahayana and almost every other Buddhism imo.

They took Mahayana doctrine such as the Path of Bodhisattva and the Three Vehicles, then further specified interpretations that are peculiar to Zen.

Are you asking how Mahayana Buddhism is differentiated from Theravada Buddhism?

If Buddhism is the Buddha's original teaching, whatever that may have been, then buddhism might mean the object of Buddha's interest aka enlightenment, rather than his teachings.

It often does, but not in the context of Zen.

"Buddha" is an honorific that means something along the lines of "Awakened One" or "Enlightened One". "Buddhism" roughly works out to "Teachings of Enlightenment/Awakening/The Enlightened One".

In Zen, all sentient beings are considered inherently enlightened. There's no distinction between "Enlightened" and "Ordinary".

Instead, Zen practictioners seek knowledge of self to improve their conscious connection with their essential Budh nature.

I think a few other Chinese schools of Buddhism also subscribe to Budh nature and inherent enlightenment, but I'm not 100% sure.

1
royalsaltmerchantSaltyZen•

Hui Neng defined Sitting Ch'an as: "In the midst of all good and evil, not a thought is aroused in the mind - this is called Sitting. Seeing into one's original nature, not being moved at all - this is called Ch'an."

Make of that what you will.

2
madewithsticks唯是一心•

Kill the Buddha.

1