Climb Ride, where am I wrong?

:health: Training

I Did CDE’s 60 minute climb ride today and thought it was great. However, one thing was nagging at me throughout the ride. At points she would state the level of exertion, saying this should feel like a 2 out of 5, or 3 out of 5. Peloton does not give a 5 level exertion chart, they do however have the pz graph which goes to 7. Using her ratios, 2 out of 5 would be about a 2.8 out of 7, and 3 out of 5 would be 60% which would equate to a 4.2 out of 7 (there were times when we were 4 out of 5 but I think you get the point) Doing the ride with these levels would have been difficult, however, would it have been the appropriate level if I were adhering to her instructions. I know “you do you” and the “levels are a suggestion”, I am just curious if I am overlooking something. If I did adhere to those levels, it probably would have been one of the most difficult rides I ever took. Also, I am 99% confident she was referring to perceived exertion and not referring to heart rate zones. Any ideas?

Posted Jan 5, 2020, 10:50 PM UTC

227
Vincedematta•

Don’t take this as condescending, but a climb ride being difficult would be perfectly normal. I would have taken her “3 out of 5” or “4 out of 5” as just that. I don’t think she was referring to any PZ or heart rate zones.

15
pheare_me•

Agreed. It sounds like it was just a scale with 1 being, I assume, ‘this is a breeze’ and 5 being ‘I can’t do this anymore’. Sort of like when you are asked by the doctor to rate your pain on a scale of 1-10 - everyone is respond differently based on their pain threshold.

This said, if the scale wasn’t defined during the class, it probably should have been.

6
drywallfan•

That does sound like Rate of perceived exertion (RPE) and it does not line up with powerzones like that. And the power you output at each level will change as you get tired. Like if you went to powerzone 5, it will feel good for a while, then get harder and harder and the RPE would slowly rise, while the powerzone would still be 5. Ever do powerzone 3 after a hard sprint? It's hard, but fresh zone 3 is pretty easy.

One of the benefits of RPE is that it changes with you. So if you are dehydrated or hot your heart rate might be higher but it may still feel the same (heart rate vs rpe), and your powerzones will shift as you get stronger or if you are not as recovered that day (powerzone vs rpe). So this was probably just an easy way for the instructor to give coaching without assuming everyone had a heart rate monitor on, and without everyone having their powerzones setup.

13
BBOverTheTop•

I don't want to come off an rude but I'm not sure what the confusion is here. If someone tells you to use a scale of 0-5 with 5 being the hardest anyone should be able to gauge that for themselves.

Maybe it's because my background in healthcare but when asking someone to rate their pain on a scale of 0-10, you shouldn't need pictures or a diagram to answer (although there are scales that do such).

13
SpinpapiOPSpinpapi:6::53::36::116::16::25:•

It’s been a while since I looked at the definitions of power zones, just confused myself and overthought it, as I said in the original post. All clear now, without the pics.

1
Cabut•

Yep, and she talked about this a lot during the ride. 5 being all out effort, 2 being a flat road you could feel but still just about talk freely, and a 3 where it was comfortable but you couldn't talk freely (or similar, it was a tough long ride a couple of days ago!).

Spinpapi, don't overthink it and listen to what she's saying - CDE is a no-nonsense, very practical instructor that will guide you through the whole thing.

1
Rocket80Rocket80:8::48::36::16::25::40:•

Heart rate zones are out of 5 - just use that. 🤷‍♂️

7
grandma-shark•

She uses that scale a lot. It’s more for the individual to know they should/shouldn’t be pushing as hard as possible. If you feel you are at a 5/5 and about to gas out and she says you should be at a 3/5 then you know you need to adjust something.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
SpinpapiOPSpinpapi:6::53::36::116::16::25:•

Ok, I get that, but wouldn’t a 4/5 on my scale equate to a 5.6 out of 7 on a power zone scale. If 7/7 is 100% of my effort, wouldn’t 4/5 be 80% of that amount?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0

Because 4/5 effort level is neither 80% of their peak power output nor 80% of their FTP; the scales don't work like that. 80% of their peak power is a huge amount that most people could only sustain for 3-10second. 80% of FTP is actually under what most people consider 4/5 effort level. 4/5 is typically used to indicate 87-93% FTP range.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5

Part of this is that there's a basic misunderstanding of power zones here. HR zones go over your limit because that's indicating an amount that's doable for a very short amount of time.

