Does the NSL have more new trains than the EWL?

I feel like a majority of NSL trains I take are the newer ones with the LCD screens that everyone hates, while almost every EWL train seems to be the first generation C151. Don't they share the same rolling stock? Am I the only one noticing this?

Posted Jan 13, 2020, 4:01 AM UTC

3712
B460•

I thought they rotated trains on the same line. Meaning you see the sane trains on the same lines.

19
rayyandamnstupid•

Most C151 trains (the first generation trains are on EWL while only some are on NSL. It used to be common on NSL but nowdays with new trains coming in, C151s are going to retire. In fact, it will retire this year.

Here are the lists of trains in NSL:

C151

C151A

C151B

C151C (The train with green and red lines as it's livery)

C651

C751B

and in the future, there will be a new train: CR151. The CR151, unlike other trains is created by Bombardier.

The EWL has the same trains EXCEPT C151C as it has not been released on ths EWL yet. Currently, there are only 2 trains of the C151C on the NSL. Other than that, it is the same.

(The info may not be correct, but I am sure it is.)

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
mfg092•

The trains that they made for the Brisbane network are not that good either. Loads of issues reported.

2
rayyandamnstupid•

On the TEL Open House, the train used is a Bombardier too. Not gonna lie, I think it is a train or track issue but the crossover was VERY hard. It felt like the train was breaking, so I can agree.

1
Xshadow1OP•

Does this have anything to do with the fact that the re-signalling was done on the NSL before the EWL? To my understanding the old signalling system doesn't work with C151B and C151C, so they had later EIS. Still doesn't explain how so few can be seen on the EWL given that the C651 has 19 trains in service to the C151B's 45, and I still see more of it on the EWL.

1
rayyandamnstupid•

I am not that sure on the train side as I am a bus enthusiast mostly but it may be related so? It depends on SMRT's deploys I guess. An example is that NSL has more C651s (example only) but it only deploys 15 trains out of 37 as the rest is in the depot.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
baiter101xdxd•

yea noticed this as well, maybe more of the new trains are stabled at Bishan depot so it’s deployed on NSL while the older ones are at Tuas so it’s deployed on EWL

1
supermomo1231randomguy•

The ones that I mostly see at clementi is the kawazaki trains

1
MyNameIsOnce•

I believe the old C151s and the new trains are all made by kawasaki

2
nlim2004•

they're doing this mainly because the newer KSF trains are fitted with the canberra station data on the panels above doors, but will pull in older trains if necessary

1
Xshadow1OP•

Yeah that makes sense. If the KHI trains are gonna be retired it doesn't make sense to update the STARiS 1.0 to include Canberra, so might as well use them on the EWL and stick a sticker there instead.

2