r/BMW•
TheMigDig

Any experiences with hardtop convertibles leaking? 2018 BMW 430i Convertible Base

Repair Help
Any experiences with hardtop convertibles leaking? 2018 BMW 430i Convertible Base

Posted Jan 13, 2020, 4:59 AM UTC

17
GTB7A4‘07 E93 328i, ‘07 E91 328i •

Try applying some Gummi Pflege to the rubber joints on the retractable hardtop and window moldings. It solved a similar problem on my E93, and is used by many BMW techs to better seal the top. You can get it at Amazon. https://www.amazon.com/nextzett-91480815-Gummi-Pflege-Rubber/dp/B075MKR3LR/ref=mp_s_a_1_2?

3
TheMigDigOP•

Short version: BMW dealership has been trying to fix minor leak on my hardtop convertible for 2 months out of last 9 months.

Any experience with this issue or how to get it escalated to the right folks for better results?

Long version:

Got the car in March 2019.

35k miles

I’m second owner.

Still under warranty until 2021 or 48k miles and at the rate I drive 2022 is more likely when I will hit those kinds of miles.

As soon as I got it, I noticed that when it rained there was a minor leak over the rear passenger door (if there was a door there).

It’s usually a few drops. In heavy rain, it pools into a larger spot but it never gets any other part of the car wet. In fact sometimes it will all evaporate and just leave a little whitish residue in the shape of the wetness before I notice. I have been able to catch it and take pics of it.

It’s been to the dealership 4 times since purchase to address this. Usually it takes a few (3-7) days and they give it back to me and I go until the next time I notice this.

Each time they tell me they fixed it and we shouldn’t be seeing each other due to this issue again. They must have felt pretty confident.

The repairs have ranged from adding waterproof sealant per specifications to the existing seals to replacing the entire set of seals by removing all those in that area.

This last time I dropped it off on Dec 18.

It’s going on for almost a month. They’ve given me courtesy vehicles and rentals when I’ve asked (I do have another BMW at home) because I don’t always need a 2nd car.

One of those weeks was over holiday and the other I was away on vacation so I didn’t really even check in with them. Now I’m checking in and they tell me it is still leaking.

The reason for my post is to ask if anyone has had experience with this type of situation. I specifically sought a hardtop to avoid leaking/soft top issues.

Is this expected from most convertibles? Is there a way to get this in front of the right folks for a solution sometime soon? Like I said, I don’t always need a 2nd car but I got this more a a recreational ride for my family and I to enjoy and it’s been at the dealer 2 out of 9 months I’ve owned it.

As I write this I can’t help feel like an entitled douche whining about how to solve one of top ten 1st world problems, but then again it’s wouldn’t be the first time a BMW driver has been called a douche.

Thanks for reading.

1
xlifewithoutshamex•

I don’t have an answer but I wouldn’t feel like a douche especially for a newer car under warranty. It shouldn’t be leaking. I’d be annoyed too.

1
Chicago_Jayhawke70 X5 4.8•

A leak like that is like when someone says there is a rattle in the dash--the tech drives it, can't duplicate it, so they try to do the typical diagnosis/repair. But unless they can exactly replicate it, they are just doing what they can in hopes it goes away. Is there a way you can bring it in right before it rains? You are entitled to have them fix it. If you feel you are getting the run-around, contact BMW and they will contact the dealer (no dealer wants BMW to be calling them). Or try another dealer if possible.

1
TheMigDigOP•

Thanks.

The thing is that they say they can duplicate it since when I ask for an update, they tell me that they tried to fix it but they still detected a leak.

I don’t think they are giving me the run around, but I don’t think they are prioritizing it. 25 days minus the holidays off seems like too long not to have this solved.

I want to at least talk to the service manager before I reach out to anyone outside their dealership.

I’ll keep your advise in mind if that doesn’t help.

1
Zombieslay3r002008 E93 328i / 2013 F10 528i•

Yes. My 3 series hardtop barley leaks at times it’s just how they are i’ve come to accept it. If doesn’t really bother me as it’s so little water.

1
TheMigDigOP•

Well now I’m losing faith. The service guy is saying they can’t get it to seal and now he’s saying that they think it was in an accident.

Seems like BS.

No record of accident and no evidence of it either.

He said “BMW engineers” are going to take a look.

The funny thing is that when I first brought it in he said “wow I’ve never seen a convertible leak before”.

Then after the 2nd time it was we walked by an M convertible and he said “they all end up leaking and we fix them.”

Now it sounds like they are trying to scapegoat the previous owner or me with a BS claim it might have been in an accident.

I will ask for evidence of an accident, but to be honest I’ve lost faith and trust in these folks.

Any other options?

1