There's no easy way to convert 1-5 difficulty to 1-7 HR zones, because '6.5 hr zone' isn't useful, because zone 6 is saying something specific already.

I would run through the power zone FTP test and get a better, tangible understanding of your body. From there, you can make more informed choices. A 5 effort can mean over FTP, 4 can mean FTP, 3 10% below FTP, for example.

0
SpinpapiOPSpinpapi:6::53::36::116::16::25:•

I may not have been clear, but during the ride I was attempting to equate effort to power zones, not heart rate zones. So I guess my basic question was if my power zone max output at level 7 went to 700 output, should 4/5 effort or 80 percent effort begin at an output of 560?

1

My honest answer is that I don't think you're driving down a useful road trying to equate two things that aren't really meant to be converted to one another. An instructor might say 10/10 effort when they want you to give it everything you have for a few minutes. That doesn't mean they want or expect you to hold your 10s power for 2 minutes (which is physically impossible.) The scales mean different things and I don't think you'll find satisfying results trying to do what you're doing.

This is the RPE (rate of perceived exertion) scale. It's 1-10. Double the 1-5 that the instructor is saying and this is what they're referring to.

​

EDIT to specifically answer your question: No, a 4/5 effort is not 80% of your peak sprint power. It's not even really 80% of your FTP. Closer to 87-93%.

1
dogrelishspinnamon_buns:8::47::70::82::36::113:•

I had the same thoughts as you this am. lolol

What I decided/realized was that zones 1-5 are not really equally interspersed amongst the 1-7. I ended up hanging out in sweet spot for most of it, pushing to 4-5 for the sustained higher efforts and ending with a 6. It was a nice, high-output ride for me but I didn't feel wiped.

2
TheOriginalFadeDont_Fade:8::47::36::40::122::13:•

This one has been beaten pretty thoroughly with all of the great answers, I’ll just add that over the last few years, many of the coaches will go back and forth in their classes between perceived effort (like the 1-5 example from today) and the specific HRZ and PZ metrics called on the bike. Perceived effort is just subjective and changes...are you sore from the day before, hungover, just tired overall? Then adjust to whatever a 3 is on that particular day for you vs metrics based rides. I did both the 90 min PZ ride and then Andy Speers lower body yesterday so when I did the CDE ride this morning, my 3 was a stinky 3 for me but it was all I had in the tank.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
thatpaco•

I translate her 3 to roughly sweet spot. For me a 4 is upper PZ 4.

1
Vervain7Vervain7:9::c::47::106::80::38::25:•

I have taken many of her rides and many of her HRZ rides... I would use her numbers as HRZ numbers. She often describes what that zone should feel like . Unless you are properly tested for what your heart rate zones are the numbers are estimates and she mentions in her HRZ classes that if it says zone x but you feel so and so then you are not in zone x. Also, her climbs are difficult.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
KraphtyoneSpinotaur:8::51::36::117::16::25:•

Two caveats:

  1. This was not a PZ ride, so don’t use Power Zones. She is given a unit less scale, likely targeted at beginners, to help them quickly gauge effort. I wouldn’t read any more into it than that.

  2. It’s CDE. So.... yeah.

0†
flhx06Drew39:8::47::38::25::40::20:•

Two caveats:

“It’s CDE. So.... yeah.” 👍🏼

1
flhx06Drew39:8::47::38::25::40::20:•

I agree. Use a metric that the equipment puts out!

0
UninvitedCriticvelocat:9::c::41::36::25::40::20:•

While I didn't do the ride, I understand your concern. Why have Power and/or Heart Rate zones if you aren't going to use them? At least Matt and Denis's PZ rides are very specific about what zone to be in.

-1†
BBOverTheTop•

Why have Power and/or Heart Rate zones if you aren't going to use them?

Because they don't have to apply to every ride. Not everyone even uses a HRM anyway. It would be null and void to mention Power and/or HR Zones in rides that aren't designated as such.

11
Cabut•

It's a bit like the XKCD comic regarding coming up with a new standard... each coach does their own thing, similarly there's no prescribed rule as to whether coaches should mirror the arms section (i.e. move their left arm when you move your right) and if countdowns go on 1 or 0.

1