Pension and National Insurance advice sought after leaving academia (UK)

Last year I concluded my employment at a UK university and took up employment in the private sector. I have started to get my personal finances in order thanks to the good advice on here, but despite the ironic username I have two questions on which I'd appreciate advice.

​

Should I transfer my pension from USS to workplace scheme?

First, in 2016-2018 I contributed about 8% of my salary with an 18% contribution from my employer to the Universities Superannuation Scheme (USS) pension. A recent summary suggests that this amounts to a pension of about £800 per year in addition to a tax-free cash lump sum of several thousand and a small cash contribution in the investment builder.

Today I work in the private sector where I am a member of a workplace pension scheme with a nondescript provider about which I know little. I don't like having many accounts and worry about losing track of USS, so I requested a transfer out member schedule to consolidate my USS pension into the new pot.

However, these figures didn't match the above. This schedule quotes a yearly pension a quarter of the above and a Cash Equivalent Transfer Value (CETV) in the region of £20,000. I would like to keep things simple but am concerned that transferring out may be a bad idea if, for example, I lose my employer's contributions or the USS is particularly valuable.

Is it a good idea to transfer my USS pension into this workplace scheme?

​

Should I pay National Insurance contributions for incomplete years?

Second, I recently set up my personal online tax account. To my surprise, I saw that for National Insurance I had:

8 years when you did not contribute enough

These years cover when I was a full-time student (undergraduate and PhD). During these years I made NI contributions of £0-£250 from paid employment.

Voluntary contributions are possible within the next 3 years and would cost between £50-£800 for each incomplete year. I have read that these may be beneficial for those later in life or who don't expect to work the 30-something years needed to accrue the state pension, but that is not my case. I am young and, although I'd rather not, expect to be working to typical retirement.

Is it a good idea to make retrospective National Insurance contributions for my time at university?

Posted Jan 12, 2020, 11:21 AM UTC

1613
flawedleopard2•

USS is a defined benefit scheme. Generally it is considered a bad idea to transfer out of a defined benefit scheme due to the guaranteed nature of the benefit.

21
FinancialYearOP2•

Thank you. This is a useful point. !thanks

1
SuddenSituation5•

The current UK pension is based on 30 full years of full NI contributions. It's probably not worth contributing on that basis, and if the government decided to increase the number of years requirement, I can't imagine them doing so without a lot of warning. I had the same calculation to make after my PhD and decided it wasn't worth it - it was better to put that money into a personal pension for now.

I would not pull out of the defined benefit scheme - transferring the balance is risky, and you will probably get a lower return per year under whatever defined contribution scheme you are in. The USS is still very generous compared to DC schemes.

What contribution are you making in your new workplace scheme, and how does your employer match it? Usually it's expressed as a % of your salary. For me for e.g. it was 4%/6% but I upped it so my contribution was higher than the maximum match my employer would give - 6%/8%. Probably the best thing you can do is just increase your contribution here - don't forget that you get tax and NI relief on your pension if it is salary sacrificed.

3
IxionS3226•

The current UK pension is based on 30 full years of full NI contributions

35 years as of 2016, with some complexity around what years contributed before then are actually worth.

4
SuddenSituation5•

Sorry, you're right. Based on OPs age though, they'll have two full years from when they were 16-18 though, so it's really only 33 working years.

1
FinancialYearOP2•

Thanks for your reply. It's a good suggestion to look at it that way: what would retrospective NI payments earn versus increasing my workplace pension %. Appreciate it. !thanks

2
whataseeword•

I will be in this situation myself in regards to the USS in a year or so, so just commenting so I remember to look back at all the great advice later!

2
FinancialYearOP2•

Good luck. A reminder that decisions about salary sacrifice affect what you can do on leaving the scheme within two years.

1
beefygravy2•

Keep your USS pension! The £800 goes up with inflation (RPI I think). UCU have been on strike a lot recently, the one a couple of years back was partly because they were mulling changing to a defined benefit scheme and everyone would end up with less pension despite paying in the same

If you took the optional extra 1% (which was matched until last... April?) then that would be in a defined contribution scheme managed by USS and you might want to consider moving that to your new pension to minimise management fees. That would have been an extra pre-tax deduction from your payslip just below your normal pension

2
IxionS3226•

Is it a good idea to make retrospective National Insurance contributions for my time at university

As you've found the main reason filling NI gaps is worthwhile is if you are not on course to hit the 35 years required to maximise your state pension entitlement.

If, as you say, you are not concerned about this there is pretty much no benefit to making voluntary contributions.

1
FinancialYearOP2•

Thanks for your reply. u/SuddenSituation makes a good point about the return on investment relevant to your point. !thanks

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
davehadley_•

However, these figures didn't match the above. This schedule quotes a yearly pension a quarter of the above and a Cash Equivalent Transfer Value (CETV) in the region of £20,000.

Could you clarify this? Do you mean that your transfer quotation states a Defined Benefit entitlement that is different to the £800 that you expected? If so, I would query this....

1